Community Mock Draft Commentary: NL East
Community Mock Draft Commentary: National League East
ATLANTA BRAVES
1S) Seth Blair, RHP, Arizona State University
2) Drew Vettleson, OF-P, Central Kitsap HS, Tracyton, Washington
2) Derek Dietrich, SS, Georgia Tech
3) Sam Dyson, RHP, University of South Carolina
COMMENT: The Braves scored with Mike Minor last year, and taking another college arm seems plausible. I think Blair is actually a bit underrated by some people and could be a steal in the supplemental round. Vettleson has a highly promising bat, while Dietrich and Dyson are college players from the Southeast, fitting well with Atlanta's general desire to get talent from that part of the country. Dietrich is a good choice in the second round. Dyson's injury history is frightening, but in the third round it could be a decent risk.
FLORIDA MARLINS
1) A.J. Cole, RHP, Oviedo HS, Winter Springs, Florida
2) Dom Ficociello, 3B, Fullerton Union HS, California
3) Gabe Encinas, RHP, St. Paul HS, Santa Fe Springs, California
COMMENT: Cole is too perfect a fit for the Marlins to pass up: a home state high schooler with outstanding projection. He won't be cheap, but I would hope he'd sign for first round money. Ficociello has enormous raw power but is still developing physically; he does seem like a possible Marlins draft. Gabe Encinas throws strikes with decent stuff but has some remaining projection. He might be a signability risk, but overall this draft fits the Marlins pattern.
NEW YORK METS
1) Drew Pomeranz, LHP, University of Mississippi
3) Kris Bryant, 3B, Bonanza HS, Las Vegas
COMMENT: Hard to make a huge splash with just two picks, but the unexpected drafting of Castellanos by the Indians plopped Pomeranz into the Mets' lap. If that happened in real life, they would be ecstatic. Bryant has the raw power to entice scouts, but he's raw enough to slip to the third round in real life. With no second round pick, the money saved could go to keeping him away from college at San Diego.
PHILADELPHIA PHILLIES
1) Cam Bedrosian, RHP, East Coweta HS, Senoia, Georgia
2) Kendrick Perkins, OF, LaPorta HS, Texas
3) Eddie Rosario, OF, Rafael Lopez Ladron HS, Puerto Rico
COMMENT: Bedrosian could go anywhere from this spot to the second round, but I like him and don't think this is horribly out of place. The Phillies director disappeared after this, so I drafted uber-toolsy Perkins to fit the regular Phillies pattern. Rosario is a personal favorite: his bat is quite polished for a high school guy, although he might not be as toolsy as the Phillies prefer, I thought he was a guy that deserved some attention.
WASHINGTON NATIONALS
1) Bryce Harper, C, College of Southern Nevada
2) Addison Reed, RHP, San Diego State University
3) Zach Cates, RHP, Northeast Texas Junior College
COMMENT: I drafted for the Nationals. Harper is the no-brain first pick. I called him as a catcher, but I agree with Scott Boras that he should play outfield as a pro. In the second round I went with a safe, polished, affordable college arm in Addison Reed. Partly that is due to the money it would take to sign Harper, but I do like Reed and think he could move quickly. Cates is one of the best JC arms out there and I couldn't pass him up in the third. Hopefully he would sign for slot money or a tad higher.
12 comments
|
0 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
As a Braves fan, I'd be pissed with that draft!
And if anyone think the Braves aren’t going to draft out of their back yard(i.e. Golden, Clarke, Bedrosian, Smelter, etc.) are fooling themselves.
Im really excited for Vettleson
He is the best player since Aaron Sele to come out of the area. If he could become that JD Drew/Andrer Eithier kind of player would be very special.
5 MORE YEARS OF FELIX!
by Marinerfanjake on Jun 6, 2010 1:51 PM EDT up reply actions
wah wah wah
They had one pick out of four I didn’t like. Blair and Vettleson both really nice picks. Dietrich was a very solid selection and makes a lot of sense as a Georgia guy. I would have looked elsewhere for round 3, but that’s more due to Dyson’s injury history than his arm.
