I combined the top 50 from here, Baseball Digest Daily, and MiLB.com, weighting each the same. The list comes out as:
- Alex Gordon
- Delmon Young
- Philip Hughes
- Homer Bailey
- Brandon Wood
- Cameron Maybin
- Justin Upton
- Jay Bruce
- Chris Young
- Troy Tulowitzki
- Billy Butler
- Matt Garza
- Andrew McCutchen
- Evan Longoria
- Adam Miller
- Andy LaRoche
- Yovani Gallardo
- Mike Pelfrey
- Carlos Gonzalez
- Reid Brignac
- Scott Elbert
- Andrew Miller
- Ryan Braun
- Jose Tabata
- Tim Lincecum
- Fernando Martinez
- Nick Adenhart
- James Loney
- Luke Hochevar
- Adam Jones
- Clayton Kershaw
- Hunter Pence
- Josh Fields
- Jarrod Saltalamacchia
- Jacoby Ellsbury
- Jeff Clement
- Elijah Dukes
- Felix Pie
- Jason Hirsh
- Ian Stewart
- Colby Rasmus
- Daric Barton
- Chris Iannetta
- Adam Lind
- Joey Votto
- Jeff Niemann
- John Danks
- Erick Aybar
- Chuck Lofgren
- Brandon Erbe
Players in the top 50, which didn't make the combined list:
Community list: 3 (Clement, Aybar, Lofgren)
BDD: 5 (Dukes, Danks, Aybar, Lofgren, Erbe)
MiLB: 7 (Dukes, Rasmus, Iannetta, Lind, Votto, Neimann, Erbe)
Players with highest standard deviation among the lists:
Dukes, Clement, Aybar, Iannetta, Stewart, Fields.
==> I find it interesting that these are also some of the guys closest to being MLB-ready.
Players ranked on all 3 with the biggest high-low difference percentage:
Stewart, Hirsh, Salty, Fields, Barton, Kershaw
Guys the community ranked highly:
Wood, Butler, LaRoche, Lincecum, Hochevar, Dukes