New York Mets MOD #1 (5/15/10)

Looking Back

2006 Draft: $2.5 Million Budget

1. Kevin Mulvey, RHP, Villanova, #62 Overall: Mulvey had average or better stuff across the board at the end of his career at Villanova. He was supposed to be drafted in either the late first round or the supplemental first round, so the Mets got a steal here of a quality college pitcher. Following players selected: Tom Hickman, Joe Benson, Drew Carpenter. Signing bonus: $585,000.
2. Joe Smith, RHP, Wright State, #94 Overall: Smith was a collegiate sidearmer who had less of a pedigree than most major college prospects. He had to walk on at Wright State to even get on the roster. However, he worked with a solid set of pitches, and he was expected go around here, the third round. Following players selected: Scott Cousins, Tyler Robertson, Jason Donald. Signing bonus: $410,000.
3. John Holdzkom, RHP, Salt Lake CC (UT), #124 Overall: Holdzkom was pretty much the definition of what many term bad makeup. He missed most of his senior draft season in high school due to academic ineligibility, then was kicked off the team at Salt Lake by his coach. He had great stuff, and a huge frame at 6’7’’, but no one knew where he’d go, since they couldn’t get a good read on him. Following players selected: Hector Correa, Garrett Olson, D’Arby Myers. Signing bonus: $210,000.
4. Stephen Holmes, RHP, Rhode Island, #154 Overall: Holmes was a college starter with fringe-average stuff, but above-average command of a fringy fastball. He profiled best as a swing man in the pros, or perhaps a middle reliever, though he was expected to go in the fourth to sixth round, in this range. Following players selected: Chris Hatcher, Devin Shepherd, Quintin Berry. Signing bonus: $168,000.
5. Scott Schafer, RHP, Memorial HS (TX), #184 Overall: Schafer was a stereotypical prep arm, with fine stuff but little refinement. He was really expected to bypass signing, as he was projected as a possible pick in the teens. The Mets jumped on him much earlier than was expected. Following players selected: Justin Jacobs, Jeff Christy, Dan Brauer. Signing bonus: $140,000.
Other Notable Selections: RHP Tobi Stoner (16th), Davis & Elkins College (WV)

2007 Draft: $3.8 Million Budget

1. Eddie Kunz, RHP, Oregon State, #42 Overall: Kunz was a wildly successful college reliever at Oregon State, and he was one of the top relievers in the 2007 draft class. He was expected to be able to close and move quickly in the pros as an early first day pick. Following players selected: Jackson Williams, Neil Ramirez, Justin Jackson. Signing bonus: $720,000.
2. Nathan Vineyard, LHP, Woodland HS (GA), #47 Overall: This was the ceiling of where Vineyard was expected to go as a projectable prep lefty. He threw an average fastball and above-average slider, though some, including the Mets, believed he’d add velocity as he filled out his frame. Following players selected: Josh Donaldson, Michael Burgess, Wes Roemer. Signing bonus: $657,000.
3. Scott Moviel, RHP, St. Edward HS (OH), #77 Overall: Moviel was a huge pitcher, standing at 6’10’’. His prospect status was actually beyond his height, as he had an average fastball and fringe-average curve. He was expected to go from rounds two to four, so this was a solid second-round pick. Following players selected: Freddie Freeman, Zack Cozart, Matt West. Signing bonus: $414,000.
4. Brant Rustich, RHP, UCLA, #93 Overall: Rustich was the Mets’ second second-round pick of the 2007 draft. Another college reliever, Rustich was much less successful than Kunz, mainly due to minus command. He had plus to plus-plus stuff and he was expected to go in the second to fourth round. Following players selected: Austin Romine, Nick Barnese, Danny Duffy. Signing bonus: $373,500.
5. Eric Niesen, LHP, Wake Forest, #99 Overall: Niesen was another college reliever, and he had similar command struggles that Rustich had at UCLA. However, Niesen did have plus stuff from the left side, and he was expected to go in the fifth to ninth round, but the Mets preferred him earlier on. Following players selected: Steven Souza, Jonathon Lucroy, Lars Davis. Signing bonus: $351,000.
Other Notable Selections: RHP Dillon Gee (21st), UT-Arlington

