Top Rule 5 Eligible Players from your team

Well, since today was protection day, I thought it might be a good idea to have a thread about this.  I haven't found a list of top unprotected guys yet (but I haven't looked that hard), as everything is focused on who was protected.  I don't think there's a need to post the protected guys.  Everyone can go to mlbtr to look at it.  Granted, the number of truly intriguing guys for Rule 5 have diminished.  I'll post the my take on the Cubs top unprotected guys, with my pros and cons as to why the decision was made/why they might get picked, after the jump.  I'm hopeful that people will post lists for their teams, as there's no point for me to have a thread on unprotected Cubs players.

Top Unprotected Cubs Prospects (IMO) - There is some speculation by people (fans really, but one of them is a really knowledgeable fan so I think that's got some people chatting about it) that some of the Cubs unprotected guys may be potential compensation pieces for the Red Sox/Padres (that is, those organizations may not want these guys on their 40, so if they pass through Rule 5, then a deal could happen).

(name, age, level finished 2011)

* Dae-Eun Rhee, 22, A+ - This one surprised/bothered me and yet I could understand it somewhat.  At year's end, he was hitting mid-90's (still sat more 92/93) with a plus change and decent slider.  Furthermore, he was working 6 or more late in the year.  Callis recently said in the Cubs prospect chat that Rhee was borderline top 10 (I have him 6th) with a chance to be a number 3 starter.  The talent's there, and as a lot of sources have noted, the stuff was really strong late in the year (9.35 K/9, 2.65 BB/9 in July/August).  On the flip side, he can hit mid-90's as a starter, but can he sit mid-90's out of the pen?  If he can't, then you've got a long man with an injury history, and you'd have to really love his starter potential to use up a spot this year.  I could see a small market team rolling the dice.

* Jeffry Antigua, 21, A+ - Lefty had an odd season, but finished strong.  On the plus side, he's got 3 solid pitches, good stamina, and fastball is more consistently in the low 90's.  On the flip side, it's debatable if he has a plus pitch, and a team may not want to put a guy like that in their pen for a year right now. I have him in the mid-teens for Cubs prospects.

* Jay Jackson, 24, AAA - Former top prospect has fallen hard (BA had him outside of the top 30, same for me).  Still can get the velo up there, but slider is inconsistent.  I do wonder if he might benefit from a pen move (and focusing on one secondary pitch), so could be an intriguing gamble for a team.

* Marcus Hatley, 23, AA/Kyler Burke, 23, Shortseason/Blake Parker, 26, AAA - Hatley was sent to AFL, so could see a team taking a gamble.  Has big time power stuff, but is raw (fb in the mid-90's, power slider).  Missed a year with injuries.  Kyler Burke moved to pitching this year and the stuff looks good, with a nice 3 pitch arsenal.  Some Cubs fans have speculated that he could get a rotation look next year.  Power stuff, but raw.  Parker finished strong, and has a live fastball with a good slider.  Stuff isn't good enough to expect more than a middle relief role, IMO.

* Marwin Gonzalez, 22, AAA - Versatile middle infielder plays a solid short, is young, toolsy, and some still expect some pop out of the bat.  That said, he's not a plus glove and the bat is still a huge work in progress.

* Ryan Flaherty, 25, AAA - Versatile player can spot at 6 positions.  Has legitimate, big time power, and a decent approach at the plate.  That said, contact ability is questionable, hasn't settled in at a corner spot (more because he's moved around so much), and is getting older.  Bad run in AAA.  Possible super-util, but Cubs have Baker, and a couple guys who could fill a similar role.

To be honest, if Gonzalez/Hatley/Burke/Parker/Jackson/Antigua get picked and stick for the entire year, I think, as a Cubs fan, I tip my cap, wish them the best, and move on.  The Cubs left a ton of spots open on the 40 (6) and they'll need some upper level positional backups/role guys, and I'm not sure they'll find better than Flaherty through Rule 5 or FA, but that's me.

Log In Sign Up

Log In Sign Up

Forgot password?

We'll email you a reset link.

If you signed up using a 3rd party account like Facebook or Twitter, please login with it instead.

Forgot password?

Try another email?

Almost done,

By becoming a registered user, you are also agreeing to our Terms and confirming that you have read our Privacy Policy.

Join Minor League Ball

You must be a member of Minor League Ball to participate.

We have our own Community Guidelines at Minor League Ball. You should read them.

Join Minor League Ball

You must be a member of Minor League Ball to participate.

We have our own Community Guidelines at Minor League Ball. You should read them.




Choose an available username to complete sign up.

In order to provide our users with a better overall experience, we ask for more information from Facebook when using it to login so that we can learn more about our audience and provide you with the best possible experience. We do not store specific user data and the sharing of it is not required to login with Facebook.