Cardinals Preliminary Prospect List
Preliminary prospect list for the Cardinals, after the jump.
Matt Adams 1B
Nicholas Additon LHP
Brian Anderson C
Scott Bittle RHP
Richard Castillo RHP
Adron Chambers OF
Kyle Conley OF
Allen Craig OF-3B
Daniel Descalso 2B
Sam Freeman LHP
David Freese 3B
Jaime Garcia LHP
Scott Gorgen RHP
Tyler Greene SS
Mark Hamilton 1B
Blake Hawksworth RHP
Trey Hearne RHP
Tyler Henley OF
Steven Hill C
Ryan Jackson SS
Jon Jay OF
Daryl Jones OF
Ben Jukich LHP Rule 5
Joe Kelly RHP
Blake King RHP
David Kopp RHP
Pete Kozma SS
Aaron Luna OF
Lance Lynn RHP
Shelby Miller RHP
Adam Ottavino RHP
Oneli Perez RHP
Shane Peterson OF
Adam Reifer RHP
Fernando Salas RHP
Francisco Samuel RHP
Eduardo Sanchez RHP
Scott Schneider RHP
Robert Stock C
P.J. Walters RHP
0 recs |
31 comments
Comments
Others to consider nomination: C.J. Beatty
Toolsy outfielder with hittability question marks. Not a top-20 guy, but possibly worthy of a C grade.
http://www.examiner.com/x-28775-MLB-Draft-Examiner
twitter | jesseburkhart -- draft-related content only
AIM | jb02186
by jesse.burkhart on Dec 10, 2025 4:27 PM EST reply actions 0 recs
Daniel Calhoun
Calhoun has below average fastball velo, but does have a pretty legit change and his control is very impressive. The guy just pounds the zone.
6BB in 48.1 IP in his pro debut +
6 BB in 97.0 IP in his junior year at Murray State = 12 BB in 145.1 IP in 2009
by bereasonable on Dec 10, 2025 4:38 PM EST reply actions 0 recs
Didn't like their draft.
Not one bit.
MLB Bonus Baby - A Draft Blog
by Andy Seiler on Dec 10, 2025 5:09 PM EST reply actions 0 recs
Care to go more in depth?
I have to agree with you that the Cardinals 2009 draft was pretty boring after the first two picks. Relievers and college players with now upside, just like every other draft they’ve ever had.
by CoolCat23 on Dec 11, 2025 10:03 AM EST up reply actions 0 recs
Just too much risk with the early picks, and not enough upside.
Miller, Stock, and Kelly are probably the most risky combo of players in the first three rounds. Beyond that was unimpressive. Not terribly bad, just not how I’d manage a draft.
MLB Bonus Baby - A Draft Blog
by Andy Seiler on Dec 11, 2025 4:38 PM EST up reply actions 0 recs
Random Thoughts
Guys to strike from the list:
1. Oneli Perez - 27 year old is simply not a prospect
2. Shane Peterson - Oakland As prospect
Guys to add to the list:
1. Roberto De La Cruz - The $1.1M still talks for me. Said another way, I would happily trade the rights to several of the guys above for his upside. He might only have a 20% chance of reaching it but a high ceiling is more intriguing than many of the low floor players on the list:
2. Casey Mulligan - Off the charts combined FIP < 3 in 60 AA innings. This guy is a relief prospect than King or Salas for example.
3. Niko Vasquez - We were clearly too high on him last year but I would guess that we are a bit low on him now. Still a young prospect with potential at a premium position.
As for others that could be interesting:
Blast from the past section - Mark McCormick, Jose Martinez, Tommy Pham, Gary Daley
Toooolsy - Virgil Hill, Tyler Bighames, Cesar Valera, Luis De La Cruz, Jon Edwards, Tommy Pham (again), Cesar Valera, Ryde Rodriguez, D’Marcus Ingrahm
Young Pitchers with Breakout Potential - Anthony Ferrara, Deryk Hooker, Brett Zawacki, Eric Fornataro, Gary Daley
Producers - Charles Cuttler, Andrew Brown, Curt Smith, Xavier Scruggs, Tyler Norrick, Donavan Solano
by Lawless on Dec 10, 2025 5:36 PM EST reply actions 0 recs
Virgil Hill
I think OF Virgil Hill is worthy of at least a C based on tools alone.
by another know it all on Dec 10, 2025 6:01 PM EST reply actions 0 recs
list
Yeah, I forgot about Peterson and already moved him to teh Oakland section.
Perez stays on the list as I think he can be a surprise conbributor in 2010.
Casey Milligan, yeah, that’s a good one. i’ll add him.
Niko Vasquez sucks.
I’ll go with Virgil Hill. He’s interesting. The other tools guys all like like nearly certain busts to me.
Roberto De La Cruz. OK.
Scruggs, OK. He’s cool.
by John Sickels on Dec 10, 2025 6:02 PM EST reply actions 0 recs
Cesar Valera
I think Valera is someone to keep an eye on simply because he got a large bonus(600K?) coming out of the DR last summer. A least one other team must have saw something pretty good in him to drive his price that high.
