Navigation: Jump to content areas:


Pro Quality. Fan Perspective.
Login-facebook
Around SBN: Lionel Messi On The Cover Of TIME Worldwide, Except In USA

Suggestion Thread

With the organization ranking list done, my next "long term" projects are an integrated Top 100 list and beginning my 2012 draft coverage. The Top 100 list will come out in mid-to-late February, and the draft stuff takes time to research. I haven't focused on the draft yet. Matt will be posting quite a bit about it but I need to do my own research as well.

In the meantime, I am working on ideas for additional features. I have some things in mind suggested by readers. In no particular order, I am planning

*Anthony Gose vs. Starling Marte Smackdown
*Cheslor Cuthbert vs. Miguel Sano Smackdown
*Prospect Retros/Historical Prospects (make some suggestions)
*Front office interviews
*My favorite Grade C prospects

Feel free to suggest more ideas.

Tweet Comment 50 comments  |  Add comment  |  0 recs  | 

Do you like this story?

Comments

Display:

2011 Late Round Draft favorites

Perhaps an article with help from the new members of your favorite players from the 2011 draft that were taken in the 10th round or later.

by ryancsablotny on Jan 25, 2026 2:07 PM EST reply actions  

Great idea

Yes, a draft sleeper article would be fun.

by philc423 on Jan 26, 2026 9:56 AM EST up reply actions  

Historical Prospect

Would love to see my all-time favorite failed prospect: Chris Snelling.

by robertgold on Jan 25, 2026 2:08 PM EST reply actions  

Posada

I think a piece on Posada would be great.

by MikeyMarchMadness on Jan 25, 2026 2:09 PM EST reply actions  

NCAA

I’d like to see a list of MLB prospects in college ball sorted by team or conference, even if it’s just a list of names with position and a range of possible draft rounds.

Fight for licensed online poker in 30 seconds. Take part in the daily action plan!

https://www.facebook.com/pages/Poker-Players-Alliance-Daily-Action-Plan/240644152648049

twitter @PPADailyAction

by rwperu34 on Jan 25, 2026 2:46 PM EST reply actions  

Not all

of these guys are MLB prospects, but are prospects of some nature. It also shows future commitments of current HS prospects coming up in the draft as well.

LINK

by Matt Garrioch on Jan 25, 2026 3:06 PM EST up reply actions  

Another great idea

This would be awesome to see. I was hoping mlb would go to a hockey style draft when they re-did the draft. I think it would be great for college baseball and it’s fans to have players drafted and under control of major league teams playing college ball. This would make the draft “truer”, if that is a word. Players would be drafted on talent. We would not see 10 of the top 200 high school prospects going completely undrafted each year if mlb clubs can keep the rights to players for 3 years.

The mlb club could sign the player after their soph or junior seasons. If they didn’t sign as juniors, they would go back in the draft as a junior, then also be able to be drafted as a senior if they didn’t sign.

by philc423 on Jan 26, 2026 10:13 AM EST up reply actions  

I like the idea of interviews

If you could get more than just FO guys, maybe a coach, strength and conditioning guys, field care guys, you name it.

Also like *My favorite Grade C prospects that idea.

Scouting the Royals
Royals Prospects

by 306008 on Jan 25, 2026 2:46 PM EST reply actions  

This may be too large a project, but it's something I've been interested in.

Historically, what percentage of A prospects develop into All Stars? B prospects? C Prospects?

I arbitrarily chose “All Star” as a measure of “star level player” because I’m not sure what other easy way there would be to do it.

Maybe you could just look at the last few years and see, which might limit the scope and make this a doable project.

A pirate I was meant to be!
"You say you're nasty pirates,
scheming, thieving, bad bushwackers?
From what I've seen I tell you
You're not pirates, you're just slackers!"

by Zach (maestro876) on Jan 25, 2026 2:50 PM EST reply actions  

If there was a way to access John’s old lists, I would be very interested in researching this. But with the SBN search function on the futz, is there any other way to view the old lists? Short of John personally emailing them to the researcher.

Twitter Blog
"I never argue with people who say baseball is boring because baseball is boring. Except, suddenly, it isn't. And that's what makes it great."
-Joe Posnanski

by free f.p. #14 on Jan 26, 2026 4:01 AM EST up reply actions  

Ben Petrick Retro

I remember him being talked about as a great prospect, but I believe I was in 7th grade when he made his Major League debut. I definitely had his rookie card. His fight with Parkinson’s is very sad, but do people overrate how big a prospect he was to make the tragedy even greater?

Here’s a link to a recent ESPN feature on him:
http://sports.espn.go.com/espn/eticket/story?page=120106/BenPetrick

by KDH2011 on Jan 25, 2026 3:04 PM EST reply actions  

Historical prospect retro idea

Joe Nathan?

Mourning Guy Carbonneau...
Royals obscure player to watch in ST: Lenny DiNardo

by playingwithfire on Jan 25, 2026 3:15 PM EST reply actions  

Nevermind, done in 2007

Yusmeiro Petit? Just to do a bust for a change.

