Navigation: Jump to content areas:


Pro Quality. Fan Perspective.
Login-facebook
Around SBN: The Most Dangerous Division in Sports

Sim League Prospect Draft


Meant to post this before, but here is a look at how 30 owners in a sim league valued the amateurs and unowned players available for drafting.  The unowned crop was pretty strong IMO, while it's been widely publicized that the Amateur crop was a bit lackluster this year.  Sorry in advance for the long post.  Any thoughts on which teams did well?

1.01    BAL    Bryce Harper             C      College of Southern Nevada
1.02    MIL    Jameson Taillon          RHP    The Woodlands HS, TX
1.03    SF     Manny Machado            SS     Brito Private HS, FL
1.04    PIT    Drew Pomeranz            RHP    Mississippi
1.05    SD     Chris Sale               LHP    Florida Gulf Coast
1.06    TB     Alex Colome              RHP    Tampa Bay Rays organization
1.07    TEX    Zack Cox                 3B     Arkansas
1.08    BAL    Michael Choice           OF     University of Texas-Arlington
1.09    LAD    Michael Ynoa             RHP    Oakland Athletics organization
1.10    HOU    Karsten Whitson          RHP    Chipley HS, FL
1.11    NYY    Alex Wimmers             RHP    Ohio State University
1.12    FLA    Jake Skole               OF     Blessed Trinity HS, GA
1.13    OAK    Dylan Covey              RHP    Maranatha HS, CA
1.14    WAS    Deck McGuire             RHP    Georgia Tech
1.15    SEA    Kellin Deglan            C      Mountain SS, B.C.
1.16    MIN    Matt Harvey              RHP    University of North Carolina
1.17    PHI    Yasmani Grandal          C      University of Miami
1.18    NYY    Stetson Allie            RHP    St Edwards HS, OH
1.19    LAA    Christian Colon          SS     Cal State Fullerton
1.20    CIN    Nick Castellanos         3B     Archbishop McCarthy HS, FL
1.21    STL    Josh Sale                OF     Bishop Blanchet HS, WA
1.22    KC     John Lamb                LHP    Kansas City Royals organization
1.23    NYM    Barret Loux              RHP    Texas A&M
1.24    CHC    Brennan Boesch           OF     Detroit Tigers organization
1.25    KC     Jarred Cosart            RHP    Philadelphia Phillies organization
1.26    ARI    Jonathan Singleton       1B     Philadelphia Phillies organization
1.27    MIN    Anthony Ranuado          RHP    LSU
1.28    TOR    Delino DeShields         CF     Woodward Academy, GA
1.29    COL    Austin Wilson            OF     Harvard-Westlake HS, CA
1.30    DET    Hayden Simpson           RHP    Southern Arkansas

S1.01   TB     Justin OConnor           C       Cowan HS, IN
S1.02   COL    Anthony Rizzo            1B      Boston Red Sox organization
S1.03   ARI    Jiwan James              OF      Philadelphia Phillies organization
S1.04   BAL    Dayan Viciedo            3B      Chicago White Sox organization
S1.05   HOU    Bryce Brentz             OF/RHP  Middle Tennessee State University
S1.06   CLE    Hak-Ju Lee               SS      Chicago Cubs organization
S1.07   LAA    Peter Tago               RHP     Dana Hills HS, CA
S1.08   ATL    Cam Bedrosian            RHP     East Coweta HS, GA
S1.09   FLA    Aaron Sanchez            RHP     Barstow HS, CA
S1.10   LAD    Kolbrin Vitek            2B      Ball State
S1.11   PIT    Robert Erlin             LHP     Texas Rangers organization
S1.12   MIN    Jedd Gyorko              2B      West Virginia University
S1.13   STL    Brandon Workman          RHP     Texas
S1.14   CHC    Kaleb Cowart             SS/RHP  Cook County HS, GA
S1.15   BOS    Kyle Parker              OF      Clemson
S1.16   CHW    Garrett Richards         RHP     Los Angeles Angels


