clock menu more-arrow no yes mobile

Filed under:

Discussion Question: Maybin vs. McCutchen

New, 19 comments

Ok, so at this point who is a better prospect, Cameron Maybin or Andrew McCutchen? I still think Maybin, but is that right? Maybin's physical tools are better than McCutchen, but his strikeout rate is a lot higher. Neither has dominated this year. Maybin's +11 OPS is better than McCutchen's +3, but McCutchen has been playing in the more difficult Triple-A environment.

So, if you could have one or the other for your favorite team's farm system, who would it be and why?