Vasquez is a tough call. 3rd round pick that was noted for being a pretty good hitter and not likely a shortstop. He was awful last year but he did perform very well in the Appy League. So he can produce against consistent 85-90 MPH fastballs and maybe some average curves. Hopefully he can rebound.
by UncleBuck44 on Dec 11, 2025 10:21 AM EST up reply actions 0 recs
list
Matt Adams 1B
Nicholas Additon LHP
Brian Anderson C
Scott Bittle RHP
Richard Castillo RHP
Adron Chambers OF
Kyle Conley OF
Allen Craig OF-3B
Roberto De La Cruz 3B
Daniel Descalso 2B
Sam Freeman LHP
David Freese 3B
Jaime Garcia LHP
Scott Gorgen RHP
Tyler Greene SS
Mark Hamilton 1B
Blake Hawksworth RHP
Trey Hearne RHP
Tyler Henley OF
Steven Hill C
Virgil Hill OF
D’Marcus Ingram OF
Ryan Jackson SS
Jon Jay OF
Daryl Jones OF
Ben Jukich LHP Rule 5
Joe Kelly RHP
Blake King RHP
David Kopp RHP
Pete Kozma SS
Lance Lynn RHP
Shelby Miller RHP B
Casey Mulligan RHP
Adam Ottavino RHP
Oneli Perez RHP
Adam Reifer RHP
Fernando Salas RHP
Francisco Samuel RHP
Eduardo Sanchez RHP
Scott Schneider RHP
Robert Stock C
P.J. Walters RHP C
by John Sickels on Dec 10, 2025 6:05 PM EST reply actions 0 recs
I need to cut two guys
I need to cut two guys. Thinking Ryan Jackson and…..who? Some of you want Oneli cut. Who would the other cutting option be?
by John Sickels on Dec 10, 2025 6:06 PM EST reply actions 0 recs
Peterson
With the A’s
"Chicks dig the long ball, although fat chicks will settle for warning track power" - Nick Diamond
by hero66 on Dec 10, 2025 7:04 PM EST up reply actions 0 recs
trey hearne?
Trey hearne? dumpable?
by John Sickels on Dec 10, 2025 6:15 PM EST reply actions 0 recs
hearne
and possibly freeman…
by another know it all on Dec 10, 2025 6:17 PM EST reply actions 0 recs
freeman
freeman is a KU guy so I don’t want to dump him….Very good arm too. But his command stinks…he might have to go.
by John Sickels on Dec 10, 2025 6:18 PM EST up reply actions 0 recs
ahhh
picked in the 32nd in ’08… not sure if his ceiling was ever more than organizational depth. Still young though
by another know it all on Dec 10, 2025 6:22 PM EST reply actions 0 recs
freeman
He can get his fastball up into the 90s with plenty of movement. Main problem is command.
by John Sickels on Dec 10, 2025 6:23 PM EST up reply actions 0 recs
list
Matt Adams 1B
Brian Anderson C
Scott Bittle RHP
Richard Castillo RHP
Adron Chambers OF
Kyle Conley OF
Allen Craig OF-3B
Roberto De La Cruz 3B
Daniel Descalso 2B
Sam Freeman LHP
David Freese 3B
Jaime Garcia LHP
Scott Gorgen RHP
Tyler Greene SS
Mark Hamilton 1B
Blake Hawksworth RHP
Trey Hearne RHP
Tyler Henley OF
Tyler Herron RHP
Steven Hill C
Virgil Hill OF
D’Marcus Ingram OF
Jon Jay OF
Daryl Jones OF
Ben Jukich LHP Rule 5
Joe Kelly RHP
Blake King RHP
David Kopp RHP
Pete Kozma SS
Lance Lynn RHP
Shelby Miller RHP B
Casey Mulligan RHP
Tyler Norrick LHP
Adam Ottavino RHP
Oneli Perez RHP
Adam Reifer RHP
Fernando Salas RHP
Francisco Samuel RHP
Eduardo Sanchez RHP
Scott Schneider RHP
Robert Stock C
P.J. Walters RHP C
cutting additon in favor of tyler herron. Still need to cut a couple of guys here.
by John Sickels on Dec 10, 2025 6:34 PM EST reply actions 0 recs
Tyler Herron
He was cut and in the Pirates system I believe.
