Cleveland Indians 2014 Community Mock Draft War Room

Alright, so today is the big day. The Indians have 4 picks in the first two rounds, thanks to compensation from Ubaldo Jimenez going to Baltimore and a competitive balance pick. This includes three of the first 38 picks. They have six picks in the first four rounds. Here is how the bonuses stack up for those six picks:

Round Pick Slot Bonus Slot Bonus +5%
1 21 $2,008,100 $2,108,505
1 31 $1,733,000 $1,819,650
Comp A 38 $1,495,400 $1,570,170
2 61 $928,700 $975,135
3 97 $539,600 $566,580
4 128 $400,200 $420,210

SUM: $7,105,000 $7,460,250

Here is a table that shows how the Indians have drafted over the past five years:

Cleveland Draft Results 2009-2013
Total picks 19
High School 37%
College 63%
Bats 47%
Arms 53%
1st round 5
1st Round % HS 40%
1st Round % College 60%
2nd round 4
2nd Round % HS 50%
2nd Round % College 50%
3rd round 5
3rd Round % HS 40%
3rd Round % College 60%
4th round 5
4th round % HS 20%
4th round % College 80%
% Bats 47%
% Prep Bats 44%
% College Bats 56%
% C 11%
% 1B 0%
% 2B 11%
% 3B 11%
% SS 22%
% OF 44%
% Arms 53%
% Prep Arms 30%
% College Arms 70%
% LHP 20%
% RHP 80%
1st Round % HS Arms 0%
1st Round % HS Bats 40%
1st Round % College Arms 40%
1st Round % College Bats 20%
2nd Round % HS Arms 50%
2nd Round % HS Bats 0%
2nd Round % College Arms 0%
2nd Round % College Bats 50%
3rd Round % HS Arms 20%
3rd Round % HS Bats 20%
3rd Round % College Arms 60%
3rd Round % College Bats 0%
4th round % HS Arms 0%
4th round % HS Bats 20%
4th round % College Arms 40%
4th round % College Bats 40%

They tend to draft college players over high school players at close to a 2:1 ratio. However, given the strength of this draft being prep arms, I will lean more towards a 1:1 ratio. Their evenly split on bats and arms, so I will aim for three of each. Of their pitchers taken, they tend to draft college arms twice as often as prep arms. Although, given the high school pitching talent, I may decide to go with two prep arms and only one college arm. Prep bats and college bats are pretty even, so I will aim for one each, and save one for BPA.

With the first pick, at pick 21, I want to look at a bat to take. The top tier college arms should be gone by then, and the difference in quality between an arm at 21 and an arm at 31 is much smaller than the difference in the quality of bats between those two picks. I suspect there will be a run on bats in the 15-30 range of picks, so if we want a good one, we will have to take it at 21.

At 31 and 38, I am looking to grab at least one high school arm, and possibly two, depending on who else is available. The reason being is there are some pretty good college arms on my board for the third and fourth round. And I think I should be able to pick up a good bat in the second round. Based on my own draft board, there should be some really good high school pitchers available at picks 31 and 38. If I don't go high school arms with both of these picks, I will look to grab a college bat with one of them.

Looking at my board, there should be some good bats available to pick from with the second round pick, pick 61. And there should be quite a few good college arms available in the third and fourth round. Right now, I am looking at college players in the third and fourth (one bat and one arm), assuming I take a high school bat, two high school arms, and a college bat in the first four picks. In the third round, we have pick 97, with a slot bonus of $539,600, with a plus 5% of $566,580. That should be plenty to sign a college player of our choosing. If we take a risky/expensive guy with an earlier pick, we could always go cheap senior sign here.

On my draft board the best prospects that should be available in the third are college arms, and in the fourth it is split between college arms and high school bats. We'll see how this plays out. I will post my top five in the comments about five picks before our turn. Please stick around to discuss this with me, and throw out any names you like!

Log In Sign Up

Log In Sign Up

Forgot password?

We'll email you a reset link.

If you signed up using a 3rd party account like Facebook or Twitter, please login with it instead.

Forgot password?

Try another email?

Almost done,

By becoming a registered user, you are also agreeing to our Terms and confirming that you have read our Privacy Policy.

Join Minor League Ball

You must be a member of Minor League Ball to participate.

We have our own Community Guidelines at Minor League Ball. You should read them.

Join Minor League Ball

You must be a member of Minor League Ball to participate.

We have our own Community Guidelines at Minor League Ball. You should read them.




Choose an available username to complete sign up.

In order to provide our users with a better overall experience, we ask for more information from Facebook when using it to login so that we can learn more about our audience and provide you with the best possible experience. We do not store specific user data and the sharing of it is not required to login with Facebook.