You're the GM! Twins Edition
You're the GM of the Twins.
Although you lost game 163, overall the 2008 season has to be regarded as a success: you almost won the division in a season that was supposed to be focused on rebuilding.
So what are the next steps? The rotation looks sound for next year: Slowey and Baker are strong. While Liriano wasn't quite his old self, he wasn't bad by any means. Blackburn and Perkins might fade out on you, and you need to be ready with alternatives. You could use some bullpen reinforcement.
Among the position players, Mauer and Morneau are rocks. Gomez is spectacular with the glove but his hitting is horrid, what do you do about that? Should you trade Delmon Young? Or give him more time to get his power stroke in order? Can you count on Denard Span again? How do you best deploy Jason Kubel? There is a lot of flux in the infield. . who are the long-term solutions at 3B, SS, and 2B?
Have at it.
0 recs |
65
comments
| Add comment
Comments
John would you put Gomez in AAA
Or do you keep him in the lineup and hope he becomes another Jose Reyes type hitter.
by Bravesin07 on
Oct 20, 2025 7:34 PM EDT
reply
0 recs
I'd keep in the lineup.
Batting 9th, however, until he can learn his patience.
Viking Vigil - The 2nd Best Vikings Community on the Internet!
http://www.vikingvigil.com
Twins Fix
http://www.twinsfix.com
by Andersklasen on
Oct 20, 2025 7:40 PM EDT
up
reply
0 recs
He's not going to become Jose Reyes
He won’t ever magically develop plate discipline. Perhaps more power, but never a Reyes-type jump in discipline.
Who's world is it? It's yours.
by BlackOps on
Oct 21, 2025 2:10 PM EDT
up
reply
0 recs
My plan...
Keep the outfield intact. There are five quality outfielders, I know, but that is a good problem.
The bullpen is sound in my opinion as well. Although it is scary for one guy to have such an effect on the bullpen, Pat Neshek will bring this ‘pen back to it’s previous spectacular form. Little needs to be done with that.
The starting rotation shouldn’t be messed with either. The current five: Liriano, Baker, Slowey, Blackburn, Perkins are totally acceptable starting pitchers. There is depth in the minors as well with Duensing and Mulvey. They could make starts if need be in 2009.
The right infield is locked in for a long time. The left infield is the problem, though.
I would propose trading for Edwin Encarnacion. He quietly hit 26 home runs for the Reds in 2008 and is eligible for arbitration this year. Even though the Twins have Danny Valencia ready for action as soon as late 2009 bringing in a 25-year old does have it’s benefits. When Valencia is ready he will have competition for the third base job, and he won’t just assume it’s his to lose.
Also, having two capable third basemen is better than having one aging veteran and a young potential star. Although the normal answer among Twins fans would be to sign a veteran third baseman for one year, like Casey Blake for example, I would suggest trading for a semi-young, proven option. Another example of this would be Adrian Beltre.
Viking Vigil - The 2nd Best Vikings Community on the Internet!
http://www.vikingvigil.com
Twins Fix
http://www.twinsfix.com
by Andersklasen on
Oct 20, 2025 7:38 PM EDT
reply
0 recs
furthermore
Edwin Encar is probably a better player than Valencia anyway
by nms on
Oct 20, 2025 7:41 PM EDT
up
reply
0 recs
Whom do you trade for Edwin if you're keeping the rest of the team intact?
It's not the results, it's how you look going about those results -- Tim McCarver
by WaddellCanseco on
Oct 20, 2025 10:18 PM EDT
up
reply
0 recs
See below..
Brendan Harris and Anthony Slama. It’s probably a little too little, though.
Viking Vigil - The 2nd Best Vikings Community on the Internet!
http://www.vikingvigil.com
Twins Fix
http://www.twinsfix.com
by Andersklasen on
Oct 20, 2025 10:21 PM EDT
up
reply
0 recs
Why not move Cuddyer back to 3B for the next couple of years?
by Caernarvon on
Oct 21, 2025 11:08 AM EDT
up
reply
0 recs
I wouldn't be opposed to that...
…but I doubt it would happen.
Viking Vigil - The 2nd Best Vikings Community on the Internet!
http://www.vikingvigil.com
Twins Fix
http://www.twinsfix.com
by Andersklasen on
Oct 21, 2025 11:11 AM EDT
up
reply
0 recs
Cuddyer
He can’t play third because he’s deaf in one ear. He had a ton of trouble hearing the bat off the ball when he played there.
by Fanon on
Oct 21, 2025 1:43 PM EDT
up
reply
0 recs
Encarnacion was the worst fielding infielder in majors according to keith law
he might be a left fielder soon.
by Bravesin07 on
Oct 20, 2025 7:45 PM EDT
reply
0 recs
Well that solves the Valencia problem!
