2011 MLB Draft: New York Yankees Review
2011 MLB Draft: New York Yankees Review
High school power bats seem a popular choice for the Yankees in 2011.
1S) Dante Bichette, Jr, OF, Florida HS: The Yankees seem to be taking some criticism for this pick, but if Bichette turns out to be anything like his dad, they may have the last laugh. His tools are very similar to his father's at the same stage.
2) Sam Stafford, LHP, Texas: Big lefty has 90-95 MPH heat and a good curve, but has significant problems throwing strikes at times. High-ceiling, higher-risk than many college arms. 1.57 ERA with 86/41 K/BB in 74 innings, just 49 hits.
3) Jordan Cote, RHP, New Hampshire HS: Projectable cold-weather prep needs some polish but already hits 90 and has a promising curveball. Buyable away from Coastal Carolina in this spot.
4) Matt Duran, 3B, New York HS: Power hitter from New Rochelle, quite raw with positional uncertainty. Committed to Fordham.
5) Greg Bird, C, Colorado HS: Scouts like his power bat, but there are mixed opinions about his ability to remain behind the plate. Arkansas commitment. Pre-draft buzz had him likely going to college, but he went early enough that he should be signable.
6) Jake Cave, OF, Virginia HS: Tougher sign than Cote, Bird, or Duran with Louisiana State commitment. Two-way player, hits 90 on the mound but raw, also athletic but raw as a hitter.
7) Austin Jones, 1B, Washington HS: Left-handed power with reasonable polish for a prep. University of Arizona commitment.
8) Phil Wetherell, RHP, Western Kentucky: Can hit 95 MPH, has a good splitter, 4.25 ERA with 44/19 K/BB in 59 innings. Projects as middle reliever with outside chance to close.
9) Zach Arneson, RHP, Lewis-Clark State: Low-90s fastball, workable cutter, projects as a middle reliever. 2.82 ERA, 46/17 K/BB in 45 innings.
10) Jon Gray, RHP, Eastern Oklahoma State JC: Low-90s fastball, good slider, has command issues, also projects as a reliever.
OTHERS OF NOTE: OF Justin James (13th round, Sacramento CC) is the son of Dion James. He's raw for a college guy and bloodline player but has good speed and power potential and could be a bargain. RHP Rookie Davis (14th round, North Carolina HS) is a signability risk from East Carolina but has the arm strength to earn an overslot bonus. LHP Dan Camarena (20th round, California HS) could have gone 15 rounds higher on talent but is strongly committed to San Diego.
SUMMARY: I personally like Bichette. The rest of the class was focused on raw high school kids with power potential and signability issues, plus some college pitchers who look like bullpen contributors, though Stafford could be really good if he throws more strikes. I particularly like James in the 14th round as a sleeper choice.
5 comments
|
0 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
Ugh...
You said it all - raw high schoolers and middle relievers. Why draft for middle relievers, probably the cheapest part of any MLB roster?
Picks I like/I think are good value:
Greg Bird
Jake Cave
Justin James
William "Rookie" Davis
Daniel Camarena
Zach Wilson
Adam Smith
Alright picks, but too early:
Dante Bichette Jr.
Sam Stafford
Jordan Cote
Matt Duran
The Rest:
Too little upside or too many projected middle relievers for my taste.
Biggest complaint of the Yankees draft is the same as always – for a team with their money, they take very few signability guys, but play it safe with lots of college players, especially pitchers with too many questions about their ability to be starters.
by cookiedabookie on Jun 13, 2025 12:07 PM EDT reply actions
Very few signability guys?
Their entire 3rd day was practically all signability guys with almost zero filler. And I think you might be underselling some of these bullpen guys. You must have a pretty good bullpen if you have a guy hitting 95 with a good splitter throwing “middle relief”.
Two other guys I like a lot are Hayden Sharp and Jeremy Rathjen. Sharp is a 6’6" RHP dual commit to Central Oklahoma to play football and baseball. He has touched 98 and sat in the mid to low 90’s (Albeit as a reliever). He’s got a great frame, good arm strength and athleticism galore. Another guys I like a lot is Jeremy Rathjen. Rice’s (hopefully) former cleanup hitter and Anthony Rendon’s protector. He was considered to go in the first 5 rounds, but fell because he blew out his ACL 16 games into the season. An athletic 6’6" CF with good speed, good instincts, and an above average arm. He had started making more consistent contact, and has plenty of room to grow into his lanky frame. The only question is how well he can come back from his injury and how badly he wants to go back to Rice. He’ll be a 4th year junior if he returns so he won’t have a ton of leverage, but it’s possible he wants to go back to school.
Strikeouts are boring- Besides that, they're fascist. Throw some ground balls - it's more democratic.
by CasanovaWong on Jun 13, 2025 2:16 PM EDT up reply actions
You do know
that the majority of the Yankees pen is cheap due to them being homegrown> I’m sure they want to keep it that way so you know they’re gonna have to draft relievers.
It’s not like they guys the Yankees chose over the guys you wanted have a much higher chance of being viable major leaguers.
World Series attitude, champagne bottle life, nothing every changes so tonight is like tomorrow night.
by Drizzzy on Jun 13, 2025 8:37 PM EDT up reply actions
Solid (A) grade draft in my opinion.
I like Stafford’s upside as a pitcher.
by PeteyNhtown on Jun 17, 2025 6:24 AM EDT reply actions

by John Sickels on 













