Voted for Daric Barton on Athletics Nation - 12/02/08 2:59 AM PST

Commented That may be three years, and so what. The A's need relievers too. on AN Community Prospect List - #13 on Athletics Nation - 12/02/08 2:58 AM PST (1 reply)

Commented Wrong. on AN Community Prospect List - #13 on Athletics Nation - 12/02/08 2:57 AM PST

Voted for Henry Rodriguez, RHP on Athletics Nation - 12/02/08 2:56 AM PST

Commented I'm OK with Cardenas at 3B as well. Even if he never develops power, he could be a pretty good player like on Monday's Hot Corner Depth Chart on Athletics Nation - 12/01/08 6:17 PM PST

Commented DeJesus for me. Even at 2B his offense is pretty valuable. on Community Prospect List: #83 on Minor League Ball - 12/01/08 6:11 PM PST (1 reply)

Voted for Ivan DeJesus on Minor League Ball - 12/01/08 6:10 PM PST

Commented Rodriguez again. on AN Community Prospect List - #12 on Athletics Nation - 12/01/08 6:08 PM PST (1 reply)

Commented Actually he was a career minor league reliever so he's not a good comparable on Community Organizational Prospect List - #8 on Athletics Nation - 11/28/08 11:51 PM PST (1 reply)

Commented You can put the Rule 5 guy on the DL but you eventually have to have on A's Shopping List on Athletics Nation - 11/28/08 11:29 PM PST

Commented This discussion misses the crucial reason why Rodriguez is the best remaining pitcher on this list on Community Organizational Prospect List - #8 on Athletics Nation - 11/28/08 11:18 PM PST (1 reply)

Commented Blanks until someone can convince me he's really this much worse than LaPorta on Community Prospect List: #78 on Minor League Ball - 11/28/08 11:08 PM PST (1 reply)

Commented I agree with this but I'd still pick Blanks. on Community Prospect List: #76 on Minor League Ball - 11/27/08 8:24 PM PST (1 reply)

Commented How is he 60 positions worse than Matt LaPorta? on Community Prospect List: #76 on Minor League Ball - 11/27/08 8:23 PM PST (1 reply)

Voted for Kyle Blanks on Minor League Ball - 11/27/08 8:22 PM PST

Commented Oliver Perez has had a great season (145 ERA+) and another very good one (120 ERA+), plus two pretty good ones. on Community Organizational Prospect List - #6 on Athletics Nation - 11/27/08 8:19 PM PST (1 reply)

Commented When did Van Poppel ever strike out 27% of BFP in a season with a 51% GB rate? on Community Organizational Prospect List - #6 on Athletics Nation - 11/27/08 8:01 PM PST

Commented Rodriguez pitched in pretty bad luck last year as well on Community Organizational Prospect List - #6 on Athletics Nation - 11/26/08 9:56 PM PST

Commented Second on Blanks. How is this guy 60+ spots below LaPorta? on Community Prospect List: #75 on Minor League Ball - 11/26/08 9:45 PM PST

Voted for Kyle Blanks on Minor League Ball - 11/26/08 9:43 PM PST

Commented Rodriguez until he's voted in. Tools. Performance. Projectability on Community Organizational Prospect List - #6 on Athletics Nation - 11/26/08 9:42 PM PST (2 replies)

Voted for Henry Rodriguez on Athletics Nation - 11/26/08 9:24 PM PST

Commented I've already penciled in Cardenas for 2011 on In Search Of A Shortstop Prospect on Athletics Nation - 11/26/08 1:55 PM PST

Commented Sure he is. He's better than Michael Young already. on In Search Of A Shortstop Prospect on Athletics Nation - 11/26/08 1:54 PM PST

Commented Cardenas is a 3B prospect on In Search Of A Shortstop Prospect on Athletics Nation - 11/26/08 1:53 PM PST (1 reply)

Commented Ya I don't see him much different than Laporta. on Community Prospect List: #74 on Minor League Ball - 11/26/08 1:42 PM PST

Voted for Kyle Blanks on Minor League Ball - 11/26/08 1:40 PM PST

Commented Danny, care to make the case for Adrian? on Community Organizational Prospect List - #5 on Athletics Nation - 11/26/08 1:33 PM PST (2 replies)

Commented .275/.365/.485 in 350 PA on How Are We Feeling About Chavez? on Athletics Nation - 11/26/08 6:32 AM PST (3 replies)