I think the Encarcion move is a strong one, for several reasons. First, Edwin’s young enough that he still has potential remaining in his bat. Second, he’ll be able to anchor the Twinks hot corner for at least another season or season-and-a-half . Third, his arm would probably play very well in Right Field if he had to move.
by demondeaconsbaseball on
Oct 20, 2025 8:27 PM EDT
up
reply
0 recs
Here is my take on it:
I threw together nearly 700 words on a proposed trade involving Edwin. Here it is.
The gist of it is this:
Twins Get:
Edwin Encarnacion, 3B
Reds Get:
Brendan Harris, 3B
Anthony Slama, RHP
Viking Vigil - The 2nd Best Vikings Community on the Internet!
http://www.vikingvigil.com
Twins Fix
http://www.twinsfix.com
by Andersklasen on
Oct 20, 2025 9:06 PM EDT
up
reply
0 recs
Something tells me that package isn't enough
You would have to deal a decent starter as well. I could see something like Blackburn for Encarcion straight up, or something like that. You can always have Mulvey step in (or trade him with Slama). Also remember that the Reds have quite a few hot corner prospects (so I’ve heard- please don’t hold me to this).
by demondeaconsbaseball on
Oct 20, 2025 9:22 PM EDT
up
reply
0 recs
You are right and wrong
The Reds do have some great 3B prospects but the closest would be Eric Eymann; currently in Double A, though he should start 2009 in Louisville. He is 24 years old. Juan Francisco and Neftali Soto are also both great prospects.
Harris is a decent starter. He hit at a .265 /.327 /.394 clip in 2008. His OPS is 721, but he only hit seven homers. If the Reds were to take the deal, they would enjoy a huge increase in defense, but a drop in power. EE doesn’t even want to play in Cincinnati, anyway.
Viking Vigil - The 2nd Best Vikings Community on the Internet!
http://www.vikingvigil.com
Twins Fix
http://www.twinsfix.com
by Andersklasen on
Oct 20, 2025 10:01 PM EDT
up
reply
0 recs
I disagree on eymann
Todd Frazier, Chris Valaika are probably much much closer. A lesser prospect would be Adam Rosales. All three are ahead of Eymann, and Soto eventually will be too.
I don’t know enough about those players to comment on how fair that trade is. Slama…reminds me of the 90’s pog epidemic.
by sharks on
Oct 20, 2025 10:30 PM EDT
up
reply
0 recs
I'm sorry...
the chart I was looking at had Frazier and Valaika listed as shortstops. They could probably play third in the majors.
Viking Vigil - The 2nd Best Vikings Community on the Internet!
http://www.vikingvigil.com
Twins Fix
http://www.twinsfix.com
by Andersklasen on
Oct 20, 2025 11:21 PM EDT
up
reply
0 recs
no big deal
valaika might eventually stick at SS anyway but his defense is not good, but I say he would stay there becuase he might end up in the majors because of his bat and that’s an open spot, frazier I heard may move to third but could maybe stay at SS, his D is better than valaika’s.
by sharks on
Oct 21, 2025 1:52 AM EDT
up
reply
0 recs
But you are right...
This package probably isn’t enough.
Viking Vigil - The 2nd Best Vikings Community on the Internet!
http://www.vikingvigil.com
Twins Fix
http://www.twinsfix.com
by Andersklasen on
Oct 20, 2025 10:03 PM EDT
up
reply
0 recs
Not Enough
The Reds wouldn’t want Brendan Harris at all. Keppinger is pretty much the same player and he will be on the bench next season. The Reds want bats. Namely a big right handed bat so they are not going to trade the only right handed bat in the lineup for pitching prospect and a player they already threw away. Much to the dismay of RedsFans Dusty Baker and Co. do love them some speedy outfielders so maybe Span and a prospect or just Gomez for Edwin might work, though I wouldn’t like either.
by kennythered on
Oct 21, 2025 8:41 AM EDT
up
reply
0 recs
as a reds fan...
Encarnacion makes mistakes, but I think his range and his offense is overlooked. He’s also still fairly young.
