Need Help With NL Prospect Draft

by jnorman76 on Mar 31, 2006 1:04 PM EST

I have my draft coming up on Monday. Where do these guys rank???

I have a list of available players ranked 1-18 (my last pick is 18. Here they are ... help me out!

1    Stephen Drew    ARI
2    Justin Upton    ARI
3    Chris Young    ARI
4    J. S'lamacchia    ATL
5    Ryan Braun    MIL
6    Troy Tulowitski    COL
7    Andy LaRoche    LAD
8    Neil Walker    PIT
9    Elvis Andrus    ATL
10    Anthony Reyes    STL
11    Jason Hirsh    HOU
12    Nelson Cruz    MIL
13    Hunter Pence    HOU
14    Andre Ethier    LAD
15    Eric Patterson    CHC
16    Carlos Gonzales    ARI
17    Matt Kemp    LAD
18    George Kottaras    SDP

Tweet Comment 5 comments | 0 recs |

Do you like this story?

Comments

Upton

I'm a Rays fan and I think Upton is the best prospect in baseball. I'd have him at one. I also like Salty better than Young, but that's based more on scarcity of position, OF is easier to find than a great catcher.

"Chuck Lamar, you're fired"- Stuart Sternburg.

by Tyler on Mar 31, 2006 1:13 PM EST reply actions

Need some info

What is your scoring system, and can you keep these guys for free until they are called up (I assume this is a keeper league)

I'm assuming guys like Ian Stewart and Carlos Quentin are already in systems? Because if not, they look like top 5 guys... Also Chad Billingsley, LAD

I'd move Carlos Gonzalez, ARI way up.. probably to number 8.

I also am not a big fan of Pence, Ethier or Patterson. I'd slot pitcher Cesar Carillo, P, SD above them.

by SLK on Mar 31, 2006 1:20 PM EST reply actions

doubt

salty stays at catcher, similar to Neil Walker in athletic ability, and mc cann will probably stay behind the dish with salty going to the OF or 1b

by SoCalSoxFan on Mar 31, 2006 1:30 PM EST reply actions

my list...

1    Justin Upton    ARI
2    Stephen Drew    ARI
3    Chris Young    ARI
4    Andy LaRoche    LAD
5    J. S'lamacchia    ATL
6    Troy Tulowitski    COL
7    Carlos Gonzales    ARI
8    Ryan Braun    MIL
9    Anthony Reyes    STL
10    Neil Walker    PIT
11    Jason Hirsh    HOU
12    Matt Kemp    LAD
13    Hunter Pence    HOU
14 Elvis Andrus    ATL
15    Nelson Cruz    MIL
16    Andre Ethier    LAD
17    George Kottaras    SDP
18    Eric Patterson    CHC

Could be some changes depending on your organizational draft philosophy (long term value, closest to the majors, etc.), but that is how I would draft them.