Grady Sizemore (AP)
Cleveland Indians Top 20 Pre-Season Prospects in Review
1) Adam Miller, RHP
Pitching again after missing early part of the year with elbow trouble. Results so far are not impressive: 5.04 ERA in 7 starts, 19/10 K/BB in 31 innings, way off his '04 numbers. I still worry about that elbow.
2) Grady Sizemore, OF
Hitting .278/.326/.442 for the Indians, 22 doubles, 9 homers, 12 steals. Solid player, will get better.
3) Michael Aubrey, 1B
Hit .283/.336/.462 in 28 games for Double-A Akron, before going on the shelf with back trouble.
4) Franklin Gutierrez, OF
Hitting just .235/.293/.398 for Akron, having major problems with strike zone judgment. His status is slipping; he seems to have stalled out, having problems converting his tools into skills.
5) Brad Snyder, OF
Hit .278/.365/.431 at Class A Kinston, leading to promotion to Akron, where he's at .257/.338/.493 so far. Good power, adequate strike zone judgment though a high strikeout rate. Holding his own.
6) Ryan Garko, C-1B
Hitting .284/.363/.485 with 14 homers for Triple-A Buffalo. Doing just fine, will be ready in 2006.
7) Fernando Cabrera, RHP
0.99 ERA with 62/9 K/BB in 45 innings for Buffalo, earning a promotion to Cleveland where he's allowed 2 runs in his first 9.1 innings. I like him a lot, should be a bullpen mainstay.
8) Jeremy Sowers, LHP
Since being promoted to Double-A, is 1-1 but with a 2.04 ERA in 6 starts, 33/7 K/BB in 35 innings. Doing very well indeed, keeping hitters off-balance with his ability to throw strikes and change speeds.
9) Francisco Cruceta, RHP
5.55 ERA in 24 games, 12 starts at Buffalo, 83/28 K/BB but 101 hits allowed in 86 innings. Stats have never quite lived up to his reputation as a prospect, and it is catching up with him this year. Status slipping.
10) Nick Pesco, RHP
4.05 ERA, 6-9 in 19 starts for Kinston, 68/28 K/BB in 107 innings, 121 hits allowed. Not terrible, not great. Best attribute is good control, but K/IP and H/IP are disappointing.
11) Justin Hoyman, RHP
9 starts at Class A Lake County, with a 3.00 ERA and 36/18 K/BB in 48 innings, before being sidelined with elbow trouble.
12) Kevin Kouzmanoff, 3B
Hit .346/.398/.616 in 49 games for Kinston, obviously strong performance, but playing time limited by a back injury.
13) Fausto Carmona, RHP
1.95 ERA in 5 starts since being promoted to Buffalo, with a sound 25/2 K/BB in 37 innings. Possible September call-up, but like Cruceta his underlying ratios bear watching.
14) Brandon Pinckney, SS
Hitting just .223/.260/.310 at Kinston, very disappointing performance considering his performance last year. At this point, a utilityman at best.
15) Ryan Goleski, OF
.214/.267/.367 at Kinston, with 99 strikeouts in 346 at-bats. Another major disappointment, this will knock him off prospect lists.
16) Scott Lewis, LHP
14 strikeouts in his first 9 innings at Mahoning Valley in the New York-Penn League. Sample too small to be meaningful.
17) Matt Whitney, 3B
Hitting just .222/.309/.281 at Lake County. Another guy not living up to potential.
18) Jake Dittler, RHP
3.33 ERA at Akron, 74/43 K/BB in 127 innings, 133 hits allowed. Has a pretty ERA, but has allowed 20 unearned runs, and his K/IP and H/IP marks are below average. Don't fall for any hype you may hear.
19) Tony Sipp, LHP
Posted a fine 2.22 ERA in 12 starts for Lake County, with a 71/19 K/BB in 69 innings. Promoted to Kinston, is 1-1, 3.75 in 5 starts, with a 30/12 K/BB in 24 innings. Solid performance in all categories, will move up the list.
20) Mike Butia, OF
Hit .252/.315/.379 in 74 games at Lake County, very mediocre numbers. Promoted to Kinston this month and is struggling with a .178/.229/.378 mark. Has some pop, but not much finesse or polish at the plate.
Injuries have been a factor here, but several Cleveland prospects have just not played as well as anticipated. This system looked loaded at the beginning of the year, but things can change quickly.
Loading comments...