Minor League Ball: An SB Nation Community

Navigation: Jump to content areas:


Pro Quality. Fan Perspective.
Login-facebook
Around SBN: SB Nation and National Football Post Announce Partnership

Albert Pujols Prospect Retro

Prospect Retro: Albert Pujols

Per reader request, a prospect retro for Albert Pujols.

Pujols was drafted by the Cardinals in the 13th round in 1999, out of Maple Woods Community College in Missouri. He was considered to be a promising bat, but there were questions about his defense, and many scouts thought he was too fat. Some scouts also questioned his listed birthday of January 16, 1980. He was born in the Dominican Republic.

Pujols made his pro debut in 2000, hitting .324/.389/.565  in 109 games for Class A Peoria, with 38 walks and just 37 strikeouts in 395 at-bats. He also got into 14 games at Class A Potomac, hitting .284/.341/.481, and went 3-for-14 in three games at Triple-A Memphis. I was extremely impressed with his bat, and gave him a Grade A- in the 2001 Minor League Scouting Notebook, rating him as the Number 18 prospect in baseball. I was a bit ahead of the curve on this. Baseball America put three different Top 50 lists in their '01 prospect book, written up separately by Jim Callis, Allan Simpson, and Will Lingo. The highest ranking for Pujols was #39.

While most people, including me, thought that Pujols would start 2001 in Double-A, he had a terrific spring training and won a starting job in the Cardinals lineup, hitting .329/.403/.610, quickly emerging as one of the very best hitters in baseball. His power has developed beyond where it was in A-ball, and he's maintained his exceptional plate discipline.

Did Pujols really come out of nowhere? He was a year ahead of schedule, but it's also true that Baseball America was tracking him, and I was tracking him, and other experts were tracking him too.

Comparable Players to Albert Pujols, through Age 24

Frank Robinson
Hank Aaron
Joe Medwick
Eddie Murray
Rico Carty
Jack Clark
Will Clark

When the WORST guy on your comp list is Jack Clark, you are a special hitter.

I think the only real question about Pujols is his age curve.

0 recs  |  Comment 25 comments

Story-email Email Printer Print

Comments

Display:

Thank you, John. :)
About his age curve, I think he may improve slightly toward his age-30 season, and in his mid 30's, tail off a little in the power categories, and maybe play to 40 or so.

Basically, if this were a graph, a slight increase toward the age 30 season, and slowly tailing off after.

by craig3410 on Sep 27, 2025 12:16 PM EDT reply actions   0 recs

age
What if he is closer to 30 already?

I'm not trying to dis on Pujols.  He is one of the guys I go to see when the Cardinals come to Milwaukee.  Not only is he an exceptional player, he is an exception person as well (from what I can tell).  Last season I sat 3 row behind the Cards dug out and before his ab's or coming in from the field between innings he gave away his batting gloves amoung other things to the younger people in the crowd.  It was at the end of the season and the Cards had the NL wrapped up.  Rolen/Renteria didn't even play (which bummed me out, I got the tickets way in advance of the game in that location to see the defense from Rolen/Rent). That said, I couldn't help but think he was a lot older seeing him up close.  I was 28 at the time and to think he was 4 to 5 years younger was sort amazing to a) believe or b) he didn't get blessed with aging looks for someone in the early to mid 20's.

Just my .2cents, he is a special hitter regardless of age and is intense to watch before/during the game how locked in he is for a meaningless game.

by FRANCHISEv2 on Sep 27, 2025 12:52 PM EDT up reply actions   0 recs

There is no way
That Albert Pujols is 25 years old. Yes, he is one of the best hitters in baseball. And YES, it also seems like he is one hell of a person. But there is just no way! I would say he looks closer to 29, heck Im 32 and he looks older than me!
Does anyone remember why his age wasnt verified back when all the guys were coming up older than their listed age a couple years back? Was it something to do with Albert already living here in the US? Did he go to high school here? Just curious...

by fatfrank on Sep 27, 2025 7:02 PM EDT up reply actions   0 recs

His birth certificate has been checked enough time
that if it was wrong, we'd know by now.

He's a very special hitter, and altough it seems like he's 30, he's not.

BTW, I'm 18, and I look like I'm about 15. :)

by craig3410 on Sep 27, 2025 9:14 PM EDT up reply actions   0 recs

Checked
Pujols  has been checked a lot from what i hear and the fact that he went to HS and college here in the states lends credibility to his age.  At this point I'd be extremely surprised if he turned out to be older.

by CrimsonLiederhosen on Sep 27, 2025 10:00 PM EDT up reply actions   0 recs

age
The rumors are awfully persistent -- but I don't think that's what John S was saying.  It isn't whether he's 25 or 29, but how his particular experience stacks up against the aggregate age curve.

As is implicit on this comment thread: is it Frank Thomas or Ted Williams?

I'd bet on the former, but only a nickel.

by wcw on Sep 28, 2025 3:21 AM EDT up reply actions   0 recs

He went to high school
in Independence, MO (home of Harry Truman!).  They had to do some checks before he could enroll.  I would give more credence to them than to us just theorizing based on how he looks.  It's not like he could pull an El Duque and claim he came over in a raft and say he was whatever age sounded good.  Pujols had to have a background check.

