I play in a 20 team strat-o-matic league (replay) and I project to have the first two picks in the rookie draft next year.  Our rookie list is comprised of all first year players (first year of MLB experience).  I'm targeting the obvious with the first pick (A Gordon) and I'd like a rock solid pitcher with the second pick, someone to anchor my rotation.  Thus I'm targeting Hughes or Gallardo.  I have the BP comparables, but i'm interested in YOUR ideas on comparable pitchers for the two.  Who do you think each pitcher will most likely resemble (style, stats, injury history, MLB value, etc...) over the next 5 years?  I know this is hard, but please ignore fantasy value.

Thanks for your help!