I really found this to be a good read. Im also very surprised the Jeter got as much accolade as he did. Just goes to show that being a good guy and fan favorite can cover up for his defensive prowess .... err lack of. I, like everyone else, was pretty shocked to see Wes Parker named at first base and not Keith "Im a Coke Head" Hernandez. Hernandez was prolly the best fielding firstbaseman Ive ever seen. I also feel that Jim Edmonds in his peak years was probably the best all around defender for outfielders. Some of the balls he got to and plays that he made were just amazing. Its hard to argue him not making the list though with Mays, Clemente and Griffey making it over him. All and all its a good list.
What does everyone else feel about this list?