2.01    LAA    Brett Eibner             OF/RHP   Arkansas
2.02    BAL    Zach Von Rosenberg       RHP      Pittsburgh Pirates organization
2.03    SF     Matt Lipka               SS       McKinney HS, TX
2.04    CIN    Fabio Martinez Mesa      RHP      Los Angeles Angels organization
2.05    SD     Derek Dietrich           SS       Georgia Tech
2.06    OAK    Alexander Torres         LHP      Tampa Bay Rays organization
2.07    WAS    Sammy Solis              LHP      University of San Diego
2.08    PIT    Wilking Rodriguez        RHP      Tampa Bay Rays organization        
2.09    LAD    A.J. Cole                RHP      Oviedo HS, FL
2.10    SF     Robert Segedin           3B       Tulane University
2.11    NYY    Carlos Monasterios       RHP      Los Angeles Dodgers organization
2.12    CLE    Mike Olt                 3B       UConn
2.13    PHI    Chris Owings             SS       Arizona Diamondbacks organization
2.14    MIL    Asher Wojciechowski      RHP      The Citadel
2.15    SEA    Yordy Cabrera            3B       Lakeland HS, FL
2.16    MIN    David Bromberg           RHP      Minnesota Twins organization
2.17    PHI    Alexi Amarista           2B       Los Angeles Angels organization
2.18    ATL    Johnny Venters           LHP      Atlanta Braves organization
2.19    KC     Miguel Velazquez         OF       Texas Rangers organization
2.20    NYY    Christian Bethancourt    C        Atlanta Braves organization
2.21    TEX    Gary Brown               OF       Cal State Fullerton
2.22    CHW    Trevor May               RHP      Philadelphia Phillies organization
2.23    MIN    Kyle Blair               RHP      University of San Diego
2.24    CLE    Adrian Salcedo           RHP      Minnesota Twins organization
2.25    BOS    Ryan LaMarre             OF       Michigan
2.26    TB     Jose Ramirez             RHP      New York Yankees organization
2.27    CIN    Mike Foltynewicz         RHP      Minooka HS, IN
2.28    PHI    Trey McNutt              RHP      Chicago Cubs organization
2.29    MIL    Tyrell Jenkins           RHP      Henderson HS, TX
2.30    BOS    Chad Bettis              RHP      Texas Tech

S2.01    TB    Trayce Thompson          OF       Chicago White Sox organization
S2.02    COL   Felix Doubront           P        Boston Red Sox organization

3.01    TEX    Seth Blair               RHP      Arizona State University
3.02    OAK    Wynn Pelzer              RHP      San Diego Padres organization  
3.03    CLE    Brandon Belt             1B       San Francisco Giants organization
3.04    NYY    Jesse Biddle             LHP      Germantown Friends HS, PA
3.05    SD     Marcus Littlewood        SS       Pine View HS, UT
3.06    BAL    Francisco Peguero        OF       San Francisco Giants organization
3.07    WAS    Tony Wolters             SS       Rancho Buena Vista HS, CA
3.08    CLE    Allen Webster            RHP      Los Angeles Dodgers organization
3.09    LAD    Starling Marte           OF       Pittsburgh Pirates organization
3.10    HOU    Carlos Perez             C        Toronto Blue Jays organization
3.11    LAA    Josh Thole               C        New York Mets organization
3.12    FLA    Jean Segura              2b       Los Angeles Angels organization
3.13    KC     Robinson Lopez           RHP      Atlanta Braves organization
3.14    BOS    Steven Hensley           RHP      Seattle Mariners organization
3.15    SEA    Reggie Golden            OF       Wetumpka HS, GA
3.16    MIN    Liam Hendriks            RHP      Minnesota Twins organization
3.17    PHI    Ian Krol                 LHP      Oakland Athletics organization
3.18    DET    Garin Cecchini           SS       Barbe HS, Lake Charles, LA  
3.19    BAL    Patrick Corbin           LHP      Los Angeles Angels organization
3.20    PHI    Dimasther Delgado        LHP      Braves Org
3.21    STL    Luis Jimenez             3b       Los Angeles Angels Organization
3.22    MIN    Rob Rasmussen            LHP      UCLA
3.23    PHI    Yorman Rodriguez         OF       Cincinnati Reds organization
3.24    OAK    Ryan "Scooter" Gennett   SS       Milwaukee Brewers organization
3.25    CLE    Junichi Tazawa           RHP      Boston Red Sox organization
3.26    ARI    Domingo Santana          OF       Philadelphia Phillies organization  
3.27    HOU    Ryne Stanek              RHP      Blue Valley HS, KS
3.28    TOR    Christian Yelich         1b       Westlake HS, CA
3.29    CLE    Alex Cobb                RHP      Tampa Bay Rays organization
3.30    TB     Chris Archer             RHP      Chicago Cubs organization

