I have compiled the results (so far) of the 1/3 grading that the community participated in doing. Take these with a grain of salt, as there were as many a as 14 votes for some prospects, and as few as 1 for others.  Also, some prospect were not nominated for grading, so this list may not contain every legitimate prospect.   I assigned GPA points for each prospect.  If you aren't familiar, an A = a 4.0, an A- = 3.7, and so on.  

Here are the top 50.  I'm strapped for time or I would go further.

1. Jeremy Hellickson - 3.93   2. Carlos Santana - 3.91   3. Dominic Brown - 3.9   4. (tie) Starlin Castro - 3.7   4. Tyler Matzek - 3.7   4. Mike Trout - 3.7   7. Desmond Jennings - 3.69   8. Mike Moustakas - 3.66   9. Dustin Ackley - 3.65       10. Pedro Alvarez - 3.59   11. Jesus Montero - 3.56   12. Michael Montgomery - 3.55   13. Julio Teheran - 3.58    14. Aroldis Chapman - 3.52   15. Mike Minor - 3.5   16. Martin Perez - 3.48    17.(tie) Kyle Gibson - 3.47   17. Jacob Turner- 3.47  19. (tie) Simon Castro - 3.38    19. Kyle Drabek - 3.38    21. Wilmer Flores - 3.37    22. Wil Myers - 3.35      23.(tie) Jake Arrieta - 3.3    23. Ryan Kalish - 3.3     25. Andrew Cashner - 3.27    26. (tie) Christian Friedrich - 3.26       26. Randal Delgado - 3.26   28.(tie) Madison Bumgarner - 3.25     28. Nick Franklin - 3.25    28. Dan Hudson - 3.25     31. (tie) Lonnie Chisenhall - 3.23    31. Alex Colome - 3.23    31. Freddie Freeman  - 3.23    31. Logan Morrison - 3.23 31. Michael Pineda - 3.23      36. Tony Sanchez - 3.21      37. (tie) Chris Carter - 3.2      37. Dee Gordon - 3.23                 37. Michael Taylor - 3.2    37. Arodys Vizcaino - 3.2     41. (tie) John Lamb - 3.18    41. Jordan Lyles - 3.18        41. Casey Kelly - 3.18    41. Chris Withrow - 3.18      45. Austin Romine - 3.17     46. Eric Hosmer - 3.16    47. (tie) Brett Jackson - 3.15    47. Devin Mesoraco - 3.15     47. Drew Cumberland - 3.15    50.  Brett Lawrie - 3.13