Most of his errors are throwing errors, and a few I saw were because Votto couldnt make a pick at first I see a lot of other 1B make (he improved as the yr went on). Some would argue that those errors are still fixable, even though he’s had a few years to do it and hasnt. He still makes good diving plays, and has plenty of range making diving stops, and plays balls in front of him well (ones which you need to charge and make an off balance throw on) mostly because he’s aware of his defensive inability and works hard in practice.
I’ve also heard he’s too slow for the OF, however i wouldnt put it past him that he could play at least a decent LF personally, but I doubt he makes that move. I’ve also heard thoughts on putting him a 1B and moving Votto to the OF, however I’m not a huge fan of moving around guys like musical chairs, the Reds defense is bad enough as it is.
Worst fielder? I wouldnt say that, thats all because he makes errors, which are the discretion of the official scorer and could be helped by a good defensive 1B. He makes it to balls more than other guys Ive seen play and then overthrows, which wouldnt have been an error if he didnt have the range he does.
His throwing technique on balls hit right to him (basically easy plays) is what concerns me, becuase he has a habit of double pumping his arm (by bringing his hands together after getting the ball in order to get comfortable before throwing) when most guys get up, set their feet and throw. I wish he would change it, but I’m not 100% sure he ever will.
In summation, he’d be useful to a team as a 3B, and I think him switching positions is unlikely.
by sharks on
Oct 20, 2025 8:29 PM EDT
up
reply
0 recs
David Wright
That defense sounds exactly like David Wright until he improved it during 2007. Great range, great at going in and making off balance throws, but double clutching on the easy plays and then making throwing errors. He still does it sometimes but he really improved it over the past year or two. It wouldn’t surprise me if Encarnacion could do it as well.
by supermets on
Oct 20, 2025 9:44 PM EDT
up
reply
0 recs
I hope your right
Overall I like EE, however we’ve been down the he’ll improve road before…so I’m not sure it will happen. but hey, I hope he turns into david wright too.
All he has to do is reduce his errors by like 8 and he becomes a well above average third baseman.
by sharks on
Oct 20, 2025 10:34 PM EDT
up
reply
0 recs
to clarify:
“has a habit of double pumping his arm (by bringing his hands together after getting the ball in order to get comfortable before throwing)”
This means he grabs the ball from his glove, brings it out, then bring his hands back together again, then brings the ball back to throw, a very unnecessary motion.
If a trade for delmon young could be worked out (EE and one or a few other guys) I would do it, and I bet it helped both teams.
by sharks on
Oct 20, 2025 8:39 PM EDT
reply
0 recs
I’d be listening to offers throughout the offseason on all five outfielders, but I’d have to get something I’m pretty excited about to move anyone but Cuddyer, and I’d expect to go into the season with all five of them. I’m kind of confused at why so many people are suddenly more down on Delmon when he basically hit in line with his projections, and I’m not anxious to get rid of him just for the sake of it. Seems like maybe not meeting his overhyped expectations is leading people to underrate his actual performance.
Not sure Casilla is a solution at 2B yet, but he’s an answer that will get at least partial credit. I don’t know that I’d resign Punto and play him at SS — but that’s doubtless what the Twins will do, and I’m OK with it. One option that came up over at DTFC was trading one of the out-of-options guys for Khalil Greene, which I think is worth thinking about, maybe even if Punto is still around.
I’m on board the “sign Casey Blake” plan for 3B. There isn’t anybody out there who’s a real long-term option, even when the Twins have a budget surplus, and I’m not interested in paying what Seattle wants for Adrian Beltre.
Rotation should be OK. I’m a bit worried about depth, but don’t really have a plan to address it. I’d like another good righty reliever if one could be had, since the extra money is there, and more security in the pen is never a bad thing.