4.01    KC     Rafael Rodriguez         OF       San Francisco Giants Org.
4.02    TB     Oswaldo Arcia            OF       Minnesota Twins organization
4.03    KC     Adys Portillo            RHP      San Diego Padres organization
4.04    MIL    Joe Gardner              RHP      Cleveland Indians organization
4.05    SD     Kellen Sweeney           3B       Jefferson HS, IA
4.06    COL    Jacob Marisnick          OF       Toronto Blue Jays organization
4.07    WAS    Drew Smyly               LHP      Arkansas
4.08    WAS    Chris Balcolm-Miller     RHP      Colorado Rockies organization
4.09    LAD    Yeicok Calderon          OF       New York Yankees
4.10    CLE    Angelo Gumbs             OF       Torrance HS, CA
4.11    NYY    Dae-Eun Rhee             RHP      Chicago Cubs organization
4.12    STL    Drew Vettleson           OF       Central Kitsap High School, WA
4.13    WAS    Dave Filak               RHP      Oneonta State
4.14    BAL    Mauricio Robles          LHP      Seattle Mariners organization
4.15    CLE    Jerry Sands              OF       Los Angeles Dodgers organization
4.16    KC     Gustavo Pierre           SS       Toronto Blue Jays organization
4.17    OAK    Juan Silva               OF       Cincinnati Reds organization
4.18    TB     Eduardo Sanchez          RHP      St. Luis Cards organization
4.19    BAL    Kenley Jansen            RHP      Los Angeles Dodgers organization
4.20    MIL    Graham Stoneburner       RHP      New York Yankees organization
4.21    SD     Jimmy Nelson             RHP      University of Alabama
4.22    CHW    Richard Alvarez          RHP      Texas Rangers organization
4.23    NYM    Kirk Nieuwenhuis         OF       New York Mets organization
4.24    CHC    Bo Greenwell             OF       Cleveland Indians organization
4.25    LAD    Chase D Arnaud           SS       Pittsburgh Pirates organization
4.26    ARI    Cito Culver              SS       Irondequoit HS, NY
4.27    MIN    Eury Perez               OF       Washington Nationals organization
4.28    BOS    Jarrett Parker           OF       Virginia
4.29    ATL    David Phelps             RHP      New York Yankees organization
4.30    CHW    Trayvon Robinson         OF       Los Angeles Dodgers organization

5.01    NYY    Hector Noesi             RHP      New York Yankees organization
5.02    COL    Chevez Clarke            OF       Marietta HS, GA
5.03    SF     Micah Gibbs              C        LSU
5.04    HOU    Craig Westcott           RHP      San Francisco Giants organization
5.05    SD     Todd Cunningham          OF       Jacksonville State
5.06    KC     Gauntlett Eldemire       OF       Ohio University
5.07    MIL    Jesse Hahn               RHP      Virginia Tech
5.08    TEX    Chance Ruffin            RHP      Texas
5.09    HOU    Jonathan Villar          SS       Philadelphia Phillies organization
5.10    SEA    Aderlin Rodriguez        3B       New York Mets organization
5.11    NYY    Marcell Ozuna            OF       Florida Marlins organization
5.12    FLA    Tim Collins              LHP      Toronto Blue Jays organization
5.13    OAK    Eddie Rosario            OF       Puerto Rico HS
5.14    WAS    Dickie Thon Jr           SS       Academia Perpetuo Socorro
5.15    SEA    Leon Landry              OF       Louisiana State University
5.16    DET    Nicholas Longmire        OF       University of the Pacific (CA)
5.17    NYY    JR Murphy                C        New York Yankees organization
5.18    ATL    Juan Nicasio             RHP      Colorado Rockies organization
5.19    TB     Sean Coyle               2B       Germantown Academy (PA)
5.20    FLA    Adam Milligan            OF       Atlanta Braves orgnization
5.21    STL    Taylor Lindsey           SS       Desert Mountain HS, AZ
5.22    CHW    Jonathan Garcia          OF       Los Angeles Dodgers organization
5.23    DET    Mel Rojas Jr             OF       Wabash Valley CC
5.24    CLE    Jhan Marinez             RHP      Florida Marlins organization
5.25    KC     Mark Trumbo              1B       Los Angeles Angels organization
5.26    TEX    Dan Runzler              LHP      San Francisco Giants organization
5.27    BAL    Andrelton Simmons        SS/RHP   Western Oklahoma State
5.28    KC     Collin Cowgill           OF       Arizona Diamondbacks organization
5.29    CLE    Luke Jackson             RHP      Calvary Christian HS, FL
5.30    BAL    Zach Lee                 RHP      McKinney HS, TX