Mourning Guy Carbonneau...
Royals obscure player to watch in ST: Lenny DiNardo

by playingwithfire on Jan 25, 2026 3:16 PM EST up reply actions  

Electronic .pdfs

Is it still possible to order an electronic version of the 2012 book?

by therichardandmartin on Jan 25, 2026 3:19 PM EST reply actions  

Yes, absolutely at johnsickels.net

They will go out this weekend

by John Sickels on Jan 25, 2026 3:37 PM EST up reply actions  

Thanks, John.

I’m a longtime site reader and just made my first purchase of the book proper. Looking very forward to receiving and reading it. Really appreciate all your work.

by therichardandmartin on Jan 26, 2026 11:17 AM EST up reply actions  

Favorites

maybe a favorite/most likely to succeed player from each round of the draft rounds 1-50 starting with the 2012 draft…it would be a fun exercise and it would keep draft content pouring in.

Ride the tiger...You can see his stripes but you know he's clean.

by James Westfall on Jan 25, 2026 3:35 PM EST reply actions  

early for it

But I’d be interested in a lot of draft coverage, especially comparing the 2012 draft with the 2011 draft; maybe if all the players were pooled into one draft, where each one would go. I’m working on a Shadow Nationals farm system, so I’m hoping to get some breadth of knowledge about the draft class.

by Jaumiusk on Jan 25, 2026 3:46 PM EST reply actions  

This would be fun

I am in a dynasty league. When you first draft players for a dynasty league, you draft from all players on 40 man rosters, then you draft from all players in the minor leagues.

That minor league draft is like putting all players drafted in the several years into one big group, plus all foreign prospects into that same group, and seeing where each one would go.

It is a ton of fun. It involves many aspects of being a real major league general manager. And each year you get to do a FYPD to divide up all the new talent.

You want to start out with 24-26 teams, and try to keep 24 franchise’s going. And charge a decent entry fee so you only get serious owners.

by philc423 on Jan 26, 2026 10:45 AM EST up reply actions  

Player comparables - useful to some, misleading to others

Faced with the choice between changing one's mind and proving that there is no need to do so, almost everyone gets busy on the proof. -John Kenneth Galbraith, economist (1908-2006)

by chewbalka on Jan 25, 2026 5:21 PM EST reply actions  

C level prospects

I think that this idea could be fascinating.

It seems to me that there are guys who have the potential to be bigger prospects (or to be good MLB players) who are C level prospects early in their careers. This definitely qualifies as the diamond in the rough type of ‘prospecting.’

by MADness on Jan 25, 2026 5:58 PM EST reply actions  

Darvish v Bauer v Bundy

Fantasy Question Alert, feel free to disregard cause thats not what this post is about but im completely torn.

Two of the three are going to get to me in my fantasy dynasty draft, Team is built to win now, who would you take?

For in depth fantasy analysis be sure to visit the Hawk Fantasy Sports site @ www.HawkBall.com

by PHGold09 on Jan 25, 2026 6:13 PM EST reply actions  

Prospects in Trade Retro

Prospect retro reviews of some of the more memorable trades in recent memory. For example, the Varitek/Lowe for Slocumb deal.

by ThomasG on Jan 25, 2026 6:18 PM EST reply actions  

What about an article about if Varitek would have signed with Twins?

The 1990’s would have been different for the Twins.

by philc423 on Jan 26, 2026 10:46 AM EST up reply actions  

Top Ten by Positions

through the years to give you a retrospective of who from there made it and who didn’t.

by smokeymcpots on Jan 25, 2026 6:31 PM EST reply actions  

top blocked prospects

Profile what guys are blocked and what teams make sense as trade destinations…

-peter

by PeterF on Jan 25, 2026 6:37 PM EST via iPhone app reply actions  

Top International players that can be signed now. Top International players that could be signed July 2. How do they compare talent wise?

Bring back the Pac-10!!!

by calas on Jan 25, 2026 7:00 PM EST reply actions  

This.

Most arguments are really about context.

by SheaWasBettor21 on Jan 26, 2026 6:34 AM EST up reply actions  

There was a question in the AQA thread a while back regarding shortstops

I wouldn’t mind a comprehensive look at the teams you think have the most depth at the position

Just don't piss her off, otherwise she'll get all Dien Bien Phu up in your Boxer Rebellion - caknuck

btho Iowa State

by MonkeyEpoxy on Jan 25, 2026 7:39 PM EST reply actions  

A few ideas...

top ten top 100 high upside prospects
top ten top 100 high floor prospects

i know you don’t like doing mlb comparisons, i know they are tough, but i and others would LOVE to hear mlb comparisons for perhaps your top hitters and pitchers lists? i really think everyone on here would be sooooooooo interested in this, if there really is no comparison u could always give us a hybrid comparison like “a cross between carl crawford and jacoby ellsbury” or something like that

"Hello. My name is Matthew Berry. I am on a Fantasy Jihad. Prepare to die!"

by Dominatio on Jan 25, 2026 9:13 PM EST reply actions  

Well

They would have to be high upside/low floor prospects, and high floor/low upside prospects, to avoid the best of the best that count in both categories. And maybe if you listed your favorites instead of “the best” it might be less confusing.

by auclairkeithbc on Jan 25, 2026 11:09 PM EST up reply actions  

systems, park effects

I’d love to see something longer comparing systems: which systems seem to develop what kinds of players better, or something like that.