by timprov on
Oct 20, 2025 8:46 PM EDT
reply
0 recs
not much
C - Mauer and Redmond….great combo, redmond recently renewed and mauer locked up…arguably the best catching duo in the majors
1B - Morneau…lack of homers was surprising this year, but still one of the game’s best driving in runs and playing gold glove quality defense
2B - Casilla…had some very bright spots and some dark ones as well….solid with the glove, nice speed, and a decent eye….good #8 type hitter ahead of gomez
3B - move proposed, see below
SS - move proposed, see below
LF - Young….power wasn’t there, but certainly wasn’t absent for those who saw his BP cuts….minnesota has a habit of taking a guy with a great line drive swing and turning him into a 15-home run hitter when he may have the power to hit 30 if allowed to finish his swing fully….i’d either allow the guy to finish his swing (a la the change boston made with ortiz that changed him from a backup DH to jeremy giambi into one of the most feared hitters in the game) or trade him….and depending on where cuddyer’s health is, the trade option could truly make sense….span slides over if a trade happens
CF - Gomez….lots of moments of brilliance….lots of moments of “WTF?!”….right now simply does not possess the patience to be a top of the order hitter, but still hits enough to be on base with TONS of speed to make something happen….perfect 9 hole hitter….great defender in center as well
RF - Span/Cuddyer….depending on Cuddyer’s health, he may force a move….i believe in span…as a solid #2 hitter….he’s not the high average, high obp guy of last season, but he does have good contact skills and would be a perfect guy to bunt a runner over or hit and run with, and possesses the type of speed to be a threat if the bases are empty ahead of him….cuddyer struggled with injury this year, but is not far removed from being a very viable threat in the middle of the lineup…his health at twins workouts during the offseason could spell the end of young….
dh - Kubel….very solid season, and still growing as a hitter….has streaks where he just disappears, though, especially against tough LH pitching….if cuddyer can’t go in the field, but can with the bat, kubel may move to the OF if young’s traded….
rotation - solid 1-5….Perkins was a huge asset in the pen in 2007, and if he could be bumped with the acquisition of another starter, he’d fill a needed long relief role….but otherwise, the rotation’s fine…
’pen - very solid….adding in neshek and the competition of prospect pitchers to break into the team through the pen will keep the ’pen very solid….
what i’d do….
trade with Seattle……they are losing Raul Ibanez to free agency and will be looking for someone to replace him….this is a chance for the twins to add some depth while filling a position of need…..Seattle sends Beltre and Greg Halman (with some salary) for delmon young….knowing the twins love for jarrod washburn, he may end up fodder in the deal with most salary paid by seattle in exchange for a low B/high C prospect added in….
i’d also use billy beane’s man-love for kevin mulvey against him and try to pry away one of his top pitchers by using mulvey and brendan harris….
last, but not least….sign raffy furcal….yes, i said the cubs should do this as well, but he would simply be a perfect fit for the twins….leadoff guy, solid defensive shortstop….they need both badly….
resulting lineup/rotation
Furcal, SS
Span, LF
Mauer, C
Morneau, 1B
Beltre, 3B
Kubel, DH
Cuddyer, RF
Casilla, 2B
Gomez, CF
Liriano
Baker
Slowey
Blackburn
Perkins (unless a deal is done with Beane)
Insanity is doing the same thing over and over expecting different results.
by biggentleben on
Oct 20, 2025 8:52 PM EDT
reply
0 recs
As an A's fan i wouldn't trade a top pitcher for Mulvey and Brendan Harris
I wasn’t aware that Beane had any love for Mulvey either. If he does, I strongly discourage it. Whom did you mean by top pitcher anyway?
It's not the results, it's how you look going about those results -- Tim McCarver
by WaddellCanseco on
Oct 20, 2025 10:24 PM EDT
up
reply
0 recs
top pitcher
i’d say that could be anything from duke to one of their prospects…..depending on what beane would give up….just that he has tried multiple times to get mulvey away from first the mets and now the twins in deals for blanton and zito….it just would seem to me like a good time to move mulvey as the bloom is still on the rose….and i don’t think he’s as good as beane thinks he is, and could bring back hefty return for that reason….i was personally thinking more along the lines of a gio gonzalez or another minor leaguer…..
Insanity is doing the same thing over and over expecting different results.
by biggentleben on
Oct 20, 2025 11:16 PM EDT
up
reply
0 recs
Zito?
Mulvey was drafted about 6-8 weeks before the Trade Deadline when Zito was still with the A’s in 2006. In other words, he couldn’t have even asked for him in a deal, not even as a PTBNL.
Personally, if they’re just going to get another pitcher back for Mulvey, might as well keep him. IF you’re going to trade a pitchign prospect, you have to address the left side of the infield unless you can put him in a package to get an Ace… like Peavy…
by SethSpeaks on
Oct 21, 2025 9:46 AM EDT
up
reply
0 recs
i don't know
i look at the twins system and see lots of nice right handed arms coming….and not a lot from the lefty side….if you can parlay one of those guys into a top-notch lefty by including in a solid utility bat, why not do it?
