clock menu more-arrow no yes mobile

Filed under:

Build a Team from Scratch

New, 53 comments

Build a Team from Scratch

In the All Questions Answered thread on Thursday, a reader asked me "If you could start a team based only on minor league players, what would your rotation and lineup be?"

I threw a lineup together really quickly, but it is an interesting question. My idea here was to build a team , using ONLY players currently in the minors, that 1) would be good in the long run but 2) had a chance to win at least a few games right away.

Here is what I came up with:


C: Devon Mesoraco
1B: Eric Hosmer
2B: Dustin Ackley
3B: Lonnie Chisenhall
SS: Jose Iglesias
LF: Eric Thames
CF: Mike Trout
RF: Bryce Harper
DH: Jesus Montero
P: S. Miller, K. Gibson, M. Banuelos, D. Betances, M. Moore
CL: Z. Stewart

I'm actually not a big Jose Iglesias guy, but I wanted to be strong up the middle defensively right away. If I was going on pure upside, this team would look different. It is NOT A LIST OF WHO I THINK IS THE TOP PROSPECT at each position. I don't think Eric Thames is a better prospect than Dom Brown, for example, and I don't think Iglesias is a better prospect than Manny Machado. Some people took me to task for not including Julio Teheran, thinking that I like Gibson better than him for example, but that's not the case. This was thrown together quickly and I'd probably pick Teheran over Miller with a re-do.

I would structure my lineup:  1-Trout  2-Ackley  3-Hosmer  4-Montero  5-Thames  6-Harper  7-Mesoraco  8-Chisenhall  9-Iglesias

Anyway, if faced with the same question, what would your team look like? Remember the conditions:

1) Only guys in the minors
2) You ARE building with an eye to the future, BUT
3) You also want to avoid being completely embarrassed this year.