2008 Draft: $6.5 Million Budget

1. Ike Davis, 1B, Arizona State, #18 Overall: Davis was the first of the Mets’ two 2008 first-rounders, and he was expected to be a solid first-round prospect. His value was completely in his bat, and he was expected to be a middle of the order force. This was a solid pick. Following players selected: Andrew Cashner, Josh Fields, Ryan Perry. Signing bonus: $1,575,000.
2. Reese Havens, SS, South Carolina, #22 Overall: Havens was perhaps more well-known as Justin Smoak’s teammate in 2008, but he was a first-round talent in his own way. He didn’t really have any plus tools, as there were even some questions about his hit tool, but he was widely considered to be better than the sum of his tools. Following players selected: Allan Dykstra, Anthony Hewitt, Christian Friedrich. Signing bonus: $1,419,000.
3. Brad Holt, RHP, UNC Wilmington, #33 Overall: Holt had big stuff and a big pro body, and many teams considered his pure arm a first-round talent. However, he never showed an ability to command a secondary pitch, and some teams saw him as a future closer rather than a starter. He was expected to go in the second to fourth round. Following players selected: Zach Collier, Evan Frederickson, Mike Montgomery. Signing bonus: $1,040,000.
4. Javier Rodriguez, OF, Puerto Rico Baseball Academy, #68 Overall: Rodriguez was a solid all-around talent who really came just short of being a five-tool player. His best attribute was a hit tool rated as above-average to plus. He was expected to go anywhere from the second to fifth round. Following players selected: James Darnell, Zeke Spruill, Jason Knapp. Signing bonus: $585,000.
5. Kirk Nieuwenhuis, OF, Azusa Pacific (CA), #100 Overall: Nieuwenhuis was a surprise pick in the third round by the Mets. Featuring a solid arm and solid hit tool, Nieuwenhuis wasn’t expected to be a first day pick, which was six rounds back in the day. It’s an interesting pick, though they might have been able to get him later. Following players selected: Blake Tekotte, Vance Worley, Aaron Weatherford. Signing bonus: $360,000.
Other Notable Selections: RHP Kyle Allen (24th), Pendleton School (FL), $150K bonus

2009 Draft: $3.1 Million Budget

1. Steve Matz, LHP, Melville HS (NY), #72 Overall: Matz was considered a unanimous first-day talent, and the Mets got him in the late second round. He had a projectable body coming from the left side, and a good fastball-changeup combination, though he hadn’t settled on a breaking ball. This was a solid pick, though it came with the inherent risk in cold-weather prep pitchers. Following players selected: Max Walla, Cameron Garfield, Kelly Dugan. Signing bonus: $895,000.
2. Robbie Shields, SS, Florida Southern, #103 Overall: Shields was fairly new to the prospect scene, having only gained national prominence after a good short stint on the Cape before his junior year. He showed good overall tools, though none rated as plus. Unfortunately, he went down with Tommy John surgery following signing. Following players selected: Jake Marisnick, Josh Prince, Kyrell Hudson. Signing bonus: $315,000.
3. Darrell Ceciliani, OF, Columbia Basin CC (WA), #134 Overall: Ceciliani was a solid junior college athlete, yet his bat was probably the least advanced of his tools. Considered a possible above-average center fielder, he was expected to go a few rounds later. Following players selected: Adam Warren, Brooks Hall, Adam Buschini. Signing bonus: $204,300.
4. Damien Magnifico, RHP, North Mesquite HS (TX), #164 Overall: Magnifico showcased a plus fastball as a prep, though he was widely considered too raw to move quickly through a minor league system. However, the Mets didn’t want to pay his high asking price, and he headed for JuCo ball at Howard JC. Following players selected: Caleb Cotham, D’Vontrey Richardson, Matt Way. DID NOT SIGN.
5. David Buchanan, RHP, Chipola JC (FL), #194 Overall: Buchanan was a solid pro prospect with a big arm and minus command. There were major worries about his delivery, and some thought he’d be prone to injury or forced to relieve. He didn’t sign as a sixth round pick and headed to Georgia State. Following players selected: Rob Lyerly, Hiram Burgos, Steven Inch. DID NOT SIGN.
Other Notable Selections: LHP Zach Dotson (13th), Effingham County HS (GA), $500K bonus

But I can see the Mets not wanting to pay a top prep pitcher.