6.01    OAK    Justin De Fratus         RHP      Philadelphia Phillies organization
6.02    DET    Marcos Frias             RHP      Washington Nationals organization
6.03    OAK    Cody Stanley             C        UNC-Wilmington
6.04    PIT    Mike Kvasnicka           C        University of Minnesota
6.05    TB     Corey Dickerson          OF       Meridian CC
6.06    KC     Brad Emaus               2B       Toronto Blue Jays organization
6.07    COL    Chase Anderson           RHP      Arizona Diamondbacks organization
6.08    ARI    Carlos Melo              RHP      Arizona Diamondbacks organization
6.09    LAD    Josh Judy                RHP      Cleveland Indians organization
6.10    MIL    Alexi Ogando             RHP      Texas Rangers organization
6.11    CLE    Marcus Knecht            OF       Connors St JC
6.12    FLA    Corban Joseph            2B       New York Yankees organization
6.13    OAK    Phil Wunderlich          3B       Louisville
6.14    PHI    Xavier Avery             OF       Baltimore Orioles organization
6.15    MIL    Noah Syndergaard         RHP      Legacy HS, TX
6.16    MIL    Taijuan Walker           RHP      Yucaipa HS, CA
6.17    BAL    Griffin Murphy           LHP      Redlands East Valley HS, CA
6.18    ATL    Billy Hamilton           SS       Cincinnati Reds organization.
6.19    LAA    James (J.R.) Bradley     RHP      Nitro HS, WV
6.20    CIN    Zack Cates               RHP      Northeast Texas CC
6.21    STL    Fernando Salas           RHP      St. Louis Cardinals organization
6.22    MIL    Eric Surkamp             LHP      San Francisco Giants organization
6.23    MIL    Paul Goldschmidt         1B       Arizona Diamondbacks organization
6.24    CHC    Matthew Spencer          OF       Chicago Cubs organization
6.25    TB     Kevin Gausman            RHP      Grandview HS, CO
6.26    LAD    Brett Oberholtzer        LHP      Atlanta Braves organization
6.27    BAL    Brett Wallach            RHP      Los Angeles Dodgers organization
6.28    PHI    Rafael Dolis             RHP      Chicago Cubs organization
6.29    COL    Rick Hague               SS       Rice University
6.30    TB     A.J. Vanegas             RHP      Redwood Christian HS, CA

7.01    LAD    Jose Altuve              2B       Houston Astros organization
7.02    TOR    Lucas Duda               1B       New York Mets organization
7.03    NYY    J.D. Martinez            OF       Huston Astros organization
7.04    PIT    Jacob Petricka           RHP      Indiana State
7.05    SD     Pat Dean                 LHP      Boston College
7.06    LAA    Addison Reed             RHP      San Diego State
7.07    COL    Justin Wilson            LHP      Pittsburgh Pirates organization
7.08    ARI    Eduardo Sosa             OF       New York Yankees organization
7.09    CHW    Juan Oramas              LHP      San Diego Padres organization
7.10    SEA    Kris Bryant              3B       Bonanza HS, NV
7.11    WAS    Vincent DiFazio          C        Texas Rangers organization
7.12    KC     Mycal Jones              SS       Atlanta Braves organization
7.13    LAA    Robbie Aviles            RHP      Suffern HS, NY
7.14    OAK    Colton Cain              LHP      Pittsburgh Pirates organization
7.15    CHW    Joe Leonard              3B       Pittsburgh
7.16    MIN    Phil Gosselin            2B       Virginia
7.17    PHI    Eduardo Nunez            SS       New York Yankees organization
7.18    NYM    Darin Downs              RHP      Tampa Bay Rays organization
7.19    LAA    Josh Slaats              RHP      Hawaii
7.20    CIN    Brayan Villareal         RHP      Detroit Tigers organization
7.21    STL    J.T. Realmuto            SS       Carl Albert HS, OK
7.22    CHW    Ryan Ortiz               C        Oakland Athletics organization
7.23    NYM    Mark Cohoon              RHP      New York Mets organization
7.24    CHC    Brandon Beachy           RHP      Atlanta Braves organization  
7.25    COL    Darin Mastroianni        OF       Toronto Blue Jays organization
7.26    MIL    Tyler Thornburg          RHP      Charleston Southern
7.27    COL    Nathaniel Roberts        OF       High Point University
7.28    TOR    Giovanni L. Soto         LHP      Detroit Tigers organization
7.29    COL    Miguel A. Gonzalez       C        Chicago White Sox organization
7.30    TB     Kevin Chapman            LHP      Florida