Braves draft
Bedrosian was gone before the Braves even picked. Golden and Clarke were under consideration but Blair and Vettleson were too much of values to pass up, I am really high on Vettleson. Smetler was actually at the top of the queue for the pick that ended up being Dietrich then Detroit swooped in and took him. Dyson was admittedly a fallback after a number of players got taken ahead of that pick, including JuCo pitchers Cates and Smith and HS RHP Rowland. Also under consideration were HS 3B Chad Lewis (taken in the unofficial 4th Round) and HS RHP Eric Jaffe. Both Dietrich and Dyson are from the area
1 MI
of the first four picks? Sorry, but the Braves aren’t lacking in arms. While you never draft for need, you need to ADDRESS your needs better than this mock.
by apoxonbothyourhouses on Jun 7, 2010 12:05 AM EDT up reply actions
this is an awfully weak draft for MI
that is really what the problem was there. In hindsight Yordy Cabrera might have worked as the Supplemental First, but I thought Blair was a much better player as I have my doubts whether Cabrera will ever put his tools together. Andrelton Simmons was under consideration in Round 3, but Milwaukee took him
Quick question John
What are your thoughts on Jimmy Nelson for Alabama? I haven’t heard a lot of talk about him, but there are whispers that the Braves could be considering him as early as their supplemental 1st round pick. I get the sense that it would be a big overdraft, but does he at least have the ability to pull a Mike Minor and prove the skeptics wrong?
nelson
I think he’s more of a late second rounder, but the Braves have a lot more information than I do.
by John Sickels on Jun 6, 2010 12:48 PM EDT up reply actions
Thanks
I was hoping he was at least that level of prospect, though not seeing him picked at all in the community mock had me a bit worried. I like the current velocity and the big frame, but his command and control certainly leave something to be desired. I’m hoping the Braves see a slight mechanical tweak that could make a difference in command, which was the first thing I saw with Minor and his velocity (his timing always seemed off in the draft videos I saw), but I’m getting ahead of myself now.
As always, thanks for the good work.
Marlins
I’ll admit to getting a little gummed up on the Marlins draft. I thought Smelter would fall to me at pick 73 (he nearly did), then wanted Grimm, Biddle, Gibson, or Jones to fall at 103, but all were taken shortly before.
I think any of those four might have been a better fit for the marlins in round 2, but misjudged that they’d all come off the board before the round 3 pick.
In reality, I think the MLB teams pull from so much more original info that there are many more surprises in rounds 2 and 3, and so a lot of these same guys we keep rehashing will last a little longer.
"In the event of a significant release of oil, an accurate estimation of the spill's total volume . . . is essential in providing preliminary data to plan and initiate cleanup operations." - Page 2 of British Petroleum's regional plan for dealing with offshore oil leaks.
I'm happy with what I pulled yesterday for the Mets
The combo of Pom and Bryant really seems to be the max value we could have gotten from the two picks. Some have discussed Bryant as a first round talent, whose only thing working against him, other than his expected rawness, is his signability. I think that as long as he’s taken within the first three rounds, and his bonus demands aren’t too crazy, he could fit into our budget. Also, as I indicated, with his strong arm and fairly good athleticism, I would shift him over to right field, and begin his developmental track there.
As for Pomeranz, I wasn’t about to look a gift horse in the mouth. Some believe that Sale will be a more successful player, but I have Pom ahead of him, and I actually think that at the end of the day, Sale winds up as a power bullpen arm. Additionally, as a college pitcher, I feel like the Mets would be much more willing to stomach his bonus.
If I was to give each of these guys a grade, John style, with a comment, they’d look like this:
Drew Pomeranz (B): Should be expected to put up dominant numbers wherever the Mets start him. Given the Mets’ aggressive philosophy when developing prospects, if Pomeranz puts up the kinds of numbers I expect him to, we could be looking at a B+/A- prospect come next year.
Kris Bryant (C+): Tremendous power potential, and upside to go along with it. Will have to adjust to playing Right Field, but could very well skyrocket up this list if things fall his way.
You’re name has 2k9 in it — what are you some 8 year-old who makes Pillsbury Doughboy cookies and jerks off to that bullshit video game with Tim Lincecum on the cover--
Frederick0220
Man, the Nats love those SDSU RHP's
Proud father of Mike Krukow (who is more than 3 times my age)
Grab Some Pine, Meat
Still cheering for Kevin Frandsen
John Bowker: One of the 3 best OF's on the Giants roster

by 
