Hell, Barry looks only about 35 he must be 35!

by count sutton on Sep 28, 2025 9:23 AM EDT up reply actions   0 recs

AFL
I remember watching him at the AFL and he was hitting monster home runs, yet the folks at baseballhq were not that high on him.  Jason Romano and Antonio Perez seemed to be getting more attention.  You have to admit that the analysts were completely caught flat footed on this one.  BaseballAmerica ranked him quite low, BaseballHQ ranked him quite low.  Everyone was excited over Corey Patterson, Josh Hamilton, Carlos Pena, Joe Crede, Joe Borchard, Antonio Perez, Alex Escobar, Jason Romano, Hee Seop Choi and Sean Burroughs.  Nobody came close to seeing him getting this good this fast and even after his great season, many analysts doubted that he was really all that good (see past Baseball Forecasters).  Even after St. Louis traded away their starting 3rd baseman (Fernando Tatis) nobody seemed to think that Albert would even take the starting role.  Sometimes the big league clubs know something that the analysts don't see.

by LindInMoskva on Sep 27, 2025 1:04 PM EDT reply actions   0 recs

One of the best hitters
I think what is amazing is that Pujols has incresaed his plate and strike zone discipline each year... he has walked more each year and has struck out less than 70 times a year...

And he's defenitely special with his ability to not only hit 40+ HR's a year but also 40+ doubles as well as hit above .330... probably one of the best pure all around hitters in a long long while

by blinkshot on Sep 27, 2025 1:14 PM EDT reply actions   0 recs

Frank Thomas
He's not on Pujols' comp list, but I think he is an interesting comparison.

The Age trend says players hit their peak from 27-30, but I can't imagine Pujols getting much better.

That's what brings me to Thomas.  He was a two time MVP early in his career as we all know.  His peak season was at age 26.  He was still MVP caliber from 27-29 (high 170s OPS+), but he wasn't able to build upwards from the 212 OPS+ he put up in 1994.

I think that is the more likely path for Pujols than following say Ted Williams who was;

  1. on his own planet for a couple years through age 23
  2. went to war
  3. came back and picked up right where he left off
  4. Around age 29 slipped to being merely awesome before going to war again
  5. Came back in 1954 and was otherworldly again

by sfjg85 on Sep 27, 2025 1:14 PM EDT reply actions   0 recs

And just another thing
I haven't really looked into #'s such as BABIP and LD% and other things this year but is there any reason in particular why this year Pujols #'s are down (though they are better than just about every player cept D. Lee).

Do the injuries to Rolen, Walker, and the down year by Edmonds hurt Pujols #'s that much or has he just been unlucky? His OBP has gone up but his SLG is his worst since 2002. And what would one rate his defense at 1B now?

by blinkshot on Sep 27, 2025 1:18 PM EDT reply actions   0 recs

Defense
He actually did well in win shares in 2004, but I haven't focused on his 2005 numbers.  Pinto's numbers had him above JT Snow in 2004.
http://anaheimangelsblog.blogspot.com/2005/02/pmr-1b-david-pintos-first-base-numbers.html

by sfjg85 on Sep 27, 2025 1:42 PM EDT up reply actions   0 recs

Theory
Pujols is probably getting pitched around a lot more this year with Rolen/Walker out/ineffective. Fewer good pitches equals less opportunity for raking and more walks.

by AucklandGM on Sep 27, 2025 5:36 PM EDT up reply actions   0 recs

d
His errors are fairly plentiful but he makes a ton of nice plays at first and gets to balls too. His defense continues to improve and he is probably behind Helton and Lee but not too many others in the NL at the position

by rickieweekshof2028 on Sep 27, 2025 7:57 PM EDT reply actions   0 recs

thomas
thought the comparison to him was right on...

by johnstjc on Sep 27, 2025 9:40 PM EDT reply actions   0 recs

re entry
Haven't all the age corrections been a result of players re-entering the country after tougher screening was put in place? I'd be curious to know if Mr. Pujols has left the USA in the last few years.....

by bluechipper on Sep 27, 2025 10:39 PM EDT reply actions   0 recs

Yeah let's check his criminal record too
Come on, enough with the conspiracy theories.

by sfjg85 on Sep 27, 2025 11:06 PM EDT up reply actions   0 recs

SFJG
it makes you wonder whether these guys are going to rest until they tear the kid down.  He's 25.  There's absolutely ZERO evidence that he isn't.

by CrimsonLiederhosen on Sep 27, 2025 11:19 PM EDT up reply actions   0 recs

of course
a couple months ago there was zero evidence that palmiero used steroids.

but what difference does it make? his stats are impressive and hes the best hitter in baseball right now regardless of when he was born.

actually, maybe he wasnt born, that could explain things, he was genetically created in a lab somewhere to be the ultimate right handed power hitter.

by lmao on Sep 28, 2025 1:07 AM EDT reply actions   0 recs

Palmeiro
I am not totally convinced that Selig didn't set Palmeiro up to take a fall.  Selig needed to catch a big fish with this new testing, and Bonds has been hurt all year.  Who better to take down than a guy who is in the twilight of his career and right after he set a milestone.  Just something to think about.

by JFP on Sep 28, 2025 12:14 PM EDT reply actions   0 recs

re: setup
How would that be worth the risk for Selig to 'set up' a player? If a setup was proved it would do irreversable harm to Selig & MLB.