Yadi is my hero
by Big Phil on Dec 10, 2025 6:46 PM EST up reply actions 0 recs
herron
Yes, you’re right. Herron was cut in November and is now with pittsburgh. that helps the list.
by John Sickels on Dec 10, 2025 7:08 PM EST reply actions 0 recs
working list
Matt Adams 1B
Nick Additon LHP
Brian Anderson C
Scott Bittle RHP
Adron Chambers OF
Kyle Conley OF
Allen Craig OF-3B
Roberto De La Cruz 3B
Daniel Descalso 2B
Sam Freeman LHP
David Freese 3B
Jaime Garcia LHP
Scott Gorgen RHP
Tyler Greene SS
Mark Hamilton 1B
Blake Hawksworth RHP
Trey Hearne RHP
Tyler Henley OF
Steven Hill C
Virgil Hill OF
D’Marcus Ingram OF
Jon Jay OF
Daryl Jones OF
Ben Jukich LHP Rule 5
Joe Kelly RHP
Blake King RHP
David Kopp RHP
Pete Kozma SS
Lance Lynn RHP
Shelby Miller RHP B
Casey Mulligan RHP
Adam Ottavino RHP
Oneli Perez RHP
Adam Reifer RHP
Fernando Salas RHP
Francisco Samuel RHP
Eduardo Sanchez RHP
Scott Schneider RHP
Robert Stock C
P.J. Walters RHP C
by John Sickels on Dec 10, 2025 7:40 PM EST reply actions 0 recs
Bottom of this list...
Bumpable…
Oneli Perez
D’Marcus Ingrahm
Blake Hawksworth (not truly a prospect anymore in my mind…)
Ben Jukich
Fernando Salas
by Lawless on Dec 11, 2025 12:32 PM EST up reply actions 0 recs
Tommy Pham, plus four 17-year-olds
Worthy of consideration:
Tommy Pham, 21-yr-old plus CF’er who steals bases at a good % (75-80% two years running), posted a merely league-ave. OPS just under .700 in the FSL…but .750 away from Palm Beach (hitter’s graveyard), and .800 over the second half.
Pham Iso. Slg. Home .101 Road .189
1st half .103 2nd half .194
Four kids: SS Cesar Valera .640 OPS not bad for a 17-yr-old shortstop in the GCL; then three other kids, all in the Dominican Summer League.
Grabiel Hernandez, also shortstop. Solid glovework reputation, OPS 150 points above league, 26-for-30 SB’s, walk rate above ave. & K rate lower than league, too.
Oscar Taveras. Just turned 17 in June, OPS 40 points above league, 7 assists from CF in just 37 games (1 error), also, like Hernandez, solid BB/K/AB ratios.
Luis Perez. (micro-sample alert!) Just 90 PA’s, but very hard to ignore an OPS more than 200 points above league, married to a 22/8 BB/K, and 39% CS rate behind the dish. Slash stats: .308/.494/.431.
Interesting longshots all. Who would I bump to make room for the above quintet? Lesse. Hamilton, Hearne, Ingram, Kopp, and O. Perez.
Oh, and CF Michael Swinson ripped a hole in the Appy League at 19 this year: .338/.425/.541, sound strikezone management, too, at 11/17 in 74 AB’s. Gotta be top 25-30.
Arky Nieto has to be there as well. He’ll still be 20 on Opening Day 2010, and he’s already had success across low & high-A (116/35 K/BB in 135 IP, and only 7 HR’s allowed).
Don’t know who to bump for the latter pair. OK, Blake King & Virgil Hill.
by Mekonsrock on Dec 11, 2025 1:26 AM EST reply actions 0 recs
+ 1
On Grabiel Hernandez.
Yadi is my hero
by Big Phil on Dec 11, 2025 12:33 PM EST reply actions 0 recs
dominican summer league
Not going to do Dominican Summer League guys. I have to draw the line somewhere.
by John Sickels on Dec 11, 2025 2:47 PM EST reply actions 0 recs
Donovan Solano
Future utility guy who may have a MLB career; split time between AAA & AA as a 21 year old last year. Superficially decent numbers in a smaller sample size in AAA (an empty, BABIP dependent .323), superficially awful numbers in AA (super low BABIP), played SS, 2B, 3B. Had nice scouting reports when he was 18ish, haven’t heard lately, or what kind of defense. But, he could end up having a career.
by gogotabata on Dec 11, 2025 3:35 PM EST reply actions 0 recs
oneli
I’m leaving Oneli in the book but am creating a seperate “free agent” category for guys who are wandering around. His place on the Cardinals list will be taken by Tommy Pham.
by John Sickels on Dec 11, 2025 10:42 PM EST reply actions 0 recs
Fair enough...
…but does that mean Wagner Mateo wouldn’t have made the top 30-40? (If he’d played a partial 2009 season in the DSL, I mean.) Not trying to trap you, John; just askin’. :)
We all forgot Mr. Patience & Power Aaron Luna—-or at least I did. Pretty sure his Peak Davenport Translation has the bat good enough for starting corner OF, and Sean Smith’s defensive yardstick pegs him an OK gloveman at 2nd base, at least for now.
Any opinions or info, John, on teen southpaws Anthony Ferrara, Hector Hernandez, or oversized Kevin Siegrist?
Finally, just a thanks for all the work you do here, and at that other place before. Merry Christmas, Mr. Sickels!
by Mekonsrock on Dec 12, 2025 5:55 PM EST reply actions 0 recs
just curious
you do know the cardinals don’t have wagner mateo anymore?
I am the Batman
by CodyG on Dec 13, 2025 7:14 PM EST up reply actions 0 recs