Insanity is doing the same thing over and over expecting different results.
by biggentleben on
Oct 21, 2025 12:37 PM EDT
up
reply
0 recs
Halman and Beltre for Young?
Don’t you think that’s a bit too much?
I like homeless people. They are funny. I like cake. It is not funny but really delicious.
by Humongo on
Oct 21, 2025 1:36 AM EDT
up
reply
0 recs
depends
on whether you think you’re getting 2008 delmon young, or if you still think there’s a lot of growth left to him….the m’s have a 3b in waiting right now, so they can move beltre, who’s in the last year of his deal….halman’s mainly so the twins have something tangible from the deal left in 2010….and halman’s a whole lot of tools right now without a lot of refining….but he’s the type of guy that the twins system could really benefit….
Insanity is doing the same thing over and over expecting different results.
by biggentleben on
Oct 21, 2025 2:34 AM EDT
up
reply
0 recs
Is it me
or does Carew’s bat look like it’s bending like a bubble-shaft golf club? Or maybe I should not have eaten that mushroom given to me by Vida Blue…
by slurve on
Oct 20, 2025 9:05 PM EDT
reply
0 recs
um
you realize that’s oliva, not carew, right?
Insanity is doing the same thing over and over expecting different results.
by biggentleben on
Oct 20, 2025 10:20 PM EDT
up
reply
0 recs
well...
guess its a funky mushroom if it makes him look like carew right?
by sharks on
Oct 20, 2025 10:45 PM EDT
up
reply
0 recs
Yeah
Realized that after I hovered my mouse over the pic
by slurve on
Oct 21, 2025 8:22 AM EDT
up
reply
0 recs
Looks like a machete
that’s gonna slice that baseball like an apple.
by StickRat on
Oct 21, 2025 2:32 AM EDT
up
reply
0 recs
they should
do some serious trading. there was some serious bubble this year. they might do well to sell high a bit. particularly on some of their pitchers.
the whole team was remarkablly healthy, and most pitchers performed unbelievablly well. that’s not exactly a reliable recipe going foward.
by RollingWave on
Oct 20, 2025 9:33 PM EDT
reply
0 recs
Beltre and Silva
I know we’ll trade for Beltre and our end of the deal will be to take Silva and his bad contract back for free. The Twins don’t give anything up and the M’s get rid of Silva to his previous team? Seems like it works for everyone haha.
In all honesty I see the Twins offering one of Blackburn or Perkins to get either a 3B or one Middle infielder. Maybe they’ll find a way to address both positions but I see them making a big trade for one of the guys mentioned on this thread or possibly a J.J. Hardy, Cano (if really available), or someone I’m not thinking of.
Other than that, I think the Twins bullpen will be fine next year if Neshek comes back healthy. If they can get a good right handed 3B or SS/2B they should be a decent lineup once again. The pitching will be fine as long as they don’t feel the need to get another Livan Hernandez/Ramon Ortiz type to replace a current starter should they trade one of them.
Peyton's good but have you ever heard of Jeff George?
by halfchest on
Oct 20, 2025 9:51 PM EDT
reply
0 recs
I could see a Hardy for young starter deal
Course, one could argue that the Brewers should just move JJ to 3B…
by demondeaconsbaseball on
Oct 20, 2025 10:55 PM EDT
up
reply
0 recs
Are the Twins
really willing to take back all that money in contracts? Beltre is getting 12 million a year and they didn’t want to keep Silva last year. While Betre is a good fielder with power he doesn’t walk much and the Twins already have too many low OBP guys n the lineup. I’d rather see them work on getting Edwin from Cincy. He has more upside and a better contract situation.
by red257 on
Oct 21, 2025 9:54 AM EDT
up
reply
0 recs
Joking
I wasn’t serious about the Twins just taking one good player and then a bad contract. I’ve never once heard of a trade like that going down although it damn near makes sense for the M’s in this scenario.
Peyton's good but have you ever heard of Jeff George?
by halfchest on
Oct 21, 2025 10:25 AM EDT
up
reply
0 recs
My plan
The Twins needs are obvious. They have a clog in the OF and holes on the left side of the infield. Here’s what I’d do:
Trade Gomez and a couple of pitching prospects for JJ Hardy, perhaps Gomez/Humber/Slama. It wouldnt be too much. I feel the Twins would be much better for now going forth with Young-Span-Cuddyer rather than Young-Gomez-Span, and perhaps Cuddyer at 3rd or on the bench. I also dont think Gomez is that good, and since they have Revere and Hicks in the minors, as well as Span and Young already in the majors, they wont have any need for him in the future. For Milwaukee, unless I’m forgetting somebody (and that’s a strong possibility), they have an opening in the outfield after Braun and Hart and they could use some speed. With a lack of pitching in the minors and possible losing Sheets and Sabathia, they could also use 1 or two pitching prospects. I think this deal works out for both teams.
