a polished catcher like Posey would be really nice. Snyder wasnt the answer in 2005 and isn’t the answer now. The quicker we get a solid backstop the better we’ll be. I have a feeling Posey will be gone by the time the Dbacks pick.

I also like the idea of a Galloway pick at #32. He has 5 tools and we’d have the elite OF with Young and Upton for the next decade. Power/Speed/defense package that would be unmatched for all three spots. Plus we could afford patience with Galloway as Byrnes (unfortunatey signed for $10/yr) for three years.

We’ve done well with pitching these last few drafts. Scherzer, parker, etc make this not as glaring a need as it is for most clubs. Especially with Webb, Haren, Owings already established for the forseeable future

I disagree with the idea that Catcher should be a priority. Snyder could be upgraded, but Montero was a highly regarded prospect (rated a B+, behind only Upton, Young, and Carlos Gonzalez in our system in 2007 by Sickels) and is off to a solid start this year splitting time behind the plate. He seems likely to be our long term starter there, or at least will get a solid shot. Catcher Ed Easley is also tied as the 2nd highest rated position player in our system according to John’s ‘08 prospect rankings (same C+ rating as 2 other position players) . The highest position player (and 3rd highest overall) is toolsy outfielder Parra. 2nd Base should be a higher priority than catcher or OF, where our only long term option seems to be the solid but not great Callaspo, consistently rated lower than Montero. We have no depth at all at 2B after Callaspo, but have some beyond Montero.
Of course, even with our pitching depth, it’s always good to stay stocked there.