Voted for Yes. on Athletics Nation - 11/26/08 6:28 AM PST

Commented Why? Giambi's likely to actually take the field. on Furcal looking for homes in the Bay Area, and Nick Johnson to relocate too? on Athletics Nation - 11/26/08 6:27 AM PST (2 replies)

Commented Denorfia's too much? How about Murton then? on Furcal looking for homes in the Bay Area, and Nick Johnson to relocate too? on Athletics Nation - 11/26/08 6:25 AM PST (2 replies)

Commented We should make him hitting coach. on Furcal looking for homes in the Bay Area, and Nick Johnson to relocate too? on Athletics Nation - 11/26/08 6:24 AM PST (1 reply)

Commented True. Bob's no Jack Wilson. on DLD (11/24/08): Report - Furcal to sign with A's on Athletics Nation - 11/26/08 6:20 AM PST (1 reply)

Commented Why is it not fair to judge a GM by his performance in unique situations? on Rule 5 Draft on Minor League Ball - 11/26/08 5:18 AM PST (1 reply)

Commented Blanks has to make it, doesn't he? on Community Prospect List: #73 on Minor League Ball - 11/26/08 5:12 AM PST (2 replies)

Commented Are there non-bitchy conniving women on Melrose Place? Can they hit? on In Search Of A Shortstop Prospect on Athletics Nation - 11/26/08 5:01 AM PST (1 reply)

Commented Yes, as long as he plays Gold Glove defense at SS on In Search Of A Shortstop Prospect on Athletics Nation - 11/26/08 4:59 AM PST (2 replies)

Commented Agreed on Gio and the slowdown. on Community Organizational Prospect List - #5 on Athletics Nation - 11/26/08 4:58 AM PST (2 replies)

Voted for Gio Gonzalez on Athletics Nation - 11/26/08 4:49 AM PST

Commented Their GM has only had his job a week, so it's a bit early to call him lazy. on Furcal looking for homes in the Bay Area, and Nick Johnson to relocate too? on Athletics Nation - 11/25/08 10:30 PM PST

Commented I wouldn't want Petit getting 450 AB on In Search Of A Shortstop Prospect on Athletics Nation - 11/25/08 10:23 PM PST (1 reply)

Commented So he's taking our advice. Good. We won't stop bitching then. on Furcal looking for homes in the Bay Area, and Nick Johnson to relocate too? on Athletics Nation - 11/25/08 9:21 PM PST (1 reply)

Commented I really hope there's no one on earth with that name. on In Search Of A Shortstop Prospect on Athletics Nation - 11/25/08 9:18 PM PST

Commented Given an Ellis-Furcal-Chavez IF I don't think it's at all moot to discuss who we'd like on In Search Of A Shortstop Prospect on Athletics Nation - 11/25/08 9:17 PM PST (3 replies)

Commented Also in that case here are some more candidates I have around the Top 50 on Community Organizational Prospect List - #4 on Athletics Nation - 11/25/08 9:15 PM PST (2 replies)

Commented Awesome! But, if we go farther than 50, I'd have to do more homework. on Community Organizational Prospect List - #4 on Athletics Nation - 11/25/08 9:08 PM PST

Commented 7 A's prospects and I'm not sure I've voted for any of them. I may have voted for on Community Prospect List: #73 on Minor League Ball - 11/25/08 9:02 PM PST

Voted for Aaron Hicks on Minor League Ball - 11/25/08 9:00 PM PST

Commented I'd also like to see Fautino as a tester. on Community Organizational Prospect List - #4 on Athletics Nation - 11/25/08 8:58 PM PST (1 reply)

Commented Top 10 should be. How far are we going? 50? on Community Organizational Prospect List - #4 on Athletics Nation - 11/25/08 8:56 PM PST (1 reply)

Commented I voted Gio, because Cunningham's defense concerns me a little, but it was very on Community Organizational Prospect List - #4 on Athletics Nation - 11/25/08 8:55 PM PST (2 replies)

Voted for Gio Gonzalez on Athletics Nation - 11/25/08 8:53 PM PST

Commented But I don't think the Astros would trade him for a short term downgrade on Semi-Baked Ideas Thread on Athletics Nation - 11/25/08 8:30 PM PST

Commented A Johnson-Ellis-Furcal-Chavez IF would have the busiest backup IF of all time. on Furcal looking for homes in the Bay Area, and Nick Johnson to relocate too? on Athletics Nation - 11/25/08 8:28 PM PST

