Ranking the farm systems position by position: Catcher
Using John's rankings, I decided to start ranking reach system position by position starting with catcher.
1.Blue Jays
Travis D'Arnaud(B+)
AJ Jimenez(B-)
Carlos Perez(C+)
Santiago Nessy(Other)
Jays have three strong prospects in full season ball and a fourth with some potential.
2.Mariners
Jesus Montero(A)
Tyler Marlette(C+)
John Hicks(Other)
Jack Marder(Other)
Montero is such a big prospect that he puts the Mariners in second on this list.
3.Yankees
Gary Sanchez(B+)
Austin Romine(C+)
JR Murphy(C+)
Isaias Tejada(Other)
Sanchez has some elite potential and both Romine and Murphy are strong prospects as well.
4.Reds
Devin Mesoraco(A-)
Tucker Barnhart(C)
Mesoraco is one of the best prospects in the game and that puts the Reds high on the list.
5.Padres
Yasmani Grandal(B+)
Austin Hedges(B-)
Jason Hagerty(Other)
Grandal is finally out of the shadow of Mesoraco. It's likely that he's going to be a strong regular in San Diego. Hedges was a top draft choice last year and Hagerty is a potential backup that doesn't get much hype.
6.Red Sox
Ryan Lavarnway(B)
Blake Swihart(B-)
Christian Vazquez(C+)
Lavarnway can really mash, and already has some big league success. Swihart is another top draft choice from last year, and Vazquez also has potential.
7.A's
Derek Norris(B)
Josh Donaldson(C+)
Max Stassi(Other)
Beau Taylor(Other)
Norris is a three outcome hitter, but is still a pretty solid prospect. Donaldson is a potential backup that gets overlooked by many. Stassi is a former top prospect who has seen his stock fall a bit.
8.Giants
Tommy Joseph(B-)
Andrew Susac(B-)
Hector Sanchez(C+)
Alex Burg(Other)
Defensive questions follow Joseph, but the youngster can has good pop in his bat. You also can't forget about top draft prospect Susac or Sanchez, who broke out last year.
9.Rockies
Willin Rosario(B-)
Jordan Pacheco(Other)
Will Swanner(Other)
Rosario is among the top catching prospects in baseball, although his stock has fallen from a year ago. Pacheco could end up at third base, but could be in the big leagues this year. Swanner is far away, but he has big power in his bat.
10.Braves
Christian Bethancourt(B-)
Evan Gattis(Other)
Bethancourt is a bit of an enigma- all talent, little production. Still he's very young and took a step forward last year in Low-A. Gattis is older but shouldn't be written off after a monster year last year.
11.Phillies
Sebastian Valle(B-)
Valle is a strong prospect, but not elite. The Phills fall to #11 because they don't have anyone other than him on John's list.
12.Indians
Chun Chen(C+)
Jake Lowery(C+)
Eric Haase(Other)
Alex Lavisky(Other)
Chen is an all-bat prospect, but has a strong enough bat to be a contributor. Lowery is a solid prospect on his own, though he doesn't get much attention. Lavisky is quite raw, but he has some real potential.
13.Rangers
Jorge Alfaro(C+)
Tomas Telis(Other)
Yefry Castillo(Other)
Personally I like the Rangers better than the Indians, but per John's rankings I had to use this order. Alfaro is a potential All-Star, but he is only in short-season ball. Telis is another kid with some potential buried in a system full of kids with potential.
14.Rays
Oscar Hernandez(C+)
Lucas Bailey(Other)
Justin O'Conner(Other)
Stephen Vogt(Other)
Hernandez is a youngster who put up big numbers last year in the VSL, but we need to see him in America before ranking him higher. Bailey and O'Conner were each high draft picks, but have struggled to adjust to the minors- although the same can be said about Devin Mesoraco two years ago.
15.Marlins
JT Realmuto(B-)
Austin Barnes(Other)
Austin Brice(Other)
Jobduan Morales(Other)
Kyle Skipworth(Other)
Realmuto had a strong season last year in his first year with a full-season club. None of the others really strike you as true prospects, although despite not producing, Skipworth has some talent.
16.Tigers
James McCann(C+)
Rob Brantly(Other)
McCann was a solid college draft choice last year, and Brantly was a pick two years ago.
17.Pirates
Tony Sanchez(C+)
Ramon Cabrera(Other)
After a down year, Sanchez saw his stock drop significantly. Cabrera is small, but hit well in High-A last year.
18.White Sox
Kevan Smith(C+)
Mike Blanke(Other)
Smith, the former Pitt football player, should move quickly through the system due to being an older prospect. Blanke is a bit of a sleeper.
19.Dodgers
Gorman Erickson(C+)
Tim Federowicz(Other)
Pratt Maynard(Other)
Chris O'Brien(Other)
Erickson isn't very well known, but is still solid. Federowicz is a defensive catcher who could be a top backup. Both Maynard and O'Brien were highly thought of last year in the draft.