Sign Rafael Furcal, and move Hardy to third. I dont like the 3rd basemen available on either the free agent or trade markets, and it would work out best for the Twins to play Furcal at short and simply slide Hardy over to third. Furcal is their type of player and would probably come “cheap” considering he’s coming off an injury. It would also make Punto a utility guy, which is what he should be.
Sign Ryan Dempster, and slide Perkins into the bullpen. The Twins have got to go out and spend some money some time, why not do it now, when they’re close to going deep in the playoffs? Open up the pocketbooks a little, and go after Dempster. He wouldnt cost as much as a Sabathia or Sheets, and it’d give them a great 1-2 punch, plus a vet in that rotation to help all the young guys. I’m not really comfortable with Perkins as a full-time starter, even if it’s in the 5th spot. This would give them a great rotation and it would also improve their bullpen, making up for the loss of Dennys Reyes.
Lastly, sign Jim Edmonds or Juan Rivera, depending on who you would rather take a chance on. Edmonds still has legit 20 homer pop and could rotate with Cuddyer between RF/DH if they’re concerned with Cuddyer’s foot. He would also provide nice veteran leadership. Rivera is an interesting one. He’s coming off a decent season where he had to split playing time, and I think showed he’s recovered from his injury and can return to his form from a couple years ago. He would come cheap and could be an interesting low-risk/high-reward play
If they do these things, this is what their team could look like:
Lineup:
Span, CF
Furcal, SS
Mauer, C
Morneau, 1B
Hardy, 3B
Young, LF
Cuddyer, RF
Edmonds/Rivera, DH
Casilla, 2B
Bench:
Punto, UTIL
Harris, INF
Redmond, C
Buscher, 3B
Kubel, OF
Rotation:
Liriano
Dempster
Slowey
Blackburn
Baker
Bullpen:
LR/MR -Perkins
MR -Mijares
MR -Breslow
MR -Guerrier
SU -Neshek
CL - Nathan
That is a damn good team. It probably wont happen, but it’s definitely feasible.
Never, Never, NEVER give up
by hero66 on
Oct 21, 2025 12:17 AM EDT
reply
0 recs
Are you nuts?
If you trade Gomez 93% of Twins territory will be hunting you down. And he IS good. He will be the next Jose Reyes.
And if the Twins go after all those guys Carl Pohlad is obviously dead.
Viking Vigil - The 2nd Best Vikings Community on the Internet!
http://www.vikingvigil.com
Twins Fix
http://www.twinsfix.com
by Andersklasen on
Oct 21, 2025 12:45 AM EDT
up
reply
0 recs
trading gomez
while is value is down a little isnt what I would do, you have to think he could repeat his fast start (pun intended) and sustain it with some seasoning.
by sharks on
Oct 21, 2025 1:55 AM EDT
up
reply
0 recs
Plus...
I’d much rather have Kubel at DH than Edmonds!! Dempster isn’t an option. He’ll make too much and I dont’ think anyone really thinks he’s as good as he was in 2008.
Furcal is an injury risk… I would consider Hardy IF they can get him for Gomez straight up, but I’d keep him at SS.
I’d advocate Beltre at 3B because he’s a one year guy. 1.) I am high on Valencia, 2.) Beltre is always at his best in contract years. 3.) I think he’s pretty impressive defensively. 4.) 2 draft picks when they let him go after 2009.
by SethSpeaks on
Oct 21, 2025 9:52 AM EDT
up
reply
0 recs
How would you compare Edwin to Valencia?
Viking Vigil - The 2nd Best Vikings Community on the Internet!
http://www.vikingvigil.com
Twins Fix
http://www.twinsfix.com
by Andersklasen on
Oct 21, 2025 9:58 AM EDT
up
reply
0 recs
Dollars...
Edwin has 3+ years in the big leagues and is a year older… Valencia is a yaer away. But I think the style of play could be similar, with Valencia being better defensively.
by SethSpeaks on
Oct 21, 2025 10:38 AM EDT
up
reply
0 recs
Yeah why trade a CFer that can't hit
for a SS that can Madness!