Comment 54 comments  |  0 recs  | 

Do you like this story?

Comments

Display:

I’m trying to remember who all from the league posts here from time to time.

Obviously you and I do. BobbyS and ShaneS have accounts but don’t post that often. Marlin and Ben used to post on here a good bit but I haven’t seen them much lately. Then some of the newer guys saw the want ads here in Sickel’s site so they may have accounts but I don’t know what they would be.

I’m still not as high on Cosart and Singleton as you are but I still think you did a really good job. I’m sort of kicking myself that I took O’Connor that high but I still like the way he sounds in the reports. We will see what happens.

by jfish26101 on Aug 5, 2010 1:32 PM EDT reply actions  

Oh, that is right…Singleton went to the D-Backs. I still think you did a good job though.

by jfish26101 on Aug 5, 2010 1:37 PM EDT up reply actions  

Some good value picks that stand out to me

Singleton at 26 I thought was very nice value
Salcedo in the 2nd round and Arcia in the 4th are really nice too. Those guys could have been 1st rounders or supplemental rounders and I wouldn’t have blinked
Chris Archer at the end of the 3rd is a steal
Christian Colon at #19 is a nice value pick

-1 and only member of the Nick Weglarz fan club!

by Jgaztambide on Aug 5, 2010 2:02 PM EDT reply actions  

Arcia

Didn’t have as much press at the time as he didn’t have the nice stats behind him. That said, he’s looking like a nice pick.

by killa on Aug 5, 2010 2:25 PM EDT up reply actions  

Yeah I wasn’t sure where to take him. I took some chances on O’Connor, Ramirez, Arcia, etc because I was worried they wouldn’t last. It’s hard to anticipate what 29 other individuals are going to do so you have to take the players you like when you can.

by jfish26101 on Aug 5, 2010 2:36 PM EDT up reply actions  

When was your draft held?

I like what KC did, getting Lamb that late seems like a steal. Other picks that seem like good value are: Hak-Ju Lee at 36, Garrett Richards at 46, Brandon Belt at 81, and Trayvon Robinson at 138.

http://bullpenbanter.com

by gatling on Aug 5, 2010 2:21 PM EDT reply actions  

Started

Same day as real draft (June 4?), but lasted a few weeks. I was KC, and tried to draft Trayvon at 135/136, before realizing I didn’t have the pick. Put him on the radar by announcing my intentions though.

by killa on Aug 5, 2010 2:22 PM EDT up reply actions  

He wasn’t going to last though based on the comments.

by jfish26101 on Aug 5, 2010 2:23 PM EDT up reply actions  

I had Mesa-Lee-Richards (in that order) at the top of my draft board for my supp pick before moving O’Connor up my list and taking him. Not looking like the wisest decision now but it’s still too early to pass judgment. Hopefully he develops because the reports sound really promising.

by jfish26101 on Aug 5, 2010 2:43 PM EDT up reply actions  

Do the amateurs

have to sign, or do you retain the rights thru college if they don’t?

http://milbprospects.blogspot.com/

by Matt Garrioch on Aug 5, 2010 2:21 PM EDT reply actions  

You retain their rights if they go to college.

by jfish26101 on Aug 5, 2010 2:23 PM EDT up reply actions  

Retain them thru college...

