FINAL Community Prospect List (+ Honorable Mention Results)

I'd like to start by giving shout-outs to everybody who made this possible: Brickhaus for starting us off until he got bored and started screwing off; whoever thought of this originally back at midseason before Brickhaus stole their idea, I forget who that was and it doesn't matter; myself of course; daveh and BaseballBrain for filling in the gaps; and Havok for bringing it home.  

I'd also like to thank all of you little people out there who voted and participated in the discussions; this wouldn't have been possible without you.  Well, it would have - in fact the list probably would have been better if nobody had participated but me - but we have to say that.  I personally think that we made a pretty good list, except maybe toward the end; that we all (hopefully) learned some things; and that if nothing else, we had some good arguments.  

In fact, I'm pretty sure of that last item. Here's the final list.

  01. Alex Gordon, 3B (KC)
  02. Delmon Young, OF (TB)
  ( Daisuke Matsuzaka, RHP (BOS) )
  03. Philip Hughes, RHP (NYY)
  04. Brandon Wood, SS (ANA)
  05. Homer Bailey, RHP (CIN)
  06. Billy Butler, OF (KC)
  07. Cameron Maybin, OF (DET)
  08. Chris Young, OF (ARI)
  09. Justin Upton, OF (ARI)
  10. Matt Garza, RHP (MIN)
  11. Andy LaRoche, 3B (LAD)
  12. Troy Tulowitzki, SS (COL)
  13. Jay Bruce, OF (CIN)
  14. Reid Brignac, SS (TB)
  15. Elijah Dukes, OF (TB)
  16. Andrew McCutchen, OF (PIT)
  17. Carlos Gonzalez, OF (ARI)
  18. Adam Miller, RHP (CLE)
  19. Evan Longoria, 3B (TB)
  20. Tim Lincecum, RHP (SF)
  21. Mike Pelfrey, RHP (NYM)
  22. Yovani Gallardo, RHP (MIL)
  23. Andrew Miller, LHP (DET)
  24. Jose Tabata, OF (NYY)
  25. Ryan Braun, 3B (MIL)
  26. Scott Elbert, LHP (LAD)
  27. Fernando Martinez, OF (NYM)
  28. Luke Hochevar, RHP (KC)
  29. Clayton Kershaw, LHP (LAD)
  30. Adam Jones, OF (SEA)
  31. Jason Hirsh, RHP (COL)
  32. James Loney, 1B (LAD)
  33. Hunter Pence, OF (HOU)
  34. Nick Adenhart, RHP (ANA)
  35. Joey Votto, 1B (CIN)
  36. Colby Rasmus, OF (STL)
  37. Jeff Niemann, RHP (TB)
  38. Daric Barton, 1B (OAK)
  39. Brandon Erbe, RHP (BAL)
  40. Adam Lind, OF/DH (TOR)
  41. Jacoby Ellsbury, OF (BOS)
  42. Felix Pie, OF (CHC)
  43. Chris Iannetta, C (COL)
  44. Phil Humper, RHP (NYM)
  45. Josh Fields, 3B (CHW)
  46. Ian Stewart, 3B (COL)
  47. Jarrod Saltalamacchia, C (ATL)
  48. John Danks, SP (CHW)
  49. Billy Rowell, 3B (BAL)
  50. Travis Snider, OF (TOR)
  51. Franklin Morales, LHP (COL)
  52. Kevin Kouzmanoff, 3B (SD)
  53. Eric Hurley, RHP (TEX)
  54. Chuck Lofgren, LHP (CLE)
  55. Ryan Sweeney, OF (CHW)
  56. Humberto Sanchez, RHP (NYY)
  57. Kevin Slowey, RHP (MIN)
  58. Jacob McGee, LHP (TB)
  59. Jeff Clement, C (SEA)
  60. Troy Patton, LHP (HOU)
  61. Clay Buchholz, RHP (BOS)
  62. Carlos Gomez, OF (NYM)
  63. Elvis Andrus, SS (ATL)
  64. Donald Veal, LHP (CHC)
  65. Joel Guzman, 3B (TB)
  66. Wade Davis, RHP (TB)
  67. Travis Buck, OF (OAK)
  68. Dexter Fowler, OF (COL)
  69. Will Inman, RHP (MIL)
  70. Chris Parmelee, 1B/OF (MIN)
  71. Carlos Carrasco, RHP (PHI)
  72. Dustin Pedroia, 2B (BOS)
  73. Chris Lubanski, OF, (KC)
  74. Erick Aybar, SS (LAA)
  75. Miguel Montero, C (ARI)
  76. Eric Campbell, 3B (ATL)
  77. Michael Bowden, RHP (BOS)
  78. Giovany Gonzalez, LHP (CHW)
  79. Trevor Crowe, OF (CLE)
  80. Joba Chamberlain, RHP (NYY)
  81. Jonathan Sanchez, LHP (SF)
  82. Brad Lincoln, RHP (PIT)
  83. Dellin Betances, RHP (NYY)
  84. Eric Patterson, 2B (CHC)
  85. Brandon Morrow, RHP (SEA)
  86. Ubaldo Jimenez, RHP (COL)
  87. Chris Volstad, RHP (FLA)
  88. Deolis Guerra, RHP (NYM)
  89. Glen Perkins, LHP (MIN)
  90. Nolan Reimold, OF (BAL)
  91. Anthony Swarzak, RHP (MIN)
  92. Hank Conger, C (LAA)
  93. Sean West, LHP (FLA)
  94. Jeremy Hellickson, RHP (TB)
  95. Blake DeWitt, 2B (LAD)
  96. Jaime Garcia, LHP (STL)
  97. Cesar Carrillo, RHP (SD)
  98. Kurt Suzuki, C (OAK)
  99. Matt Sulentic, OF (OAK)
 100. Brent Lillibridge, SS (ATL)

Honorable Mentions (in order, but un-numbered):

  - Neil Walker, C (PIT)
  - Thomas Diamond, RHP (TEX)
  - Jonathan Meloan, RHP (LA)
  - Tyler Clippard, NYY (NYY)
  - Sean Rodriguez, SS (ANA)

As a bonus, here are the HM top 20 finishers (I decided to use jax's 7-3 scale instead of the original 5-1; it didn't change the outcome much but seems better somehow.)

  1. Neil Walker 97
  2. Thomas Diamond 91
  3. Jonathan Meloan 84
  4. Tyler Clippard 84
  5. Sean Rodriguez 76
  6. Cedric Hunter 73
  7. Alberto Callaspo 63
  8. Alexi Casilla 57
  9. Jonny Cueto 54
  10. Kyle Drabek 52
  11. Lars Anderson 39
  12. Angel Villalona 38
  13. Justin Huber 33
  14. Brian Barton 32
  15. Eric Duncan 30
  16. Charlie Haeger 28
  17. Sean Gallagher 22
  18. Mark Reynolds 19
  19. Mike Carp 18
  20. John Mayberry Jr 16
  21. Tony Butler 16
Again, a big thank you to everybody except for those of you who aren't reading this.  Good night, and good luck.  

PS - Should we fold in Iwamura and Igawa somehow now?  

Trending Discussions