Dynasty League Trade Question

If you’re going to move him for one of those prospect packages, i’d take door #2.

I think CarGo is in for some regression but I think with 2 more years before FA you could potentially get a lot more down the line than if you were to take one of those deals right now…

I’d suggest wait it out and see what’s available near the ASB if these are your best offers

Neither offer has enough to sway me.

CarGo may have had a career year but should still be pretty damn valuable. You need to get more than this to move him. You can probably still get these kind of offers for him next year.

I agree with the sentiment of those who chose #2… try to work on that guy to get more. If not, no big deal. Hold onto him and try this again next winter…

LaPorta came off hip surgery last season, even the Indians manager has been saying he will give him a complete mulligan, he’s shown good patience at the plate, and the power is still in there, I’d be more concerned if he was hitting HR’s but the patience wasn’t there anymore.
Delgado is a rare safe bet to be at least a #3 starter in the majors while also maintaining the strong potential to be a #2 or an ace, plus he will pitch in the NL East while Lamb will face nasty lineups in the AL.
Iglesias, while not being much of a fantasy stud, is a safe bet to be a mlb regular, his defense will get him to the show, once there he can be very useful, especially in a dynasty setting, I’m not sure if your league is 30 teams or not. But I can certainly see Iglesias hitting around .280-.290 with 5 HR’s and 10-15 SB’s, nothign to sneeze at from the MI position if it is indeed a deep league.

I think Bourjos is probably just as good as Jennings, as they have similar skills across the board while Bourjos has more power in his bat and better outfield defense, doesn’t help in fantasy but it will keep him playing every single day in centerfield. I’d say Jenning will be a Juan Pierre type but Bourjos has a real shot to be a Curtis Granderson, Victorino type, maybe with even more speed. He could produce a line like .275 20 HR 40 SB in his prime, while Jennings could do something like .290 5 HR 50 SB.
While I’m not crazy about Westmoreland’s chances of coming back, if he does come back he has an amazing skillset.
Medlen’s coming off Tommy John but was great last year.
Cortes is a wildcard, he struggled in his winter-league but BA sees him as the mariners next closer. Could be an andrew bailey type deal.
I’d take wheeler or conger from the last 3. Wheeler has a huge upside and SF knows how to develop those young arms. Conger has a very underrated bat, its a .300 hitting bat with even k:bb numbers and some pop, at the catcher position that’s pretty special.

Don’t get me wrong here, I love Jennings but I don’t think his power fully develops, making him kind of one dimensional. I don’t see the Crawford comps at all.
Lamb is nice but he’ll be in the AL and probably has a #2 upside, I like Delgado more alone. Carlos Perez is underrated around baseball but that doesn’t put him above Conger, as we’ve seen him actually do it at higher levels.
Maybe I’m alone but Skaggs would seem like a back of the rotation arm, I like Medlens chances of coming back off TJ surgery in 2012 and being a #3 over Skaggs chances of being a top of the rotation guy.

I’m the team that offered deal #2, lol.

CarGo could hit .290 this year and his value will still be more than either package.

I think you can get more.