I think both have ceilings of #1 lefty starters; both are very young, great stuff, and get a lot of k’s and don’t give up hits. Moore needs to get his control down some more, but that can develop; what can’t be developed is the ability to miss so many bats. I am totally in love, though, with just about every pitcher in the top ten, and think all of them have top of the rotation potential. I have the most doubts about Beckham and Flores, actually, in terms of fulfilling their potential.

He’s a reliever now, right? I don’t know if he’s got the same stuff as, say, Kimbrel, who just barely squeaked on for me. But I do think the ‘big three’ starters on that club (Familia, Allen, Carson) and Beaulac will be contributing to the Mets in a few years; people just haven’t paid much attention to these guys yet. If he stays a starter, I’m not sure if I’d put him over Carson, who is a ground ball machine, or Marte, who is a bit of a toolshed and a potential defensive ace in center.

Leaving him off isn’t that ridiculous, he’s a little old to be considered a top prospect in that league. His numbers are very good, but what separates him from Dexter Carter and guys like that?

How about Christian Friedrich, Trevor May, Dimaster Delgado, Adam Milligan, Ryan Lavarnway, Anthony Gose, Jose Pirela, and Corban Joseph.

I’m trying to hit the guys that passed through the league, not just the ones currently in it. Mostly to compare and contrast guys at similar stages of development.

Probably Perez for me, with Kelly-Moore-Friedrich close behind him.

Like I said, I put it together in like 30 minutes. It’s a good way to get corrected on outdated impressions, and get better info from those closely following a system.

This list is basically my ranking of how I’d value these guys for my own team.

Skipworth and Collier are on strictly because of their tools and ceilings; I think they could be the players they appeared to be when drafted, but it’ll take longer than originally thought. As long as the potential’s still there, I’ll keep some hope. I’d trade three Dexter Carters for one Skipworth or Collier, just on potential.

Seaton has pitched well statistically, but I haven’t read a scouting report where he’s been impressive, or dominating, all year long. His k rate is notably low, and I haven’t heard reports of a plus or out pitch. Going up the ladder against more advanced hitters, he’s going to have to miss more bats to put up his numbers, and right now I don’t know how he’s going to do that.

Carter has pitched well, but he looks like a middlish reliever to every scout I’ve read. He’s older and more polished than most, and the league isn’t exactly stacked with impressive lineups. I don’t want to put a guy on just because he’s pitched well, as some kind of reward, when his stuff doesn’t look to play that great going forward. I guess that’s one beef I have w/ one of John’s tendencies, to seemingly reward strong years with B/B- grades, when the guy is too old, or doesn’t show the tools to play on the big stage.

Kimbrel looks like a potential closer to me, but I would love to hear a report from someone who follows that system more closely.

Naropean, or another Rangers follower, can address Ramirez/Font better than I can. But, again, for myself, I’ll take stuff over current performance (w/o the stuff) any time.

My own strategy, in my dynasty DMB leagues, is to acquire as much young, high-reward/risk guys as possible, and then try to winnow down to the keepers.

He was little.

What’s his outlook now?

I haven’t read all of your scouting reports, but I read quite a few while compiling the list.

Do you have a read on Adam Milligan? He is suddenly very intriguing to me.