The continuing saga of a member (who shall remain nameless) to try to put Dustin Pedroia atop the list of prospects in the entire league has now reached BJ Upton, who is technically not a prospect, but spent the entire year at AAA last year. For our intents and purposes, we will label him as a prospect.
The poll is, as usual, who will have a better career, BJ Upton or Dustin Pedroia. Now, most people will think this is silly, but I want to see how many people actually think Pedroia will have a better career. For reference, John Sickels lists Pedroia outside of the top 40 hitters, while Upton, if still eligible, I'm sure would reside in the top 10, if not the top 5.