It seems like overall people were happy with separating the lists into a positional list and a pitching list, then combining them into an overall list. I am going to get this started, and I'll take some type of ownership over this list, but if others want to chip in, or if people want someone else to take over, that is fine with me. We've been talking too long about getting this started, so I figured I might as well do it.
I believe we used 7% as the level a prospect must achieve if he's to remain on the list but certainly this can be tweaked. Anyone who feels this percentage should be changed, please mention it in the discussion. Make sure you suggest potential new candidates/testers as well, so we can keep a full list to vote on.
We will be using the +1 system. If there is a close vote, we'll do a tie-breaker. I feel strongly that we should only have heads up tie-breakers, not 3 way ones, but I'll do it however the majority thinks is best.
Without further delay, let's start with these 10:
Matt Moore, Julio Teheran, Shelby Miller, Tyler Skaggs, Jameson Taillon, Jacob Turner, Drew Pomeranz, Gerrit Cole, Trevor Bauer, Dylan Bundy