1941 .406
by FrozenTed9 on
Oct 21, 2025 10:41 AM EDT
up
reply
0 recs
The onky reasonable plan...
is for Twins fans to pray that economy continues on its downward spiral to such a degree that a second Great Depression comes along (Greater Depression?). Perhaps then, the Pohlad family can spring into action, in grand, Pohlad-like fashion, stealing the homes of hardworking Americans to further contribute to their offensive wealth. Perhaps then their coffers will swell and bloat enough that they’re forced to spend money on their (er, OUR) Twins.
Then again, I did say “reasonable”, didn’t I?
Oops.
by damianschaab on
Oct 21, 2025 1:57 AM EDT
reply
0 recs
My plan
The twins really only have a couple of areas to fix, and fixing them could easily hand them the central with a legit shot at the World Series.
1) Sign Juan Cruz or some other shutdown reliever to a 3 year deal. The pen was incredibly weak, and while it looks as though help is on the way, I’d just assume add one more arm
2) Make one of two trades: Perkins, Bonser, Buscher, prospects to Seattle for Beltre or to Milwaukee for Hardy.
3) If they make the trade with Milwaukee, sign Crede to a 1 year incentive laden deal.
4) Send Gomez to AAA to work on his plate discipline
5) Trade Buscher, Guerrier for anything or DFA them if nothing is available.
6) There may be room to pick up a 5th OF or someone else on the bench
Your roster
C - Mauer
1B - Morneau
2B - Casilla or Harris (if no Hardy)
SS - Hardy or Casilla
3B - Beltre or Crede
LF - Young
CF - Span
RF - Cuddyer
DH - Kubel
SP - Baker, Liriano, Slowey, Blackburn, Humber
RP - Nathan, Neshek, Mijares, Cruz, Crain, Breslow
BN - Redmond, Harris, Ruiz (spell Morneau at first from time to time), Tolbert or Punto (both if Hardy is not aquired as Harris starts), Pridie (or some FA pickup).
3B is intentionally setup to be a short term stop gap. That should give Hughes/Valencia time to develop and we can get an idea of one of them is for real.
by diehardtwinsfan on
Oct 21, 2025 8:49 AM EDT
reply
0 recs
Why
trade/cut bucher for nothing he still has options and at very least could be in AAA next year.
1941 .406
by FrozenTed9 on
Oct 21, 2025 10:43 AM EDT
up
reply
0 recs
Point taken
I’d assume if we were trading for Beltre the Ms would likely get him as a filler. But I do see your point. For some reason I was thinking he and Guerrier were out of options
by diehardtwinsfan on
Oct 21, 2025 11:35 AM EDT
up
reply
0 recs
Agree and Disagree
I’m an advocate of possibly signing a guy like Crede to a 1 year deal like you said. As long as he’s a type B free agent next year we get at least the 1 draft pick at the end of the year plus Crede could surprise a lot of people after having another off season to heal up.
I also like Buscher and could see him being a nice addition to any trade for a 3B since it will give that team a cheap decent option for a few years to replace what they give up.
I think the pen is going to be fine. Crain will have another year post injury and Neshek should be back, hopefully just as effective. Mijares looked good and the Twins were starting to trust Breslow much more towards the end of the year. Guerrier should be better with not so much of the weight on his shoulders as well. He was way way waaayyy overused this season and it wrecked him for the home stretch. The Twins have enough young pitching they shouldn’t waste any money on a big name reliever. Someone be it Bonser, Humber, Mulvey, Swarzak is going to have to convert if the Twins start out weak in the bullpen again. The Bullpen has been the Twins strongest point for many years and only because of the loss of Neshek and the sharp decline of Rincon did it look weak this year.
No reason at all to DFA either Buscher or Guerrier. I wouldn’t want to trade Guerrier for the same reason I wouldn’t trade Gomez or Young, there value is down and I think they’re better than they did this year. If I were going to trade anyone it would be Span, Buscher, or Blackburn because I believe they all overachieved and have higher value right now than they should. It’s not that I don’t like those players I just don’t see them consistently performing like they did, especially Buscher.
Peyton's good but have you ever heard of Jeff George?
by halfchest on
Oct 21, 2025 10:44 AM EDT
up
reply
0 recs
the pen
I’m not sure the pen will be fine. The outlook certainly looks better with Neshek’s return, but this pen is one injury away (or Neshek simply not coming back to form) from being just as bad. I don’t believe Guerrier will be worth much of anything next year. Neshek was overused last year like Guerrier was this year and look what happened. Personally, if we got a guy like Cruz on top of things, I’d suspect that we could just get rid of Guerrier alltogether. Even if he looks like the 2007/early 2008 version, he wouldn’t be as good as anyone else we have. We’d have a very nice pen.
