Detroit Tigers Top 20 Prospects in Review
This list was originally posted December 10th, 2007. THIS IS NOT A NEW LIST!!!! THIS IS A REVIEW OF AN OLD LIST AND OLD GRADES!!!!!!!!!!!!
1) Rick Porcello, RHP, Grade B+
2.84 ERA with 66/30 K/BB in 114 innings, 107 hits for Lakeland in the Florida State League. I don't like the low K-rate but he gets lots of grounders and is young for the level, so he gets some slack on that for now.
2) Jeff Larish, 1B, Grade B-
.269/.361/.540 for Triple-A Toledo, .245/.327/.408 for Detroit. Will hit homers and draw walks, won't hit for average.
3) Danny Worth, SS, Grade B-
.254/.331/.386 for Double-A Erie. I tihnk he's capable of better. Currently on the DL at Triple-A Toledo.
4) Yorman Bazardo, RHP, Grade C+
6.42 ERA with 66/36 K/BB in 102 innings, 132 hits for Toledo. Obviously terrible. Ground ball tendency not enough to save him.
5) Michael Hollimon, INF, Grade C+
.223/.308/.465 for Toledo, .261/.280/.565 in 11 major league games. Has power and draws walks, strikes out so much that batting average and OBP are problems.
6) Charlie Furbush, LHP, Grade C+
Hasn't pitched this year due to Tommy John.
7) Brandon Hamilton, RHP, Grade C+
5.01 ERA with 22/28 K/BB in 32 innings in the Midwest League. Now in the GCL, 1.67 ERA with 24/7 K/BB in 27 innings is much better. Good long-term potential but a long way off.
8) Duane Below, LHP, Grade C+
4.06 ERA with 105/55 K/BB in 113 innings, 115 hits allowed for Lakeland. Doing OK, command needs to be improved.
9) James Skelton, C, Grade C+
.305/.467/.405 with 14 steals for Lakeland, just promoted to Erie where he is 3-for-13 so far. Draws lots of walks, unusual speed for a catcher, no power.
10) Casey Crosby, LHP, Grade C+
Rehabbing from Tommy John.
11) Diek Scram, OF, Grade C+
.249/.336/.389 with 13 steals for Erie. Could be a fourth outfielder if he can boost the hitting more.
12) Scott Sizemore, 2B, Grade C+
.286/.365/.409 with 14 steals for Lakeland, has been on the DL since early June with broken hamate.
13) Francisco Cruceta, RHP, Grade C
2.90 ERA with 43/16 K/BB in 31 innings for Toledo, 5.40 ERA with 11/10 K/BB in 12 innings for the Tigers. He's always had the stuff, needs the command to go with it.
14) Jordan Tata, RHP, Grade C
10.31 ERA with 16/23 K/BB in 18 innings for Lakeland. Made six starts in the GCL, with 2.83 ERA but 18/18 K/BB in 29 innings. Horrendous command this year.
15) Clay Rapada, LHP, Grade C
2.96 ERA with 33/13 K/BB in 24 innings for Toledo, 4.30 ERA with 12/7 K/BB in 15 innings for the Tigers. LOOGY.
16) Cale Iorg, SS, Grade C
.257/.331/.401 with 18 steals for Lakeland. Poor plate discipline with 29 walks but 96 strikeouts in 327 at-bats.
17) Brett Jensen, RHP, Grade C
4.00 ERA with 6/1 K/BB in 9 innings for Erie. On DL since May.
18) Clete Thomas, OF, Grade C
.259/.336/.436 with 22 steals for Toledo, .284/.366/.405 in 40 games for the Tigers. Looks like he can be a useful player but not a star.
19) Brent Clevlen, OF, Grade C
.297/.383/.542 for Toledo. Clevlen needs to decide if he sucks or not. He's been horrible some years and really good other years. Back on the good track now. Can he stay there? I have no clue.
20) Noah Krol, RHP, Grade C
4.20 ERA with 41/26 K/BB in 41 innings, 11 saves, 31 hits allowed for West Michigan. Eh....gets grounders but needs better command.
