FanPost

Which Roster Would You Prefer

We had a discussion a week or two ago about two dynasty league trades.  Wanted to see what people thought of the rosters that resulted from them - which roster would you prefer, the first roster (my actual, post trade and draft roster) or the second (what my roster would have looked like without the trades and with the picks I would have made instead).  In evaluating the rosters, assume that my major league roster has young studs and depth at almost all positions other than 3B:

Roster A

Matt Wieters
Travis Snider  

Madison Bumgarner

Pedro Alvarez
Derek Holland

Justin Smoak
Brian Matusz

Michael Bowden

Reid Brignac

Dayan Viciedo


Roster B

Travis Snider

Madison Bumgarner

Colby Rasmus

Neftali Feliz

Derek Holland

Chris Tillman

Michael Bowden

Reid Brignac

Matt Dominguez

Dayan Viciedo