Thus Zach Lee and Austin Wilson types could still have value if not signed this year…

by killa on Aug 5, 2010 2:23 PM EDT up reply actions  

Minnesota

got a lot of polished pitching.
Viciedo, Hak Ju Lee, AJ Cole, Gausman in the 6th is a steal.

http://milbprospects.blogspot.com/

by Matt Garrioch on Aug 5, 2010 2:47 PM EDT reply actions  

I like Colorado’s picks of Marisnick and Wilson at the top. Not a fan of the Florida draft though.

http://milbprospects.blogspot.com/

by Matt Garrioch on Aug 5, 2010 2:48 PM EDT up reply actions  

COL

I have shied away from the really young toolsy types in the past,,,,but my farm is/was VERY thin on potential impact players, so I figured those two were both worth the risk…and then tried to mix in a few more higher level guys (Rizzo, Doubront, etc) to even out my draft.

Most of my best prospects right now…are from this draft….which could either say good things about this year’s selections, or horrible things about my farm leading into it! haha

by BobbyS on Aug 5, 2010 2:57 PM EDT up reply actions  

No Doubt

You did a nice job this year sir.

by killa on Aug 5, 2010 7:56 PM EDT up reply actions  

We had to change GMs for Florida in the middle of the draft.

I think his pick of Segura at 3.12 was his first. I thought he reached on Collins but I’m not sold he can be a high leverage RP. Milligan is pretty toolsy but having a horrible year. I like Corban Joseph actually.

So I think they Marlins could have done better but there were some extenuating circumstances. I believe he said he would have taken Colon where the previous GM took Skole, can’t remember who he would have taken instead of Sanchez.

by jfish26101 on Aug 5, 2010 2:59 PM EDT up reply actions  

I also

Like the Minnesota, with Gyorko being one of my favorite selection to add to the arms acquired

"The key to winning baseball games is pitching, fundamentals, and three run homers."

by fourfingerwoo on Aug 5, 2010 10:16 PM EDT up reply actions  

John Lamb, Garrett Richards, Carlos Perez, Adrian Salcedo, Wilking Rodriguez, Brad Emaus, Kevin Gasuman, Brandon Belt are some good values

some curious picks in there too, but in a league like this you gotta take risks, I think there might have been too much of a focus on guys who were just drafted, though. I don’t know if I’d take a guy like Kyle Parker, or even Jake Skole in the first 3 rounds, especially with names like that available. Wilking is a top 100 guy and he is going behind pretty much the entire first round of the draft. I don’t know about that.

Overall very interesting o see results of something so deep like this.

by Navi's_Navy on Aug 5, 2010 2:58 PM EDT reply actions  

Definitely different strategies in terms of how the teams approach the draft. Some of the GMs just took whoever the next highest drafted player was unfortunately. Some GMs just don’t seem to put much focus on the minors and I think it will really hurt their teams in the long run unfortunately. The different strategies definitely make it interesting though.

by jfish26101 on Aug 5, 2010 3:01 PM EDT up reply actions  

You have to keep in mind...

…there are NO lists to go off of…So you have basically 30 different scouting departments working without ANY shared knowledge of what each other like. We all have access to BA and the like, but each team has different needs that you can’t see as well. Not defending anyone necessarily, just saying…Even thought the majors league teams have wayyy more resources, there were also plenty of non-consensus picks. On the selfish side, I love to see a Skole or Parker taken, because my guy moves up a notch. That said, we’ve got different levels of owners, as guys below have said, as well as different levels of need.

All in all, I agree that you have named a few nice picks (keeping in mind that the draft started almost 2 months ago).

by killa on Aug 5, 2010 8:02 PM EDT up reply actions  

You could tell each GM was going off completely different lists the longer the draft went on. After Archer, I don’t really think I took anyone that was on anyone else’s radar. Honestly, Colome seemed like the only pick I made where someone right after me had said they were hoping he fell to their next pick.

by jfish26101 on Aug 5, 2010 8:08 PM EDT up reply actions  

I think it just means in June/July, nobody has updated lists. You are using lists made in Dec/Jan as your guide but a lot has changed.

by jfish26101 on Aug 6, 2010 8:20 AM EDT up reply actions  

These are the kind of leagues..

I’m trying to give information too at my site. Even after all the picks you guys made, I bet I could find a ton of guys I’d be psyched to take. Yes, I’m that big of a nerd about this stuff.

