Now that the regular season of minor league baseball has arrived, I figured it'd be a good time to start another regrade thread.
The last time I did one of these, it pretty much exploded the site with 2195 comments and some pretty good discussions. [http://www.minorleagueball.com/2010/9/8/1676215/end-of-regular-season-player]
The format that we used last time worked very well, with a user listing a players name, and then the rest of the community replying to that comment with a letter grade for that player, and possibly an explanation for why they choose that grade.
PS: I might also through it out there that I would be okay if we also included major leaguers who are still young and unproven, guys in their first or second year in the majors who we still don't have a great idea about the type of player they are going to become.