20.Royals
Cam Gallagher(C+)
Gallagher was a big bonus high school draftee, but has some real potential.
21.Cubs
Wellington Castillo(C+)
Neftali Rosario(Other)
Castillo would be best as a backup, but could eventually get a chance to start.
22.Cardinals
Cody Stanley(C+)
Tony Cruz(Other)
Robert Stock(Other)
None of the Cards have much chance of being more than a backup.
23.Nationals
David Freitas(C+)
Freitas doesn't really impress me as a "C+" prospect.
24.Astros
Chris Wallace(C)
I like Wallace at a "C" grade.
25.Orioles
Gabriel Lino(C)
Lino has some potential.
26.Angels
Carlos Ramirez(C)
Abel Baker(Other)
Neither of the Angels prospects excite me.
27.Brewers
Martin Maldonado(Other)
Maldonado has a better shot to be a big league backup than Hermann, so the Brewers rank a bit higher.
28.Twins
Chris Hermann(Other)
Hermann isn't likely to make the bigs.
t-29.Diamondbacks
NONE
No catching prospects mentioned by John.
t-29.Mets
NONE
No catching prospects mentioned by John.
24 comments
|
Add comment
|
0 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
Cubs
- To suggest that Castillo would be best as a backup seems to imply that that is the extent of his capability. I’m not sure that is fair. Here’s a fairly solid defensive catcher, who has the potential to be better defensively (but albeit, is still a bit inconsistent), who has 15 HR power. He’ll strike out some, and he doesn’t portend to hit for a high average, but that’s better potential than a backup catcher.
- There were some disappointing reports on Rosario from instructs, I believe, but he’s young and far away.
- a guy who profiles as a backup backstop would be Steve Clevenger. Solid defensively, will put the bat on the ball and make good contact.
- system has some a lot of questions at catcher. Marck Malave was the big international signing, but can he stick at catcher? Micah Gibbs has to hit … something … to have a shot. Yaniel Cabezas is solid defensively, but like Gibbs, has questions on the bat. Luis Flores has had non-baseball concerns. That said, with Castillo/Clevenger at the top, the youngsters have time to develop.
by toonsterwu on Jan 24, 2026 3:43 PM EST reply actions
Castillo
I wouldn’t be surprised to see Castillo start, but think he’s most likely going to be a backup. Especially if the good version of Soto shows up.
by mattp31 on Jan 24, 2026 4:07 PM EST via mobile up reply actions
if you are talking 2012
sure. Soto will be the starter most of the year. If a team needs a catcher at the deadline, wouldn’t surprise me if the Cubs shopped him.
by toonsterwu on Jan 24, 2026 8:31 PM EST up reply actions
Curious
Where would the Mariners rank without Montero? Cause that’s where they should rank with him.
"I feel sorry for people who don't drink. When they wake up in the morning, that's as good as they're going to feel all day."
-Frank Sinatra
by Kerm on Jan 24, 2026 4:40 PM EST reply actions
Yeah
but if there were a top DH prospect list…
I know this list was based of Sickels’ grades so I really can’t argue too much. I will say, however, that I expect a big bounceback year from Sanchez. For one thing, his defense was good all season. He was excellent blocking pitches, he improved his game calling and his pop times were good all year. Offensively, his BB and K numbers stayed solid. His problem (and it wasn’t a little one) is that he couldn’t hit the ball with any authority, evidenced by a disastrous .077 ISO. However, I think the broken jaw Sanchez suffered after being hit in the face by a pitch in 2010 could explain for this. Sanchez was unable to get back to his playing weight before 2011 started. He played the entire season between 10-15 pounds lighter than 2010. Once the season began, he was unable to build the necessary muscle back, although that’s not surprising. Players rarely are able to gain weight in-season. Since Sanchez never had great power, losing what he did have seriously hindered his ability to drive the ball. Yes, this is nothing but speculation and maybe I just have my rose-colored glasses on, but I expect Sanchez to be in Pittsburgh to stay by September 2012.
by KentuckyPirate on Jan 24, 2026 5:55 PM EST up reply actions
I don't know if you could say that.
Z said on the call yesterday that he will get every opportunity to catch and he still is considered a prospect.
by tarheels24 on Jan 24, 2026 5:55 PM EST up reply actions
Yeah, but it's cool to call Montero a DH only even though none of us has seen him play catcher consistently.
by PissedMick on Jan 24, 2026 6:30 PM EST up reply actions
It's not like
people are making this up and it’s not limited to posters either. Sickels has made it clear he has serious concerns about Montero’s catching ability as well:
Any doubts about Montero center on his glove. He has a strong throwing arm, but his throwing mechanics are less than ideal and he’s not especially effective against basestealers. He caught just 20% this year for Scranton, and 21% in his minor league career. Other aspects of his defense have gradually improved. He’s steadily cut down on passed balls (15 last year but just seven this year) and errors, and he has improved his mobility behind the plate. However, despite the improvement in his statistics, most scouts still rate his defense as mediocre at best, and as he gets older what flexibility he has will likely decline. There has been some talk of making him a first baseman, but he’s never played the position and that won’t help him much in New York, anyhow. In the end, Montero will likely spend much of his career at DH…
by KentuckyPirate on Jan 24, 2026 6:49 PM EST up reply actions
Well
Clearly John and the scouts he talked haven’t seen him catch consistently enough.