If any of you guys could offer me insight as to how my efforts could help you guys, let me know. I want to offer a product that could be another opinion and help you find the kind of players you are looking for.
 My database has over 5000 players from the big leagues down to international guys from this season to a few players not eligible until the 2015 draft. I can sort it to find whatever you are looking for.
Someday I’d like to get this online but I don’t have the knowledge or the cash flow at this point so for now, it’s in a spreadsheet and I’m putting it into an access database to be a little more aesthetically appealing.

http://milbprospects.blogspot.com/

by Matt Garrioch on Aug 6, 2010 3:21 PM EDT up reply actions  

I suppose deep rankings that are up to date would help some people. killa already mentioned the lack of information that is out there on prospects in June. Most of the online publications are knee deep in their draft coverage so it is understandable that they aren’t doing updated lists/rankings (plus they have small samples to go off of and possibly very little new information in terms of reports).

I’m not sure what kinds of things would be helpful. I did purchase Seiler’s draft guide this year but it turned out to be more of a good read than a useful tool for the draft given so much of our draft pool was not in the guide because they had already turned pro.

by jfish26101 on Aug 6, 2010 4:08 PM EDT up reply actions  

Well...

You could start by being my personal volunteer draft consultant. :-p

Really though, I think it’s tough to cater to sim leagues because each is going to have a different set of draft rules and preowned players. So each leagues draft pool is going to be significantly different concerning international and minor league guys.

I suppose, it would be pretty sweet if there were resources that we could simply plug in a database of our ineligible and eligibility rules. BUT….I don’t know if i would like something that basically takes all of the work out of a GMs hands.

If i could just pull up a auto generated list of pre ranked guys, it wouldn’t be nearly as fun or rewarding. I enjoy having to research several different sites to get opinions, stats, updates, etc…..and then seeing how it all fits within my organizational needs.

Not that such a product couldn’t be useful, I’d just be hesitant to agree with one that took too much away from individual work .

by BobbyS on Aug 6, 2010 4:08 PM EDT up reply actions  

Good point

Most of the fun is in the research, that’s why I do what I do, I really enjoy it. It’s fun to see video and read opinions and come up with your own opinion.

The main thing that my system could do is provide names and another opinion. It wouldn’t really take away the fun of research, it would just be another tool.

The rating systems used by John and Andy are very broad, mine is more specified and can be sorted more to however you want it. If you want a list of high ceiling OF’s within 2 years of the majors, you can scan it to see who is taken and who’s not. Take the top 5 names and let the research begin :)

As for the consultant position, if you want another another opinion, just ask.

http://milbprospects.blogspot.com/

by Matt Garrioch on Aug 6, 2010 11:33 PM EDT up reply actions  

Just to expand a bit...

…on what was said about Lists below. There are absolutely Zero lists that weigh Brett Eibner versus Miguel Valezaquez for example, amateurs versus unowned minor leaguers. That’s what makes it really tough. In the past, I was usually a bigger scouter of the amateur ranks. This year, with the widely perceived “weak” draft class, I scouted unowned minor leaguers, including amateur signings (which take a year to enter the draft pool), to try to grab some strength of past draft classes that were overlooked. I think the only amateur I grabbed was Gauntlett. It’s hard to judge what the owners 29 owners are looking at, with such a big pool. The depth also plays a large role, as anybody ever listed in a Top 100 or 150 in the past (i.e. Colome) is going to be nabbed very early.

by killa on Aug 8, 2010 11:18 PM EDT up reply actions  

Interest

I don’t know how to contact the original author privately, but what game/program do you use for the Sim? DMB, Strat, etc? Do you have a league site you can post or send to me?

Thanks.

by Sethy on Aug 5, 2010 3:04 PM EDT reply actions  

We use DMB.

You can find some of the details from the fanshot I created earlier. I’m not sure why Toad sounded upset our base rules were framed off of their rules, we have made considerable changes since. DMBO is a great league as well though from everything I have heard. I tried to get a team there myself before deciding to create my own league.

by jfish26101 on Aug 5, 2010 3:07 PM EDT up reply actions  

whoever got Lamb and Cosart are huge winners. i’d take them before a majority of the guys they got taken in front of.

R.I.P. cwhitman412, Frederick0220, & Mets2k9

by doublestix on Aug 5, 2010 3:11 PM EDT reply actions  

I’ve come around on Lamb some but I still am not drinking the kool-aid on Cosart. Besides, I feel DMB sort of screws LHPs because of all the platoons so shy away from them some these days.

by jfish26101 on Aug 5, 2010 3:23 PM EDT up reply actions  

Ha!

