Prospect of the Day: Andy Dirks, OF, Detroit Tigers
Prospect of the Day: Andy Dirks, OF, Detroit Tigers
Rookie outfielder Andy Dirks of the Detroit Tigers is holding his own in the Show so far, rapidly making the transition from unheralded sleeper prospect to major league contributor. What does the future hold? Let's take a look.
Andy Dirks was a successful college player at Wichita State University, hitting .320/.406/.400 with 19 steals as a junior in 2007, followed by a more robust .388/.498/.632 with 11 homers and 26 steals in 2008 as a senior. Although not a big guy at 6-0, 190, he was a good athlete with average tools across the board and a strong performance record, so it was a bit surprising that he wasn't drafted at all until his senior year. The Tigers took him in the eighth round, signing him for $35,000. He got into just 13 games after being drafted, though he went 15-for-44 (.341) for the GCL Tigers and West Michigan.
Dirks began 2009 with Lakeland in the Florida State League, where he hit .330/.410/.379 with 10 steals in 27 games. This earned him a rapid promotion to Double-A Erie, where he hit .255/.323/.349 with 11 steals in 98 games. This wasn't too impressive, though Tigers officials still felt he was a sleeper. Returning to Erie in '10, he hit .278/.342/.425 with 11 homers and 19 steals in 98 more games, then a sharp .375/.398/.648 in 22 games for Triple-A Toledo. He hit .328/.375/.527 in 34 more games for Toledo this spring before moving up to Detroit. Overall in his minor league career, Dirks is a .291/.352/.429 hitter.
So far in the majors, he's at .263/.317/.421 with three homers, a 6/10 BB/K in 76 at-bats, and two steals. He hasn't been amazing, but there are things to like here.
Dirks is already 25 years old, so his upside is more limited than many prospects, but he has a broad base of skills. He has a compact swing that hits liners to all fields. Although he can be overpowered by plus fastballs, he holds in well against breaking balls and changeups thanks to a discerning eye. He doesn't draw a huge number of walks, but he avoids excessive strikeouts.
His running speed is a tick above average and he was an aggressive, and successful, stealer in the minors. His arm is average or a bit below, but his throws are usually accurate, he has enough range to play center field, and is very good in left. UZR already rates his defense very positively, granted the sample is small, but it does accord with the minor league scouting reports. Scouts love his makeup.
Dirks profiles as a perfect fourth outfielder since he has no spectacular skills, but does a lot of things well. He could be a regular under the right circumstances. He's similar to players like David DeJesus or David Dellucci, guys who aren't world-beaters but who help their teams in myriad ways.
10 comments
|
0 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
His arm
was above average the times I’ve seen him, but that’s only a couple.
by blackoutyears on Jun 23, 2025 8:18 AM EDT reply actions
arm
It didn’t look too great to me when he was in college, and other scouting reports have it as mediocre. But you know, things can change, and sometimes scouting reports are inaccurate.
by John Sickels on Jun 23, 2025 9:38 AM EDT up reply actions
I think
a big part of it is the accuracy that you mention. The throws had good velo, but definitely played up because they were on line. Judging them on trajectory and distance they were above avg for me. I wouldn’t say the arm is as strong as Heisey’s though, and over all Dirks impressed me as a slightly lesser version of Heis in the looks I got. Just a half tick behind in speed, power, fielding, size.
by blackoutyears on Jun 23, 2025 11:25 AM EDT up reply actions
ive seen him play a couple of times,
it was the scouts say his strenth with his arm avarge but he always hits the target, making him a good trower technically.
by Jt Malley on Jun 23, 2025 5:14 PM EDT up reply actions
He was pretty good in News Radio
Don’t care for his later work all that much.
by maguro on Jun 23, 2025 8:42 AM EDT reply actions
Who will have the better career...
Andy Dirks or Brennan Boesch?
by Kapellmeisters on Jun 23, 2025 1:28 PM EDT reply actions
Boesch
I think he has really figured it out, he said his swing clicked in Chicago (June 2), and his swing does look much shorter now and he’s hitting with power (and discipline). This stuff comes and goes, but if it doesn’t go I would not be surprised if he’s .850-.900 OPS for the rest of the season, especially hitting in front of Cabrera.
Dirks hasn’t overly impressed me, he could be a good 4th outfielder, a poor man’s DeJesus or Dellucci. But I would disagree with John and wouldn’t call his eye ‘discerning,’ and I actually think that his best chance at becoming a regular is to develop that eye and really control the strike zone. He doesn’t have enough pop to get by otherwise.
by The Fume on Jun 23, 2025 2:05 PM EDT up reply actions
I'd go with Boesch
He looks a lot better at the plate this year. I’d expect Dirks to stick around as a fourth outfielder fighting with Casper Wells for playing time.
by Ekaye80 on Jun 23, 2025 2:05 PM EDT up reply actions
Boesch
I dropped him in my dynasty league right before he went supernova about 3 weeks ago. I was his owner since April 2010, but after his 2nd half where his OPS was about 500, and his awful May which pushed his YTD OPS at around 650, I just couldnt take his terribleness anymore.
by Jack203 on Jun 23, 2025 8:50 PM EDT reply actions
He's a regular in my book
Dirks is not a spectacular player, but he does everything well. I’ve seen him a lot and the more you watch him, you can see his skills translate to every day play. He’s a guy that grows on you.
He probably won’t get that chance in Detroit, but if people want a top of the order type that has surprising pop, they should trade for him.
I see a .270 type guy with around 15 homers or so and stuffing the stat sheet nicely all around.
detroitbaseballpage.com
by dbpjohn on Jun 27, 2025 2:16 AM EDT reply actions

by John Sickels on 













