Sorry about re-posting this but I made the mistake in the earlier post of including a poll. As a result there were no discussion about the pluses and minuses of both pitchers. Beachy shockingly won that poll and I would just like to hear from the people that voted either way as to why you feel one is better than the other.
The question is simple. If you can have either Brandon Beachy's or Turner's first 6 MLB seasons, who would you pick and why?
In my mind Turner is the better pitcher simply because he has proven every stop of the way that he can handle the workload and succeed at a relatively young age. He also throws harder and has arguably a better breaking ball (Turner's curve vs. Beachy's slider).
So what do you guys think? Don't be shy, I know over a hundred of you voted. You surely have opinions and good reasoning behind it.