My other concer with Buscher was that he defense was bad. Bad defense on the left side cost several games last season. While Buscher may be league average in terms of offense, his defense leaves a lot to be desired and getting Beltre over there would alleviate that. If Crede was the solution, I could definitely see putting Buscher back in AAA as Crede will need some insurance.
by diehardtwinsfan on
Oct 21, 2025 11:41 AM EDT
up
reply
0 recs
What would the Giants have to give up to get Delmon Young?
I’d love for the G’s to grab Young, but I’m not sure if there is a good fit between the two teams for trading purposes. The Giants have a lot of young pitching; the Twins don’t really need pitching. Still, I think the Twins still owe us one for taking advantage of our idiot GM and stealing Nathan and Liriano from us… worst, trade, EVAR.
Psycho killer, qu'est-ce que c'est?
by shikantaza on
Oct 21, 2025 10:32 AM EDT
reply
0 recs
Sabean
Considering that GM still inexplicably has his job, I’m guessing the Giants would probably end up on the losing end of that one. Cain for Delmon?
by Fanon on
Oct 21, 2025 1:52 PM EDT
up
reply
0 recs
I don't know
I wonder why the Twins are looking at dealing Young. Based on his 2nd half performance and his age, I’d think they’d be excited about his future. They better not trade him unless they get a very good SS/3b back, because that’s about all they need. Maybe if they could get JJ Hardy or something….
Harris is more of a utility player. Punto, lol. Buscher probably just had the best year he’s ever going to have. SS/3b is a black hole right now and needs to be dealt with. If anything, deal Cuddyer for a decent SS/3b.
by BaseballBrain on
Oct 21, 2025 10:42 AM EDT
reply
0 recs
Punto, lol?
He was a joke a few years ago but excelled this year. Just take a look at his 2008 line:
.284/.344/.382 with an OPS of 726. Certainly not great, and he has little power, but he is no longer a joke. He is an above-average utility infielder.
Viking Vigil - The 2nd Best Vikings Community on the Internet!
http://www.vikingvigil.com
Twins Fix
http://www.twinsfix.com
by Andersklasen on
Oct 21, 2025 11:14 AM EDT
up
reply
0 recs
OK....
If a 726 OPS is your data point to show that he’s not a joke, then you’re reaching. 726 is pretty horrible for a 3b. It would be fair for a SS, if he could maintain it.
I agree, he’s a utility player, just like Harris.
by BaseballBrain on
Oct 21, 2025 2:08 PM EDT
up
reply
0 recs
2010
I think the Twins should sit on their hands this winter and focus on 2010. This year’s success was unexpected and should not cause a sense of being competitive next year. They should use 2009 as a consolidation year to let their young players mature, which means keeping all of the young outfielder and pitchers. The worst idea would be giving up a potential 2010 contributor for a 2009 rental like Beltre. If Young or Gomez regress or Span and Casilla were flukes, then the Twins can make better decisions.
The Twins should only trade for or sign players who will be with the team in 2010.
by meatdox on
Oct 21, 2025 10:43 AM EDT
reply
0 recs
Crede and Hardy
I like the idea of signing Crede to a one year deal as it’s been rumored that he wants to do that anyhow to get his value back up after an injury laden couple of years.
Beyond that I’d love to see the Twins go hard after Hardy. While not the greatest defender on earth he could possibly switch to 2B and let Casilla take over at SS. As long as Hardy doesn’t have the same “I can’t turn and throw syndrome” that Brendan Harris has. I don’t know what they’d have to give up but I’m thinking one of either Blackburn/Perkins and a couple decent prospects.
This brings 50-60 homeruns worth of power to the Twins and what’s greater is it’s both from the right side where the Twins need it from. This combined with what I think will be modest increases from Morneau, Cuddyer, Kubel, and Young could make the Twins a legitimate power lineup heading into 2009.
Crede has the potential to nab at least one draft pick and when you take into consideration that Beltre could bring only one prospect as well depending on who signs him then he might not be worth the cost in prospects for him.
Peyton's good but have you ever heard of Jeff George?
by halfchest on
Oct 21, 2025 10:53 AM EDT
reply
0 recs