Commented I'm not sure why the Nats would want Crosby when they already have Guzman and Zimmerman. on The Holliday Acquisition And Being Good In 2010 - Not Mutually Exclusive on Athletics Nation - 11/25/08 8:14 PM PST (1 reply)

Commented I don't know that you can really project reverse splits based on this sample size on Semi-Baked Ideas Thread on Athletics Nation - 11/25/08 8:09 PM PST (2 replies)

Commented Without the defense on Furcal looking for homes in the Bay Area, and Nick Johnson to relocate too? on Athletics Nation - 11/25/08 8:00 PM PST (1 reply)

Commented They're delicious! on The Holliday Acquisition And Being Good In 2010 - Not Mutually Exclusive on Athletics Nation - 11/25/08 7:24 PM PST (1 reply)

Commented Doesn't a rotation anchor have to pitch 200 innings with a 120 ERA+ or better? on The Holliday Acquisition And Being Good In 2010 - Not Mutually Exclusive on Athletics Nation - 11/25/08 7:20 PM PST (1 reply)

Commented Whereas I laughed for at least 30 seconds on Community Organizational Prospect List - #3 on Athletics Nation - 11/25/08 7:00 PM PST (1 reply)

Commented I'm presuming anyone in this conversation (ie not Henry Rodriguez) on Community Organizational Prospect List - #3 on Athletics Nation - 11/25/08 6:57 PM PST

Commented QOTM! on Community Organizational Prospect List - #3 on Athletics Nation - 11/25/08 6:18 PM PST (1 reply)

Commented I see Mike Cameron offense with average defense as his upside. on Community Organizational Prospect List - #3 on Athletics Nation - 11/25/08 6:16 PM PST

Commented Why is BB/BFP a better indicator of the ability to control the strike zone than K/BB? on Community Organizational Prospect List - #3 on Athletics Nation - 11/25/08 6:13 PM PST (1 reply)

Commented Crosby + $4.85M for Hu is an easy "YES" for me. If they want a relief prospect like Lansford to get on DLD (11/24/08): Report - Furcal to sign with A's on Athletics Nation - 11/25/08 5:37 PM PST (1 reply)

Commented Oops that was your point. I see now. on Community Organizational Prospect List - #3 on Athletics Nation - 11/25/08 5:34 PM PST

Commented Do you see him starting there for the A's for more than two years? on Community Organizational Prospect List - #3 on Athletics Nation - 11/25/08 5:33 PM PST (1 reply)

Commented I'm not sure defense is really underrated. How much less do you think Dunn's going to get on The Holliday Acquisition And Being Good In 2010 - Not Mutually Exclusive on Athletics Nation - 11/25/08 5:23 PM PST

Commented They do have an opening in CF though. on Community Organizational Prospect List - #3 on Athletics Nation - 11/25/08 5:11 PM PST (1 reply)

Commented Cust is a pretty good comp offensively, but Carter should make a better LF on Community Organizational Prospect List - #3 on Athletics Nation - 11/25/08 5:03 PM PST (1 reply)

Commented Simmons had a 3.75 K/BB in 2008. That's very good. Here are some others: on Community Organizational Prospect List - #3 on Athletics Nation - 11/25/08 5:00 PM PST (1 reply)

Commented I've never voted for Inoa but how can we take him out until #90 when he's winning? on Community Prospect List: #72 on Minor League Ball - 11/25/08 3:52 PM PST (1 reply)

Commented Couldn't all threads have this title? on Semi-Baked Ideas Thread on Athletics Nation - 11/25/08 3:48 PM PST

Commented I didn't know you were a Yankee fan. on Semi-Baked Ideas Thread on Athletics Nation - 11/25/08 3:47 PM PST (1 reply)

Commented I realize Gio was 22 last year. on Community Organizational Prospect List - #3 on Athletics Nation - 11/25/08 3:43 PM PST (1 reply)

Commented I'm a Simmons skeptic and don't think he has much upside. I'm not aware of his "plus-plus command" on Community Organizational Prospect List - #3 on Athletics Nation - 11/25/08 3:41 PM PST (3 replies)

Commented Ya, I like the bump if you don't get 5% rule. We could modify it to relegate the bottom three or something. on Community Organizational Prospect List - #3 on Athletics Nation - 11/25/08 3:37 PM PST

Commented I would have liked to have seen Hicks over the other three. on Community Organizational Prospect List - #3 on Athletics Nation - 11/25/08 3:35 PM PST

Voted for Chris Carter on Athletics Nation - 11/25/08 3:33 PM PST