I’d also be curious to read about how park effects play a role in the development of players. Is it a big hindrance for a system to have a park/league that hugely inflates/deflates offense? I feel like I’ve read that some teams are more likely to have a player skip a level if that affiliate plays in a bandbox, or things like that.

by Ben Hall on Jan 25, 2026 9:16 PM EST reply actions  

bust/success rates

Might also be too big of a project, but I’d be very interested in something about how prospects of various grades have turned out. Are the top pitching prospects still less valuable than B+ hitters?

I also really like the favorite C+ prospect idea.

Not actually affiliated with whygavs.

by WHYG Zane Smith on Jan 25, 2026 10:39 PM EST reply actions  

well three-ways are more difficult

In baseball anyway. In other contexts they are fun. so I hear.

by John Sickels on Jan 26, 2026 10:53 AM EST up reply actions   2 recs

Depends

Can’t speak for others but doesn’t that depend on the make-up?

by odbsol on Jan 26, 2026 11:13 AM EST up reply actions  

Not sure if this has been done already...

…But a review of the 2005 draft, with preliminary grades of the 1st round draftees from the begining, their road traveled, and where they are at presently. Would be an interesting parallel of what to expect from this years 2011 class of draftees.

by Bulldawg5 on Jan 26, 2026 8:09 AM EST reply actions  

Best Tools/Skills

Might be neat to see lists of maybe the top ten prospects for each tool/skill, best power prospects, pure hitters, runners etc.

by Trashman on Jan 26, 2026 8:43 AM EST reply actions  

I'd love a

RIght direction/Wrong direction analysis by organization.

and what about a breakdown of organizations by philosophy? and it could be fun to try and come up with some sort of ranking based on some combo of philosophy and results. We have the rankings based on farm sys talent, but that’s at this particular slice in time. If we could go further and rank orgs by FO philosophy and how that translates to success at the big club. Admittedly, could be beyond the scope here.

by ThnkGoodnessforHowieRose on Jan 26, 2026 11:18 AM EST reply actions  

Top 25

Top 25 and under sort of thing? I know a few other sites do it, and its not just minor leaguers, but I would love to see the way you would rank the top 25 under 25. Dont think youve ever done anything like it.

by CaptainHowdy on Jan 26, 2026 11:46 AM EST reply actions  

Top 10 most lopsided propsect trades?

Might be slightly off topic..

by diehardtwinsfan on Jan 26, 2026 11:53 AM EST reply actions  

Given our two new HoF inductees

Perhaps a piece ranking who you think of current prospects the top five most likely to be comparable to Barry Larkin and Ron Santo. Obviously, comparing any prospect to a HoFer is a stretch, but I think it would generate some good debate.

by cookiedabookie on Jan 26, 2026 1:00 PM EST reply actions  

2012 All Quad A Team

Now that would be fun to figure out…Clint Robinson has to be on that team somewhere!

by Hawkewind on Jan 26, 2026 2:47 PM EST reply actions  


User Tools

Minor League Ball: Where the Future of Baseball is Discussed

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recommended FanPosts

Hal2_small
2012 Average Farm System Rankings
Headshot_small
2012 Farm System Rankings based on John's individual grades

Recent FanPosts

Small
Project Prospect Top 25
Small
Community Positional Prospect #55 RUNOFF
Small
Overall Community Prospect #79
Small
Community Pitching Prospect #54
Small
Ranking the farm systems position by position: First Base
March2111_084_small
2012 Minor League Ball Fantasy League has Openings
Small
MLB.com Top 100 Prospects
Small
New Deep 30 Team Dynasty League
Small
Community Positional Prospect #55
Small
Mike Olt

+ New FanPost All FanPosts >

Baseball Nation Recent Stories

Second baseman Omar Vizquel of the Chicago White Sox throws to first to complete a double play after forcing out Bobby Abreu of the Los Angeles Angels of Anaheim at Angel Stadium in Anaheim California.  (Photo by Stephen Dunn/Getty Images)

Is Omar Vizquel A Hall Of Famer?

CLEVELAND, OH: Juan Pierre #1 of the Chicago White Sox dives to miss a close pitch during the third inning against the Cleveland Indians at Progressive Field. (Photo by Jason Miller/Getty Images)

Phillies Reportedly To Sign Juan Pierre

Ryan Theriot of the St. Louis Cardinals fields a ground ball against the Chicago Cubs at Busch Stadium in St. Louis, Missouri.  (Photo by Jeff Curry/Getty Images)

Ryan Theriot Signs With Giants

More from Baseball Nation >


Managers

March2111_084_small John Sickels

Jeri_avatar_small mssickels

Authors

Headshot_small dougdirt

Mblpglogo_small Matt Garrioch

Small SethSpeaks

Osnation2_small Jordan Tuwiner

Img00006-20101226-1702_small Ray Guilfoyle

Lax-xl_small Marisa Ingemi

Small Marc Hulet

Moderators

Small mrkupe


Site Meter