Who do you think in the long should turn out to be the better overall player (all attributes included, defense etc.), Joey Votto or Chris Davis? Both of these players have big upside, Davis has the obvious power edge, but Votto has plate discipline and a decent amount of speed. Defensively, I give Votto the edge at 1B. Davis also plays pretty poor 3B and Votto can also play a corner outfield position. Everything I have read ranks them pretty evenly, with Davis catching up to Votto's status over the last few years.