Thanks from a fellow Royals fan! The rest of the pick were based on team organization. You can PM me if you want to see how the BNSL Royals look…

by killa on Aug 5, 2010 8:06 PM EDT up reply actions  

Well there are no openings but we keep a waiting list. While you wait, you are welcome to serve as an assistant GM for a team so you can get acclimated to the league and its rules. There are some more details in the fanshot I referenced earlier if you are truly interested. Just take a look and send me an e-mail.

by jfish26101 on Aug 5, 2010 5:32 PM EDT up reply actions  

We break all 30 teams into 6 tiers based on the previous years base payroll (we call it base revenue but it is essentially your cap minus the revenue sharing you received). Each tier gets 5% more than the previous so the poorest teams get the most RS, and the tiers actually change as their base revenue increases/decreases (your base revenue increases based on your team’s performance).

On the other end, I believe every team pays 20% into the RS pool. The smallest tier gets paid 5%, then it scales up from there.

by jfish26101 on Aug 6, 2010 11:00 AM EDT up reply actions  

Nice Depth

I commish a 26-team strat league, and we have prospect rosters 45-deep. These picks pretty much reflected our most recent draft.

by TMcD on Aug 6, 2010 12:10 PM EDT reply actions  

From a KC Perspective

Guys I liked that went (closely) before my picks:

2.15-Yordy Cabrera-Strictly because I had no Org. 3B other than Moustakas, and I think he’ll hit. (Took Velazquez @ 2.19)

3.22-Yorman Rodriguez- Had him at maybe a 55-45 edge over Rafael Rodriguez (stats since probably widen that gap), but this pick forced my hand with Rafael at 4.01.

4.30 Trayvon Robinson- Had I thought he’d be taken, I would have selected him over Robinson Lopez in 3rd Rd. Gamble didn’t pay off. Eldemire has long been a favorite, and didn’t want to lose another guy I had my sights set on.

7.04-Jacob Petricka-Like the progress his velocity made at end of season, which has also been evident in pro results (despite ARL). Went with organizational depth with Mycal Jones, who provides insurance for Grant Green, Brandon Crawford, and Gustavo Pierre at an important position.

by killa on Aug 8, 2010 11:30 PM EDT reply actions  

From a TB perspective, within 10 picks of mine:

Josh Sale at 1.21
Adrian Salcedo at 2.24

Pretty much from that point on, draft went really well for me. Because of those two picks though, I pushed O’Connor/Ramirez up. There were a few guys I had in front of Ramirez/Archer that went more than 10 picks before me but if I could have gotten those two guys and still nabbed Ramirez/Archer I would have been absolutely ecstatic with my draft.

by jfish26101 on Aug 8, 2010 11:51 PM EDT reply actions  

I guess I should also add I was hoping Taillon fell. I’m still happy with Colome’s potential but I liked Taillon more.

by jfish26101 on Aug 8, 2010 11:54 PM EDT reply actions  

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

Minor League Ball: Where the Future of Baseball is Discussed

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recommended FanPosts

Small
Minor League Ball Gameday, 5/25 MILB
Me_at_8_small
Minor League Ball Gameday Discussion, MiLB 5/24
Me_at_8_small
Today in Minor League Baseball Discussion, MiLB 5/23
Me_at_8_small
MiLB 5/22
Me_at_8_small
MiLB 5/21

Recent FanPosts

Small
Washington Nationals MOD 3
Xander_small
Red Sox MOD: Draft Room
Small
Padres MOD #4 (Final MOD)
Henrik-lundqvist-crossed-pads_small
MOD: Mets #6 (2012 Review)
Small
Good luck everyone.....
Small
Toronto Blue Jays MOD #6
Timmyace_small
MLB Mock Draft Round 1, 1s, 2, 3
Small
MOD#6 - Rangers (2nd Round - 93rd Pick)
Molina_small
Cardinals MOD #3

+ New FanPost All FanPosts >

Yahoo_full_count

Managers

March2111_084_small John Sickels

Jeri_avatar_small mssickels

Editors

Small Craig Goldstein

Authors

Headshot_small dougdirt

Mblpglogo_small Matt Garrioch

Small SethSpeaks

Osnation2_small Jordan Tuwiner

Img00006-20101226-1702_small Ray Guilfoyle

Lax-xl_small Marisa Ingemi

Small Marc Hulet

Moderators

Small mrkupe


Site Meter