I did enjoy the smackdowns... but I think it'd be cool to include more than just a couple names.
My "top" tier is Posey, Montero, Santana, Norris, and Flowers. So I'm including the next 10 names at the C spot. Fact-based discussion strongly encouraged.
My 2010 Top 100 list is almost done, but I have to admit that catcher is the hardest to gauge, so I look forward to seeing the results/discussions out of this one.
I think the next tier looks something like this:
Jason Castro - HOU
Hank Conger - LAA
Josh Thole - NYM
Wil Myers - KC
Austin Romine - NYY
Christian Bethancourt - ATL
Tony Sanchez - PIT
Alex Avila - DET
Wilson Ramos - MIN
Travis D'Arnaud - PHI
5 of these are currently in the 70-100 of my list... 2 others were on there but I have since knocked them out. Ramos seems over-rated to me.
I thought about including a poll, but I'd rather just see everyone post their own rankings. I'll post mine later