This should be an easy question for many out there.  I know the criteria: 130 ABs, 50 IP, 45 days service outside of September roster expansion.  I also know for 100% fact that service time is cumulative from year to year, ie. on MLB roster 20 days one year, 30 days the next, and lose ROY eligibility.  I also have always thought that ABs and IP were the same way, however, I have recently been told by someone who interpreted the official MLB rule differently from me that IP or AB must be achieved in a single season.

So for example, if a guy pitches 32 innings in 2006, then 23 in 2007 (he now stands at 55 career IP), but does not surpass 45 days service time outside of roster expansion, is this pitcher ROY eligible in 2008?

Here's MLB.com's official wording:
"A player shall be considered a rookie unless, during a previous season or seasons, he has (a) exceeded 130 at-bats or 50 innings pitched in the Major Leagues; or (b) accumulated more than 45 days on the active roster of a Major League club or clubs during the period of 25-player limit (excluding time in the military service and time on the disabled list)."

I see the top prospect list being populated with outfielders, pitchers, some third baseman and shortstops too.  First basemen will be coming soon with Loney and Votto.  But what about second base?

Continue reading this post »

I find the Brewers in the NL to be a very interesting team.  There is some good young talent there.  Of the players on the Brewers, I would say Bill Hall intrigues me the most.  This guy is quietly putting up a season where he could hit 30-35 HRs.  He absolutely crushes left handed pitching, and hits righties for good power, despite a not so good OBP and batting average.  He strikes out a lot and doesn't walk very much, but hits the ball hard.  He seems to be able to play quite a few different positions rather well.  He is having a better major league career so far than minor league career and is just entering his prime years.

Could this guy actually get a little better than he already is?  Is his future probably at 3B or will the Brewers continue to utilize him as a multiposition guy when Hardy comes back?    It just feels like this guy somewhat came out of nowhere last year to become a very, very productive major leaguer.  And his continued success this year shows that it probably isn't a fluke.  I was thinking of requesting a prospect retro on this guy next time John takes requests (and probably still will), because I find these types of players very intriguing.  You know, the types that come into the league with no hype and quietly go on to have nice careers (Placido Polanco is a good example of this).