clock menu more-arrow no yes

Filed under:

Pick a Prospect

New, 34 comments

Here's an interesting discussion question for you to mull over while you want for the supplemental first round section of my mock draft:

You are given a choice between choosing two catchers. Both are considered equally signable for an equal amount, and they are the same age, so you are picking on pure talent alone. Below are future grades of their tools.

Player A - Hit: 65, Power: 60, Run: 50, Arm: 65, Glove: 65, OFP: 61

Player B - Hit: 55, Power: 80, Run: 45, Arm: 80, Glove: 50, OFP: 62

Based on tools alone, with no question of makeup, which player do you choose and why?