Raffy used. Raffy Got caught. All MLB did was not look the other way.

Your version makes for a good Oliver Stone conspiracy film, but I don't see it as realistic.

by natsfan2005 on Sep 28, 2025 12:18 PM EDT up reply actions   0 recs

for conspiracy theorists
why is it Bonds missed the entire year.  Did he have to have thsoe surgeries?  Isn't it ironic that he missed all this season and came back with 2 weeks to play?

LOL!

by So Cal Bob on Sep 28, 2025 12:24 PM EDT up reply actions   0 recs

IF Pujols was already
a citizen of the US, or had some kind of residency they wouldn't have checked and that's why I asked. I was under the assumption that he was living here before 2001/2002 when all these age discrepancies came about. (See post above by BLUECHIPPER)

I don't know the complete facts and that's why I posed the question. But it seems to me if went to high school here then his birth certificate would have not been put under the scrutiny that some of the foreign players are put under today. There just wasn't the need 10 years back.
From my understanding, if a person/player had residency here in the US then the need to verify their work visa when the came back to the US was not there. Another example off the top of my head is Miguel Tejada. Again I dont know the exact stipulation, but I know its something along those lines.

Look, I love watching Pujols and think the things he has done are amazing. It has nothing to do with trying to tear the "KID" down, but I just don't believe the guy is 25 years old.
I guess nobody will probalby ever no for sure on Pujols or some of these other foregin players.
However, I do think Pujols will still be proucing at the level he is now in five years when he's 30 (Or 35, in "the guys trying to tear him down" mind) Hell, even Julio Franco is still a productive Major leaguer and look he's like 47 or 55 the "conspiracy theorists" say!

by fatfrank on Sep 28, 2025 3:58 PM EDT reply actions   0 recs

circumstanial evidence
Bill James had a study in one of his old baseball abstracts about how players develop as they age. How they tend to improve more between age 18 and 19 than between 19 and 20. Likewise they tended to improve more between 19 and 20 than they did between 20 and 21, and so on until most of them stopped improving some time in their late 20's. These are just tendencies of course, there is nothing to say an individual player might not show his greatest improvement between 24 and 25.

Pujols made an incredible leap forward in 2001 going from hitting .324/.387/.565 in the midwest league to hitting .329/.403/.610 in the majors.

That is an amazing improvement to make in one year, actually having a better year in the majors than the one he had the year before in low A.

It seems to me that huge leap forward is at least circumstanial evidence that Pujols is the age he says, since it is much more likely for a player to make that leap between 20 and 21, than between 24 and 25, or whatever the real age that some think Pujols was at the time.

by tinsmith on Sep 29, 2025 11:26 AM EDT reply actions   0 recs

replying to your previous comment
liebe poesie in porto portugal und pistole biblische geschichten fur kinder vitamin d uv reise frankfurt stuttgarter zeitung lauf doktor pc rock am ring limp bart simpson on keramag wc hotel baglioni cala del porto grundlagen bwl martina kern diamanten online can bus grundlagen connie palmen speed most wanted for pc pfister boote hotel tivoli porto net internet service die dynamische registrierung oder die aufhebung der registrierung recklinghauser zeitung mobel walther guitar tabs rock fahrradteile ringe kampf um mittelerde inventory management software ich kuchen gemacht schuh verloren

by Isisaston on Dec 19, 2025 5:15 PM EST reply actions   0 recs

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

Minor League Ball: Where the Future of Baseball is Discussed
Start posting on Minor League Ball »

Join SB Nation and dive into communities focused on all your favorite teams.

Connect_with_facebook

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recommended FanPosts

Small
If Mejia starts the year in the majors: Just how stupid?

Recent FanPosts

Small
Reds 5th starter
Small
Prospects moving up
Small
Community Prospect #89
Punto_small
Milton Bradley = Kanye West of Baseball?
Small
Adam Miller
Small
Second Basemen
Small
Community Prospect #88
Small
Danny Duffy Retires
Small
Runoff for Community Prospect #87
Small
Community Prospect #87

+ New FanPost All FanPosts >

In Association With

MLB -- FanHouse

  • History Made, Ichiro Eyes Immortality
  • Leake Could Flow Straight to Cincinnati
  • Yankees' Rotation Set, but Future Unclear
  • Jim Edmonds Has Spot With Brewers if He Wants It

SBNation.com Recent Stories

Jim Edmonds' Comeback On Track: Brewers Add Veteran To Opening Day Roster

SB Nation's 2010 MLB Previews: Los Angeles Dodgers, Leaving Unfixed The Unbroken

Phil Hughes Named Yankees Fifth Starter; Joba Chamberlain Headed To Bullpen

More from SBNation.com >


Managers

Carew_small John Sickels


Site Meter