"I feel sorry for people who don't drink. When they wake up in the morning, that's as good as they're going to feel all day."
-Frank Sinatra
by Kerm on Jan 24, 2026 7:35 PM EST via mobile up reply actions
I agree with this.
I’m waiting till we get a better read on his defense.
by mr. maniac on Jan 24, 2026 10:52 PM EST up reply actions
Montero
I live in Scranton, PA- home of the Yankees AAA team. I have seen plenty of Montero the last two years.
He’s not awful behind the plate but he is on the borderline between bad and well below average. As he ages especially I think he’ll grow a bit and slow down, further hindering his ability to stay back there.
He can catch right now for a non-contender like Seattle. He may be able to stay there a few years, but he will ultimately move out from behind the plate. If he was with a contender like the Yankees, I don’t think he’d be a good fit behind the plate for any extended period.
by mattp31 on Jan 25, 2026 9:06 AM EST via mobile up reply actions
This seems to be roughly the consensus on his defense.
Along with questionable D, his bat’s probably way too good to risk injury/wear and tear behind the plate.
"I feel sorry for people who don't drink. When they wake up in the morning, that's as good as they're going to feel all day."
-Frank Sinatra
by Kerm on Jan 25, 2026 9:53 AM EST up reply actions
Some We Like...
You mention Chris Wallace, but you left off a couple of catchers we find at least interesting:
Austin Hedges C/SD (may not hit enough but fine defense)
Christian Vazquez C/BOS (looks very good for his level)
Bryce Massarini C/COL (nice bat)
by Hairylady on Jan 24, 2026 5:40 PM EST reply actions
He mentioned Hedges
Noticed it right away before any posts were made.
by auclairkeithbc on Jan 24, 2026 7:15 PM EST up reply actions
Vazquez
I also mentioned him. Masssarini was skipped because he was either not listed by John or I may have missed him if he was listed. I only went with guys John listed and based everything around that.
by mattp31 on Jan 25, 2026 9:09 AM EST via mobile up reply actions
Well done.
I want to see the other lists so keep ‘em coming (I sort of wish that John distinguished CF prospects from corner OF prospects and starting pitcher prospects from reliever prospects as that would make for more interesting reading, though yes it can be difficult to forecast such a player’s ultimate role as a big leaguer).
I noticed that you missed Alberto Cordero (I like him) and Michael Perez from the Mets’ and Diamondbacks’ Others lists, respectively. Why in the world are the Cardinals still trying to develop Robert Stock as a catcher? Does he no longer possess the velocity to pitch?
by reillocity on Jan 24, 2026 5:54 PM EST reply actions
typo
Make that Albert Cordero (though Alberto Cordero admittedly has a much better ring to it).
by reillocity on Jan 24, 2026 5:57 PM EST up reply actions
D-backs did just draft a fourth round catcher
He’s a C-grade at this point, but he’d show up on most teams’ lists. Michael Perez.
Founder and Chairman of the Send Dan Some Pizzeria Bianco Commission (SDSPBC). SDSPBC is a totally, definitely for-profit organization.
by Dan Strittmatter on Jan 24, 2026 7:08 PM EST reply actions
Good compliation
Like the info in one place.
by McCutchenIsTheTruth on Jan 24, 2026 7:20 PM EST reply actions
Rangers
Should probably be higher if you add on Deglan and the recently-converted Mendonca.
The Dodgers won't win a playoff series until the Cool-a-Coo returns.
by mckeeno on Jan 24, 2026 10:20 PM EST reply actions
Mendonca doesn't add much
he’s a real long shot with the bat and who knows how he’ll take to catcher. Deglan, though is a real prospect.
Some see a glass half empty, some a glass half full. I see a glass that's twice as big as it needs to be. - George Carlin
by t ball on Jan 25, 2026 1:38 AM EST up reply actions
Rangers
I missed Deglan on the list. I completed this at work, so I was bound to miss someone on the others list.
I read about the Mendonca move an hour or two after I posted. I’m not sure how I feel about his chances. I do like him though after seeing him a few times in college
by mattp31 on Jan 25, 2026 9:16 AM EST via mobile up reply actions
Something to say? Choose one of these options to log in.

- » Create a new SB Nation account
- » Already registered with SB Nation? Log in!

by mattp31 on 











