American League Rookie of the Year pick: Jeremy Reed, OF, Seattle Mariners. Wins a close vote over Dallas McPherson and Scott Kazmir.
National League Rookie of the Year pick: Garrett Atkins, 3B, Colorado Rockies. This assumes that his hamstring injury is not serious. If it is, all best are off...Jason Dubois would be a candidate if he plays enough. I don't have a lot of confidence in Gavin Floyd right now.