Community Mock Draft Commentary: American League West
Community Mock Draft Commentary: AL West
LOS ANGELES ANGELS
1) Stetson Allie, RHP, St. Edward HS, Olmstead Falls, Ohio
1) Peter Tago, RHP, Dana Hills HS, Laguna Niguel, California
1) Brett Eibner, OF, University of Arkansas
1S) Aaron Sanchez, RHP, Barstow HS, California
1S) Ryan Stanek, RHP, Blue Valley HS, Overland Park, KS
2) Angelo Gumbs, OF, Torrance HS, California
3) Tyler Holt, OF, Florida State University
3S) Tony Thompson, 3B, University of Kansas
COMMENTARY: Multiple picks makes this a potentially huge draft. This class would provide a drool-worthy influx of high-upside pitching to the system. It would also be quite expensive, and of course high school pitching carries risks. Eibner is a potential bargain in the bottom of the first round, and with all the other arms it makes sense to let him play the outfield and see if his bat will work at higher levels. Tools outfielder Gumbs is a personal favorite. Holt and Thompson provide some college leavening to the class. Overall, I think this looks terrific, although it would also be a stress on the budget. It will be interesting to see if the Angels are this aggressive in real life.
OAKLAND ATHLETICS
1) Karsten Whitson, RHP, Chipley HS, Florida
2) Mel Rojas Jr, OF, Wabash Valley CC, Illinois
3) Christian Yelich, 1B, Westlake HS, Thousand Oaks, CA
COMMENTARY: Oakland hasn't looked much at high school pitching at the top of the draft lately, but I could see them being interested in Whitson, who is more polished than most. Rojas is a tools hound and rather raw, but they do take some upside tools risks at times. Yelich has one of the best high school bats available but might be a tough sign away from Miami in the third round. They did buy Max Stassi last year. I could see Oakland being interested in all of these guys under the right conditions.
SEATTLE MARINERS
1S) Jesse Hahn, RHP, Virginia Tech
2) Austin Wates, OF, Virginia Tech
3) Jordan Swagerty, RHP, Arizona State
COMMENTARY: Hahn would be a bargain in the supplemental round if he's healthy, so I like the pick from an upside perspective. Wates has some defensive questions but has an intriguing bat that could move quickly. Swagerty is a reliever who should also rocket through the system. The Mariners were college-heavy after the supplemental round last year, so from a historical point of view this draft looks logical.
TEXAS RANGERS
1) Michael Choice, OF, University of Texas-Arlington
1) Asher Wojchiechowski, RHP, The Citadel
1S) Jarrett Parker, OF, University of Virginia
1S) Chance Ruffin, RHP, University of Texas
2) Micah Gibbs, C, Louisiana State
3) Daniel Gibson, LHP, Tampa Jesuit HS, Tampa
COMMENTARY: This is college heavy but not low on upside. Choice is a fine pick with the unprotected first round slot, a local guy with big offensive potential. Woj has a lively arm and seems to fit what the Rangers look for in pitchers, with arm strength and athleticism. Parker is toolsy but not everyone thinks he'll hit. Ruffin is another local who doesn't have massive upside could move through the system quickly, likewise LSU defensive specialist Gibbs. Gibson is a projectable lefty with signability doubts, but I like him. All told, I think this is a logical use of multiple picks, mixing guys with upside and polish.
0 recs |
5 comments
| Add comment
Comments
personal comments on Angels draft
I was keeping track of how I felt my draft would stack up signability-wise. Allie pretty much fell into my lap - was not expecting him to be there, but he’s the sort of guy that you shuffle some things around to bring into your system, I think he’s a gem. After that I started watching for California guys, knowing that the Angels keep very close tabs on in-state players, and also that such players might make for easier signs. I’ve been on Tago for a while now and was relieved that he got down to me. Eibner was another case of a guy falling into my lap . . .he was actually going to be my selection at 18 if not for Allie, and was shocked that he made he down to me.
I’ve been watching video on Sanchez and really like what I see. He needs some polish but I couldn’t say no to him here. I really love Stanek - he’s got size but not too much, good present velocity with the room for more, good feel for secondary pitches. He was actually my backup plan at 29 if Tago had been taken. I couldn’t leave him on the board, especially knowing that I had to wait 40 picks . . .that’s the point where you just make sure you get the best guy left on your board and sit and wait.
A strong rush on college position players threw me off a little at 81, but getting to add the toolsy Gumbs to the system would be a real coup and I didn’t feel bad at all about that. By this point I just wanted a couple of easy signs to take home the day, and I found them in Holt and Thompson. Two very different types of players, but they’re polished players who complement the earlier prep selections.
Will this draft be cheap? Probably not, but it’s by no means extravagant, either, and the Angels aren’t reluctant to spend for quality. This is a draft that completely remakes the system.
by mrkupe on Jun 5, 2025 8:55 PM EDT reply actions
That would be a dream draft as an Angels fan
by HaloFanInDC on Jun 6, 2025 1:39 AM EDT up reply actions
kudos to mrkupe for the Angel's draft
I think you absolutely nailed rd 1 and 1s.
Gumbs is also a pick I could see the Angel’s making IRL. I wonder, however, whether the Angels might go with either Walker or Frazier at this position.
Holt is the one pick I don’t like (especially with Kyle Blair still on the board).
I also am not excited by Thompson, but understand the need to get a signable player for this unprotected pick.
Overall, a great job.
by oater on Jun 5, 2025 9:05 PM EDT reply actions
I would be escatic if the A's draft ended this way
Great picks IMO Toddy Baseabll.
Let’s hope for the best starting Monday however this may be as good as it ever looks.
Here is to being surprised.
by Bud Light on Jun 6, 2025 1:06 AM EDT reply actions
Something to say? Choose one of these options to log in.
On Facebook? Use Connect to join SB Nation. Share insights with fans and friends.- » Create a new SB Nation account
- » Already registered with SB Nation? Log in!
by John Sickels on 









