Fantasy Help: Trade for Smoak OR Draft a Beckham & a Pitcher?

Have to bother the community one more time with my fantasy league! It looks like my draft is going to go 1- Smoak, 2-Hosmer. Would I be crazy to trade the #3 & #4 up for the #1 to take Smoak and the #11?

Or should I just take two of:

  • Gordon Beckham
  • Tim Beckham
  • Brian Matusz
  • Derek Holland.

I know a lot of people answered Smoak as the BPA in my last question... is he worth two of these guys? Or am I losing my perspective? I thought he was going to drop to me and got settled on taking him... is this pre-buyer's remorse or is Smoak worth it??