Not an impressive system. Aside from Porcello, there is not much to get excited about here as trades ripped the guts out of the system over the past two years. They really need to hope the 2008 draft helps things out.
7 comments
|
0 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
Jonathan Kibler
Any thoughts on Jonathan Kibler? I’m not sure his story, but he’s a a Mich State grad who is dominating lo-A. Granted, you’d hope that a college guy can, but his numbers are pretty good 1.66 ERA in 135 ip. Striking out about 20% while walking 5% and his GB% is a really high 61%
The Dodgers won't win a playoff series until the Cool-a-Coo returns.
Matt Joyce
would probably be considered the 2nd best prospect today. Was in 2006 in low A, made jump to AA in 2007, struggling in first half before playing well 2nd half and getting hopes up. .270/.352/.550 in 56 AAA games this year, .275/.338/.585 in 142 ABs in the bigs. 23 years old, as a Tigers fan he reminds me of Granderson in 2005, a wiry kind of guy who can kill the fastball and has opposite field power that you wouldn’t think he would have. He seems to be showing some improvement hitting the offspeed but still has a ways to go.
God
I hope he turns into Granderson. I’ve been pretty impressed with what I’ve seen in Joyce this year, but I’m not sure if it’s something he can maintain.
joyce
i kind of like Joyce at this point. I did not put him on this list, HOWEVER he was listed in the book as a sleeper with a chance to sneak up on us in 2008.
Unfortunately...
...it seems that most of the Tigers prospects whose performance bears notice this season, don’t happen to be on this list. These guys were all mentioned in the organizational rundown, but that’s what these little review sessions are for, right?
Aside from the aforementioned Joyce and Kibler, there is:
Wilkin Ramirez – .297/.365/.522 in AA with 21 steals. He had an awful stint in Toledo and his discipline is poor, but his power/speed combo is intriguing (to me at least).
Casper Wells – .240/.351/.447 with 16 steals in low-A, .278/.364/.556 with 6 steals in AA.
Ryan Strieby – .273/.352/.544 in high-A Lakeland. On fire of late, up to 27 bombs now.
Dusty Ryan – .259/.341/.494 primarily in AA. Nothing too special, but he’s a Catcher.
Plate discipline seems to be a system-wide issue, but guys like Skelton and Justin Henry seem to have sharp batting eyes.
As far as pitching, there are a few Latin players who have had good years.
Alfredo Figaro – 2.45 with 101/34 K/BB in 132.1 IP. Primarily did damage in low-A, and got knocked around in his most recent high-A start, but a good season.
Luis Marte – 3.66 with 67/29 K/BB in 78.2 IP. He was absolutely dominant in Lakeland, and had an outstanding debut in Erie. He got smashed in his second start, then missed two months with an injury, and has had control problems since.
Guillermo Moscoso – 2.17 with 82/14 K/BB in 58 IP. Worked out of the pen a lot earlier, but was bumped up to Erie to start, and struck out 10 in 6 IP, with 3H, 1BB, and 1 unearned run.
I have no scouting pedigree, so maybe all of the hitters are flukes and the pitchers are soft tossers, but at least statistically, the system isn’t quite as barren as it would seem.
I also think Porcello bears further scrutiny. He has pitched very well in Lakeland, getting a ton of groundballs, but the strikeout rate is concerning. Is he really just a future sinkerballer, or is something wrong?
Video of Porcello
I put up a video I took of Porcello from July 4th of this year. It over in the fanpost section but not getting much love.
If anyone has not seen him live here is a little taste,
http://www.minorleagueball.com/2008/7/29/581946/rick-porcello-bull-pen-act
Poe
Oh yeah
I saw that video over on MLive recently…very nice work there, and I appreciate getting a chance to see him throw. It’s hard for me to take much from it though…my eye is not refined enough to glean much unless he’s going against live batters.

by 












