Best Player available draft vs. Signability Draft

Both drafts' costs were almost identical although I was able to sign far fewer players in the Best Available draft. Leaving aside the players that I chose in both drafts, which draft would you rather have:

*

SIGNABILITY DRAFT (BA Ranking)

*

Bradley Jr., Jackie (#34)

Chafin, Andrew (#38)

Lopez, Jorge #39)

Story, Trevor (#40)

Zych, Toni (#50)

Boyd, Hudson (#58)

Westlake, Aaron(#59)

Lowell, Charlie (#62)

Greene, Tyler (#83)

Murray, Colton (#111)

Moore, Navery (#113)

Kukuk, Cody (#154)

Stites, Matt (#178)

Valdez, Jesus (#195)

Plus the compensation pick at #32A in the 2012 player draft

*

BEST AVAILABLE PLAYER DRAFT (BA Ranking)

*

Guerreri, Taylor (#10)

Norris, Daniel (#16)

Howard, Dillon (#31)

Goetzman, Grandon (#52)

Matt Dean (#54)

Eiermann, Johnny (#84)

Plus compensation picks at #38A, #52A, and #59A

Plus signing 8 extra warm bodies