I was going to do a Prospect Retro on Curt Schilling, but it turns out I already did.
Normally my memory about those things is really good, but apparently I need to actually run the search engine on that now. . .we've done a lot of retros over the past few years.
Anyway, Curt is officially retired now. There has been some wondering about if he's Hall of Fame Caliber or not. 216-146, .597, 3.46 ERA with 127 ERA+, 3116 strikeouts. . .certainly people have gotten into the Hall with less. His Top 10 Sim Scores:
Drysdale, Vance, and Hunter made it in, and Smoltz will be a candidate.
Black Ink Test: 42 (Average HOFer=40)
Gray Ink Test: 205 (Average HOFer=185)
Hall of Fame Monitor 171 (Likely HOFer=100)
Hall of Fame Standards 46 (Average HOFer=50)
My guess is that he'll get in, but probably not on the first ballot. I don't have a problem with that.